ScoobyNet3! - A new begining!!
28 January 2004, 02:42 PM
#1
Hi All
Taking everyone's suggestions in to account, we've come up with what we consider to be ideal structure for ScoobyNet3!!
We're working really hard behind the scenes getting all of this implimented, so apologies if replies are not instant.
Please post your thoughts, comments and suggestions, and thank you to everyone for such an incredible display of community spirit in the thread discussing these suggestions.
The Concept
A fresh start to ScoobyNet. Give more flexibility and features to the true supportive community members, and even more benefit to ScoobyNetPlus members. Provide an environment to reduce the burden on moderators and re-focus to provide more support to genuine community spirited members. Actively promote the supportive and community spirited nature of this community.
How?
Upgrade forum software to vBulletin.
Provide low cost subscription forums to increase the signal / noise ration for those that place importance on it.
Provide low cost additional forum features to improve the service for those that wish to use them.
Complete moderator procedure review (and ongoing), uncluding heavier moderation of anti-community spirited posts (to be defined).
In relevant subscription forums, allow thread starters to moderate their own threads in order to allow the removal of unwanted / disruptive posts.
Structure
Forum Features (subject to testing and trials)
-Private Messaging
-"Reputation" system to allow members to incrementally vote to increase or decrease a member's "reputation" score.
-Polls
Subscription Forums
ScoobyNetPlus forum - Only available to Plus members.
Non subscribers can read forums, but not post.
Thread starters can moderate own threads.
Scooby Lounge - £5 for 2 months - £15 per year - FOC to Plus members
For relaxed, and friendly chat.
Non subscribers can read forums, but not post.
Thread starters can moderate own threads.
Fight Club - £5 for 2 months - £15 per year - FOC to Plus members
"Take it to Fight Club". For those that want to fight, they can do it in here.
Requirement to view disclaimer prior to entering forum.
Non subscribers can read forums, but not post.
Not included in search engine.
Reduced moderation to only include legal issues.
No advertising / specialised advertising.
Super Muppets Forum!! - FOC to SuperMuppets (see below) - FOC to Plus members
No longer the dumping ground of dodgy or pointless threads. A place for pure muppeting.
Private For Sale Forums - £5 for 1 month - £20 per year - FOC to Plus members
Categorised for sale forums
Non subscriber can view, and reply. Only subscribers can start threads.
Thread starters can moderate own threads.
BTT not allowed - investigating features to ensure this.
Commercial sales not allowed.
Trade Sales Forum - TBA
Subscription Packs
ScoobyNet Plus membership - £25 per anum
All usual benefits (click plus member icon to the left of this post)
Access to all subscriber forums
Additional forum features to include (pending testing and trials)
-File Uploader (Attachments to posts)
-Can download attachments
-Extended private messaging
-Increased "Reputation" power (able to increase or decrease a member's reputation by a slightly greater amount than standard members)
-Switch on or off Google Sponsored links
-Avatars & signatures (make visible or invisible by all members)
-Can delete replies from their own threads
SuperMuppet!! membership - £15 per year (Must have a minimum of 100 posts) - FOC to Plus members
-Super Muppet - User tag
-Access to Super Muppet's forum.
----
I'm sure there will be things that are not clear in this, so please ask away and we'll reply as soon as possible.
Thanks again
Simon, Shaun, and the moderator team.
[Edited by webmaster - 1/28/2004 6:23:34 PM]
Taking everyone's suggestions in to account, we've come up with what we consider to be ideal structure for ScoobyNet3!!
We're working really hard behind the scenes getting all of this implimented, so apologies if replies are not instant.
Please post your thoughts, comments and suggestions, and thank you to everyone for such an incredible display of community spirit in the thread discussing these suggestions.
The Concept
A fresh start to ScoobyNet. Give more flexibility and features to the true supportive community members, and even more benefit to ScoobyNetPlus members. Provide an environment to reduce the burden on moderators and re-focus to provide more support to genuine community spirited members. Actively promote the supportive and community spirited nature of this community.
How?
Upgrade forum software to vBulletin.
Provide low cost subscription forums to increase the signal / noise ration for those that place importance on it.
Provide low cost additional forum features to improve the service for those that wish to use them.
Complete moderator procedure review (and ongoing), uncluding heavier moderation of anti-community spirited posts (to be defined).
In relevant subscription forums, allow thread starters to moderate their own threads in order to allow the removal of unwanted / disruptive posts.
Structure
Forum Features (subject to testing and trials)
-Private Messaging
-"Reputation" system to allow members to incrementally vote to increase or decrease a member's "reputation" score.
-Polls
Subscription Forums
ScoobyNetPlus forum - Only available to Plus members.
Non subscribers can read forums, but not post.
Thread starters can moderate own threads.
Scooby Lounge - £5 for 2 months - £15 per year - FOC to Plus members
For relaxed, and friendly chat.
Non subscribers can read forums, but not post.
Thread starters can moderate own threads.
Fight Club - £5 for 2 months - £15 per year - FOC to Plus members
"Take it to Fight Club". For those that want to fight, they can do it in here.
Requirement to view disclaimer prior to entering forum.
Non subscribers can read forums, but not post.
Not included in search engine.
Reduced moderation to only include legal issues.
No advertising / specialised advertising.
Super Muppets Forum!! - FOC to SuperMuppets (see below) - FOC to Plus members
No longer the dumping ground of dodgy or pointless threads. A place for pure muppeting.
Private For Sale Forums - £5 for 1 month - £20 per year - FOC to Plus members
Categorised for sale forums
Non subscriber can view, and reply. Only subscribers can start threads.
Thread starters can moderate own threads.
BTT not allowed - investigating features to ensure this.
Commercial sales not allowed.
Trade Sales Forum - TBA
Subscription Packs
ScoobyNet Plus membership - £25 per anum
All usual benefits (click plus member icon to the left of this post)
Access to all subscriber forums
Additional forum features to include (pending testing and trials)
-File Uploader (Attachments to posts)
-Can download attachments
-Extended private messaging
-Increased "Reputation" power (able to increase or decrease a member's reputation by a slightly greater amount than standard members)
-Switch on or off Google Sponsored links
-Avatars & signatures (make visible or invisible by all members)
-Can delete replies from their own threads
SuperMuppet!! membership - £15 per year (Must have a minimum of 100 posts) - FOC to Plus members
-Super Muppet - User tag
-Access to Super Muppet's forum.
----
I'm sure there will be things that are not clear in this, so please ask away and we'll reply as soon as possible.
Thanks again
Simon, Shaun, and the moderator team.
[Edited by webmaster - 1/28/2004 6:23:34 PM]
28 January 2004, 02:47 PM
#4
PS. Should make it clear that the above is EXTRA, rather than - in place of. The forums will still be available as they are (with the exception of the for sale forum), but the subscriber forums, etc will be added as extra.
All the best
Simon
All the best
Simon
Trending Topics
28 January 2004, 03:03 PM
#10
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jan 2002
Location: South East London
Posts: 739
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Looks pretty good to me.
My only concern is this bit
Although I absolutely agree with it, I fear the ability to decrease a member's score will have to be closely watched otherwise it may lead to abuse?
Having said that, hopefully the full set of changes will weed out a lot of the less desirables in the first place.
Apologies if this point has been answered or approached elsewhere,
John
My only concern is this bit
"Reputation" system to allow members to incrementally vote to increase or decrease a member's "reputation" score.
Having said that, hopefully the full set of changes will weed out a lot of the less desirables in the first place.
Apologies if this point has been answered or approached elsewhere,
John
28 January 2004, 03:06 PM
#13
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2000
Location: www.mrcookie.co.uk
Posts: 5,757
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Looks good although i have same reservations as josh ref moderating own topics.
Also
Does this mean that if a plus member attaches a picture only other plus members can see them
Si
Ps can i have my ex mod plus member pack now lol
Also
-File Uploader (Attachments to posts)
-Can download attachments
-Can download attachments
Si
Ps can i have my ex mod plus member pack now lol
28 January 2004, 03:31 PM
#18
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2002
Posts: 2,390
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Sounds good Simon . A few questions...
1/ Would SN+ members be able to delete replies from their own threads regardless of which forum that thread was started in (i.e. benign to effect of moving thread between forum)?
2/ I don't know what features the intended uploader has, so this may be a null question. But - some restrictions on the uploader may be desirable. For example, it could be manipulated to - say 'share' copyrighted music files, etc. Do you have details of this?
3/ Will it be possible to ignore particcular users?
4/ Are there proposed features relating to feedback of moderation? Or, is this to be tied to a moderator's user rating?
. A few questions... 1/ Would SN+ members be able to delete replies from their own threads regardless of which forum that thread was started in (i.e. benign to effect of moving thread between forum)?
2/ I don't know what features the intended uploader has, so this may be a null question. But - some restrictions on the uploader may be desirable. For example, it could be manipulated to - say 'share' copyrighted music files, etc. Do you have details of this?
3/ Will it be possible to ignore particcular users?
4/ Are there proposed features relating to feedback of moderation? Or, is this to be tied to a moderator's user rating?
28 January 2004, 03:33 PM
#19
Scooby Senior
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2000
Location: Wildberg, Germany/Reading, UK
Posts: 9,706
Likes: 0
Received 73 Likes
on
54 Posts
Can I have Super Muppet and Plus Member under my username (when you finally get my check) or are we only allowed one or the other?
Looking forward to seeing SN3 keep up the good work chaps.
Looking forward to seeing SN3 keep up the good work chaps.
28 January 2004, 03:39 PM
#20
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Derbyshire
Posts: 4,496
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Simon, Shaun, et al.
On the point of the reputation system, would it be possible to give reasons for the positive/negative rating that a user decides to give another user? A bit like the ebay stuff where you can at least give a reason for the feedback.
I can see, as mentioned previously, that if it's purely a click to increase/decrease then this could be open to abuse, possibly malicious, with no way of tracking how many times one person has increased or decreased a users rating and their reasons for doing so.
On the whole, looks like an interesting new proposition for the next generation of the BBS and a lot of work. I hope it all goes well for everyone concerned in the construction, migration and usage
[Edited by Hanslow - 1/28/2004 3:40:35 PM]
On the point of the reputation system, would it be possible to give reasons for the positive/negative rating that a user decides to give another user? A bit like the ebay stuff where you can at least give a reason for the feedback.
I can see, as mentioned previously, that if it's purely a click to increase/decrease then this could be open to abuse, possibly malicious, with no way of tracking how many times one person has increased or decreased a users rating and their reasons for doing so.
On the whole, looks like an interesting new proposition for the next generation of the BBS and a lot of work. I hope it all goes well for everyone concerned in the construction, migration and usage
[Edited by Hanslow - 1/28/2004 3:40:35 PM]
28 January 2004, 03:51 PM
#22
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Oct 2001
Location: X5 and MCS JCW country....London :)
Posts: 2,223
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Looks Good, time to upgrade to plus then.
Within the for sale forums are we going to have :
Subaru Cars for sale
Subaru Parts for sale
Other cars for sale
Other car parts for sale
Non car related sales
I assume this will give enough scope to reduce BTT and be far more informative to people viewing.
Hope this helps
David
Within the for sale forums are we going to have :
Subaru Cars for sale
Subaru Parts for sale
Other cars for sale
Other car parts for sale
Non car related sales
I assume this will give enough scope to reduce BTT and be far more informative to people viewing.
Hope this helps
David
Just joined!
28 January 2004, 03:52 PM
#24
Hi Guys
Thanks for the GREAT feedback.
Reputation System
A member can increase another member's reputation by 1 point by clicking (will look in to "reasons"), and cannot affect that user's rating until they have rated another 40 members. This means it would be an absolute nightmare to abuse the system, and means that 1 person liking another person, will not be able to show them to be a huge star. We are investigating other restrictions like time until you can rate the same user as well.
Group Buy Section
Understood. We'll try to come up with a solution to this, but it may not be in time for launch as it has commercial complications attached to it.
Moderating Own Topics
Still open to final decision on this one. It will only be the thread starter, and all they can do is delete a post within it. Agreed, potentially open to abuse, but if abused, the feature will be removed for that member, or completely.
In for sale, this is vital IMHO as it will allow users to get rid of the irritating spoilers that have cropped up from time to time.
Plus members will not be able to moderate posts in non-subscriber forums.
Moderator Rating
Possibly with the standard user rating, but people have in the past (possibly not, now we're all focussed on a new start) been more willing to rate things as negative, than positive, so will need thinking about carefully, and will need the support of the people who think the moderators did a good job. Needs more planning, but feedback forum will allow usual discussion, if put forward in a constructive way.
Uploader
Only plus members will be able to upload / download attachments.. this is effectively to pay for the bandwidth. You can still post links, and use the IMG tag to insert images, etc.
Mr.Cookie - of course!! please sign up as normal and send shaun your member number rather than sending a cheque.
Ignore feature. Good point, this will be available to plus members.
SuperMuppet and PlusMember Tags. You can have both
All the best, and thank you once again for all the feedback and support.
Simon, and the team.
Thanks for the GREAT feedback.
Reputation System
A member can increase another member's reputation by 1 point by clicking (will look in to "reasons"), and cannot affect that user's rating until they have rated another 40 members. This means it would be an absolute nightmare to abuse the system, and means that 1 person liking another person, will not be able to show them to be a huge star. We are investigating other restrictions like time until you can rate the same user as well.
Group Buy Section
Understood. We'll try to come up with a solution to this, but it may not be in time for launch as it has commercial complications attached to it.
Moderating Own Topics
Still open to final decision on this one. It will only be the thread starter, and all they can do is delete a post within it. Agreed, potentially open to abuse, but if abused, the feature will be removed for that member, or completely.
In for sale, this is vital IMHO as it will allow users to get rid of the irritating spoilers that have cropped up from time to time.
Plus members will not be able to moderate posts in non-subscriber forums.
Moderator Rating
Possibly with the standard user rating, but people have in the past (possibly not, now we're all focussed on a new start) been more willing to rate things as negative, than positive, so will need thinking about carefully, and will need the support of the people who think the moderators did a good job. Needs more planning, but feedback forum will allow usual discussion, if put forward in a constructive way.
Uploader
Only plus members will be able to upload / download attachments.. this is effectively to pay for the bandwidth. You can still post links, and use the IMG tag to insert images, etc.
Mr.Cookie - of course!! please sign up as normal and send shaun your member number rather than sending a cheque.
Ignore feature. Good point, this will be available to plus members.
SuperMuppet and PlusMember Tags. You can have both
All the best, and thank you once again for all the feedback and support.
Simon, and the team.
28 January 2004, 04:12 PM
#27
What about registration dates?
They were included in the user details a few years back but seem to be missing in the later members details?
Helps to know when high post count whether a long time Scooby enthusiast or Muppet poster when evaluating responses given!
How about free/ discounted Plus membership for those with more than... say 5 years membership
Cheers
Mick
They were included in the user details a few years back but seem to be missing in the later members details?
Helps to know when high post count whether a long time Scooby enthusiast or Muppet poster when evaluating responses given!
How about free/ discounted Plus membership for those with more than... say 5 years membership
Cheers
Mick
28 January 2004, 04:20 PM
#29
"Give more flexibility and features to the true supportive community members"
True supportive community member = anyone willing to contribute to your coffers.
Still it's your site and you shall do what you want with it, but please don't try to cloak what is a blatant commercial venture as an altruistic and community-focussed relaunch.
Good luck
Suresh
True supportive community member = anyone willing to contribute to your coffers.
Still it's your site and you shall do what you want with it, but please don't try to cloak what is a blatant commercial venture as an altruistic and community-focussed relaunch.
Good luck
Suresh
28 January 2004, 04:22 PM
#30
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2002
Posts: 2,390
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Re uploader: agreed, it makes sense that it's only available to SN+ members. But what sort of files may be uploaded? Graphic files, I assume. But what else? What is to stop someone renaming song.mp3 as song.jpg and uploading that for sharing? Or even, renaming VirusLadenSpreadsheet.xls as something else? Of course everyone could see who has uploaded it, but even with the best will in the world, it's possible to distribute malicious files unintentionally.
I presume that there will be specific T&Cs on use of the uploader, but I think you need some technical restrictions as well.
I presume that there will be specific T&Cs on use of the uploader, but I think you need some technical restrictions as well.