Boy in court over hoax fire death
22 July 2008, 10:06 AM
#1
Boy in court over hoax fire death
A district judge has criticised sentencing powers which left him unable to jail a youth for making a hoax fire call which led to a woman's death.
Nicola Stacy, 36, died when her car collided with a fire engine in Sheffield. Her 10-year-old daughter is still seriously injured in hospital.
Ian Patterson, 17, told police he made the hoax call for "a laugh".
A judge at Doncaster Youth Court said his powers were limited and handed him an Anti-social Behaviour Order.
The court was told Patterson, of no fixed abode, pleaded guilty to making false reports to South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service on 26, 27 and 29 June.
He made the third call from a mobile phone at 2249 BST and reported that a warehouse was on fire on Old Sheffield Road, Rotherham.
Two engines were deployed and while one arrived to discover it was a false alarm, the other was involved in the fatal collision on Attercliffe Common.
Ms Stacy was declared dead at the scene and her daughter, who was a front-seat passenger, was taken to hospital with life-threatening injuries.
District Judge John Foster said: "As a result of your actions, someone has lost their life and a young child has been seriously hurt. Very seriously hurt.
"What has frankly astonished me is the powers I have to deal with a case of this sort are so limited.
"Parliament has decreed that if you were 18 years of age you could be sent to prison for a maximum of three months only. But you are not 18, you are 17.
"You richly deserve to lose your liberty in my view for a significant period of time but because you are 17 and because the maximum sentence an adult can receive is three months in prison, I cannot sentence you to custody."
Speaking after the sentencing, Mark Shaw, area manager for South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service, said they were disappointed a prison sentence was not an option.
He said that although the force had reduced the number of hoax 999 calls made, they still received an average of two false reports each day.
Very disappointing outcome and what a complete *****
Nicola Stacy, 36, died when her car collided with a fire engine in Sheffield. Her 10-year-old daughter is still seriously injured in hospital.
Ian Patterson, 17, told police he made the hoax call for "a laugh".
A judge at Doncaster Youth Court said his powers were limited and handed him an Anti-social Behaviour Order.
The court was told Patterson, of no fixed abode, pleaded guilty to making false reports to South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service on 26, 27 and 29 June.
He made the third call from a mobile phone at 2249 BST and reported that a warehouse was on fire on Old Sheffield Road, Rotherham.
Two engines were deployed and while one arrived to discover it was a false alarm, the other was involved in the fatal collision on Attercliffe Common.
Ms Stacy was declared dead at the scene and her daughter, who was a front-seat passenger, was taken to hospital with life-threatening injuries.
District Judge John Foster said: "As a result of your actions, someone has lost their life and a young child has been seriously hurt. Very seriously hurt.
"What has frankly astonished me is the powers I have to deal with a case of this sort are so limited.
"Parliament has decreed that if you were 18 years of age you could be sent to prison for a maximum of three months only. But you are not 18, you are 17.
"You richly deserve to lose your liberty in my view for a significant period of time but because you are 17 and because the maximum sentence an adult can receive is three months in prison, I cannot sentence you to custody."
Speaking after the sentencing, Mark Shaw, area manager for South Yorkshire Fire and Rescue Service, said they were disappointed a prison sentence was not an option.
He said that although the force had reduced the number of hoax 999 calls made, they still received an average of two false reports each day.
Very disappointing outcome and what a complete *****
22 July 2008, 10:11 AM
#2
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (5)
Join Date: Sep 2007
Location: Hudds
Posts: 1,788
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
"given a 3 year asbo preventing him causing alarm and a referal order aimed at repairing the harm caused" FFS! Nothing can repair the harm caused but an asbo just adds insult to injury. Was her daughter ok in the end?
22 July 2008, 12:56 PM
#5
yes guys
it was one of our local members who's family was involved in the terrible smash
our thoughts go out to his family at this time!
The lad has been given a pathetic punishment for his actions,a complete joke and just sums up this countrie's excuse of a legal system
Let's all just hope and prey he gets whats coming,i do think they call it "karma"
marcus
it was one of our local members who's family was involved in the terrible smash
our thoughts go out to his family at this time!
The lad has been given a pathetic punishment for his actions,a complete joke and just sums up this countrie's excuse of a legal system
Let's all just hope and prey he gets whats coming,i do think they call it "karma"
marcus
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post