scoobz84

hi

last week my scooby died on me, i have spoke to two garages and both have advised me that it would be cheaper to replace engine rather than strip down replace and rebuild. i dont have much idea on what im doin so i could do with some advise on what engine will fit, where best to get one from and where to get fitted(am i best goin for specialist or would any garage be able to do it). I am in bedfordshire.

I have a W reg turbo 2000 UK, engine code is EJ205NW2KD. ive seen a few engines about but not sure if they will fit as ive been told that some may not fit the gearbox!!

Any advice would be much appreciated as im pretty much in the dark with this! any other information that may be needed to help please ask, i apologise now for my idiocy now

thanks for looking mike

cushti

iTrader: (7)

How did it 'die' - what's the problem, cambelt snapped? Does it still turn over?

happydude303

iTrader: (1)

and a rebuild woudl be better int he long run or a brand new bottom end as if you but a second hand unti you just dont now how long it will last and how it has been treated and igf it goes pop then your back to square one with more labour cost and another second hand engine and as above how did it die

TonyBurns

iTrader: (3)

You would need to fit a like for like engine, ie another MY99/00 engine (phase 2) and not a phase 1 or 1.5 engine.
As above, what happened to the engine? they dont just "die" without a cause, that will leave you where your next course of action is, refurbed/2nd hand engines are a mine field, in most cases your going to end up costing yourself more in the long run so if your engine is still in good internal condition it will be best to have it rebuilt by someone who knows what they are doing

Tony

scoobz84

Basically I was driving at 20mph turning a corner(no heavy driving involved) there was a cracking noise and what sounded like something was dragging. The engine starts but on idol it sounds bad enough, the recovery driver drove it on2 the back of the truck so it drove but the sound was not nice, there was no smoke whatsoever straight after or even now. A mechanic started the engine and told me to turn it off straight away, obviously he couldn't tell what it was without stripping it but could have been a bolt or a bearing had broke/dropped etc. He said it sounds like it's running on 3 cylinders. This is way past my knowdledge of cars so I'm going on what he's told me.

TonyBurns

iTrader: (3)

Oh, could be anything from a bearing to a broken piston will need to be stripped by the sounds, was it a highish mileage car?

Tony

scoobz84

The car has done 79k cam belt was done 4 months ago. I've been quoted by 1 garage £2.5-£3k for a recon engine fitted with 12 months warrenty. Would a rebuild come close or pass that price obviously it's hard to say when not knowing the problem just wondering if u may have had any past experiences!!
Another place is offering a complete recon engine for £1400 then fitting costs on top, really not sure what to do

TonyBurns

iTrader: (3)

Look at someone like API in Coventry, recon engines are a nightmare, warranties on these are as good as toilet paper, or what you put on them!
Atleast with a rebuild you know whats going in there (well with a good engine builder) and some uprated parts wont cost you much more (the uprated x drilled/nitrided crank for instance and acl race bearings plus pistons and rods), better than a recon wreck

Tony

PS, avoid SMR engines at all costs

scoobz84

SMR is the place that offered me the engine for £1400!
Thanks for the advice I'll stay well clear

APIDavid

iTrader: (4)

Scoobz, Call me on 01926 614333 and l'll walk you though the options. A sensible conversation with no obligation to buy from me.

Good luck David APi

01926 614333

Warwick ! Coventry sounds so downmarket Tony

scoobz84

Hi David, just tried ringing but you were busy, I left my number. if you could get back to me when you've got a minute today. it would be much appreciated
thanks Mike Birchall

happydude303

iTrader: (1)

3 grand is enought to forged the engine and if the crank is ok that will be plenty dont recon, forge it, or you can buy a brand new bottom end for 2000 grand and stay away from smr engines speak to api or any other subaru tuner or vene engine tuner he could do you a nice 2.1 stroker for that sort of dollar

APIDavid

iTrader: (4)

Mike I just tried again at 17.03 and your mobile is going straight to message.

I need to get away now. Lets try again after about 09.15 tomorrow,

David

scoobz84

David, sorry my signal is terrible where I am at the minute!! That's fine give me a ring in the morning and we'll talk.

Thanks mike

TonyBurns

iTrader: (3)

Whats wrong with coventry?..... oh wait a minute, was there on a course and we all went for a buffet in the town centre, was kicking off at 7:30pm ok agree with you on that one David Warwick sounds better

Tony

APIDavid

iTrader: (4)

Or even: ROYAL Leamington Spa