Oilburner

I'm going to have a look at a Bug Eye later its very cheap but it was a Cat D write off in 2004 I've already got a few questions to ask the seller (where was the repair work carried out etc) but do you guys think its worth a punt?

prodriverules

iTrader: (52)

Depends on weather the repairs were carried out by an approved garage and were and what damage was caused in the accident really mate.
some times though its the only way for some people to own the car there really after.

my94wrx

iTrader: (4)

yeah i have owned loads of write off's as what you see is what you get, nobody is trying to hide anything from you (well nearly everyone)
as for the car in question, i would want to make sure its been repaired to decent standard, no nasty cut and shuts,ETC the main thing is the price, if the car in question is only say £200 cheaper than a straight one get the straight one, its simple really.

stevie1982

iTrader: (16)

Would not bother if it were me, would rather buy one with no history but that's just me

Hope you get a good deal and you are happy

Oilburner

This one is a 51 plate Bug WRX wagon 61k on clock,full Subaru history in Sonic blue its a fair bit cheaper than all the others I've found with similar miles as its up for £2700

my94wrx

iTrader: (4)

what was the damage, is it really that much cheaper? a chap i know has just chopped his bugeye wagon in for a sti and got £2500 and that had a new engine.

Oilburner

The seller has the repair invoice so I'll have a good look and the closest other one I've found is £3299 for an 02 plate with 95k on clock

Sami_D

iTrader: (1)

Would rather buy a cat d with no repair work done to it - that way you know EXACTLY what you are getting.

5 years ago i brought a bug eye sti from an auction cat d - needed side skirt and a little bit of welding underneath - i knew what needed to be done and could get it sorted myself.

Paid under the odds for the car (at the time) £6900, sold it on last year for £5300 so no major loss - its a gamble but maybe hold out for one where you KNOW excatly what work needs to be done!?

Xs

TheVoices

iTrader: (5)

Someone has one for sale on here for £3600, not listed as a total loss ?

Pay a bit more for one without the 'damaged repaired' status and it will be far easier to re-sell and hold its value better.

£2700 is too dear for a high mileage CAT D bugeye estate, 'listed' cars are normally worth 30-50% less than non-listed !

I work at a Jaguar main dealer and the rough 'rule of thumb' for valuing such vehicles is half of Glasses Guide trade price!

Are you sure it's Sonic Blue, I thought that colour was only available on the classic shape ?

Oilburner

Thanks for the advice and I'm not so sure it is called Sonic blue but its definately the bright blue colour similar to the rally cars (WR Blue?)The guy has had it up for sale for a few weeks now so I'll see how much he'll come down.Parkers say a 51 plate with 90k on the clock is worth £3100

mouse555

iTrader: (1)

I would have thought there were enough about to be able to get yourself sorted with a straight one at a price you want to pay. I would not buy a cat-D because of the potential probs you may have when it comes to selling it.

For a few hundred quid more it could be a better bet.

Oilburner

Scrap that idea!I extended my search a bit and found a straight one for similar money!Its a bit further away so got to see if I can get some time off work to go!

nick172sport

iTrader: (6)

ive seen a wagon on ebay 2200 lady owner high miles though

SRSport

Is "lady driver" actually a good thing?

jayallen

iTrader: (31)

Nope!! My mrs drove my Scoobs harder than i did..

daz_vx220

I paid £4000 for a cat cat d 2004 wagon, only 34k miles with full subaru service history. Had it a couple of months now, mint for that money. Owned several cat c/d cars. Not a problem if you no what your looking at.

f4la k

iTrader: (1)

Cat d is usually not that bad and dont need to be vic checked like the cat c. My mate bough a 58 plate astra vxr 11000 miles for 4.5k. the car had slid down a bankin and was more damaged pullin it out, because the car was under a year old the owner got a new car from the insurance, under £2 fixed it, not inclucing time, and he just sold it for 9k....

gojonnyjo

iTrader: (1)

depends on the damage and how it was repaired,

Terminator X

iTrader: (7)

Cat Ds should be priced 1/3 less than undamaged cars.

I wouldn't buy one myself as usually there are no records of what was damaged with the owner stating it was minor yet the car was amazingly written off by the insurance company Such a scenario sounds fishy to me ...

You'll struggle to sell it on too IMHO as they tend to be frowned upon by most people albeit if you've no plans to sell then it may be OK.

I saw a RS4 for sale recently at £16k (Cat D) which fits description of 2nd para above ... what damage must it have had to write off a £24-26k car

TX.

my94wrx

iTrader: (4)

a cat d write off can be worse then a cat c, either can be written of for as little as a scratch to needing a new front or back or side.

Luminous

iTrader: (3)

I think it depends on who repairs it, and how much information is available.

I've looked at a few recently, but for me I'd happily buy one if its from someone who I trusted. Either that, or I would buy a wreck and get someone who I trusted to fix it.

For example, I know the garage that does the work on my car fixes written off cars. Here is one example:
http://www.johnpyemotors.com/gallery...M3E46/123.html

Last time I popped in there were doing something restoring a mini which seems to be going well:
http://www.johnpyemotors.com/bodywork/body-styling.html

If you can trust the people who do the work, then I'd save the cash

Herbie.

Ive had a Cat D, would never buy another one. Nightmare to try and sell on.

Oilburner

Thanks for your thoughts folksIt does remind me of a mate who had his brand new Rover 75 written off when he bashed the wing in a car park because new parts weren't avaliable anymore

Steve169

shameless self ad buy....

https://www.scoobynet.com/private-fo...ml#post9561706

Thats mine for sale, very tidy.

Abx

iTrader: (15)

Ask to see some photos of damage, may just have been keyed and the respay cost may have made it uneconomical to repair, on the other hand it could have had a major front end and repaired on the cheap.

If its being sold by a dealer, get the former keepers address from the V5 and try and get in touch with them, I did this years ago when looking at a MkV Escort Cab, dealer told me it was written off for a cracked bumber, previous owner was really nice and sent me the pics she took of the car after the accident, needless to say it was a hell of a lot more than new bumper, whole front end so I walked away!!

N_Scooby

iTrader: (2)

If it was damaged in 2004, the car would be less than 3 years old so I would have thought it was a lot of damage to write it off.

gray-efc

look at mine in for sale section its is mint

Oilburner

Sorry mate nice looking car but its got to be a wagon and I've still not shifted my Galaxy yet either!

wylie1

i had a classis wrx then the day after i broght every pannel was keyed so it was a cat d so after a respary it was good as new id definately find out why its a write off in the 1st place

StickyMicky

My current MG is a cat c, never bothered me, because IMO with the car being worth next to **** all anyway, having it worth say one third less of **** all, is still **** all