scoobywrx320

Hi all,

decision time today, im going to look at a 54 Subaru impreza sti ppp, ecutek remapped etc, gunmetal grey, 59k miles, cambelt changed, fdsh, mint AND a 54 plate clio 182 cup, orange, 49k miles, cambelt changed, fsh, miltek exhaust etc.

Basically im looking a a toy for the weekends etc but cant decide lol.

Help please

#68 rb5

iTrader: (1)

2 very amazing cars, but 2 different leagues of car. Depends what you want from a car I suppose.

scoobywrx320

a great toy for the weekend and something im going to keep for a good few years as my pride and joy really, love both cars but very different type of cars as you said.

#68 rb5

iTrader: (1)

If you want a car for fun driving then clio, if you want a car for fun driving with the added bonus of using it as a modifying project and the feel of a boost of power as you accelerate out of the B road bends then Subaru. Guess what I would choose? Lol

GREGGYG

iTrader: (2)

What do you want from the car, what do you want it to do performance wise?

I've owned 8 Impreza STi's and one Clio 182 Sport to date. I would buy another Impreza tomorrow but never a Clio 182 again for numerous reasons.

Greg

scoobywrx320

i suppose power and handling really, what bhp should a 54 sti with ppp, ecutek remap be pushing bhp?

Aaron1978

iTrader: (12)

320-340ish

Arkynsei

Prolly biased but I'd go for the Impreza. As it's a weekend thing, it wouldn't feel as special if it was a Clio. Not to me anyway. Too much like a daily. And I personally wouldn't get as much satisfaction out of cleaning it, still a Clio at the end of the day!

No one can really decide but you though mate . Just to add to the mix, Scooby will sound better and more tuneable .

Henrik

iTrader: (5)

Personally I'd go 182 cup. Not as fast in a straight line, obviously, but the ones I've seen on track days etc have been real weapons even as standard.

Spend the change on petrol, sticky tyres and some track days

ditchmyster

iTrader: (7)

Clio is a great car BUT it's definitely NOT pride and joy material.

THE END.

Shaks-STI

iTrader: (7)

For weekend toy i would try a classic mate, my choice would be a Type R

thenewgalaxy

I had a Clio 200 Cup a little while back and used it as a daily. Was a great drivers car but I couldn't deal with this one time I was rinsed by a Mondeo Diesel estate on the M6 and I sold it soon after.

Get the Scooby, it is more of a pride and joy machine and something you feel more special in.

topshot

iTrader: (4)

Impreza for me, clio is a good fun car but not in same league and have too many niggly issues for me.

irondrew

iTrader: (1)

Surely asking an impreza forum you knew what answers you'd get!?!?

bill.

i have a 172 cup, bang for buck you cant beat em, for the money they cost to buy and run i cant think of an alternative, mines got bilstein coilovers on and the geometry has been set up, handles superbly, my daily drive on b roads leaves most things scratching there heads wondering why the 172bhp clio has just disappeared into the distance.

As you can tell i love my cup! cant wait to track it, these clio's do very well on track, oh and mines been as reliable as they come, as where my other clio's, ( mk1 1.8 16v & williams ) but when i can afford to run a nice modded blobeye i'll be buying one, if i could afford to keep the clio as a track toy and still get a scooby i would.

As a nice weekend toy i'd get a nice impreza, but don't rule out the clio for a cheap fun car, like i said for the money they are hard to beat i'd be getting a 172 cup and not a 182 cup if you go for a clio ( more special )

scoobywrx320

almost bought one yesterday but it sold an hour before! was a 2005 impreza sti ppp ecutek remap with 60k miles

Still looking if anyone knows of any nice examples....got £8000 to play with

alphaj12

At least you made the right decision, just need to be a bit quicker next time to make sure you get it.

maff125

iTrader: (1)

Ive always had a weekend fun car and it needs to do everything, be fast enough, handle well enough and have that special feeling when you drive it, bit like a motorbike for the road I reckon, and after god knows how many tuned clio 16v's s4's corrado vr6's etc i am am back in a classic impreza, they need sorting on the handling side but when you have a good one, well it's the only car I've ever just gone out for a Sunday drive in, but can't stop thinking of a 5.0 tvr Griffith though?!!

Liam.

I currently own a Clio 182 and a UK Turbo Impreza. The Clio has the edge in the 'fun' factor as it feels like you are throwing a go kart around. However the Impreza corners quicker and pulls harder in every gear. I assume you won't be doing that many miles in the car therefore I'd go with the Impreza.

In saying that the 182 is a great car and I'll definitely own another. Very capable cars.

mantazini

iTrader: (25)

8K will get you a souped up type r or P1 with rebuilt engine , 6 speeder maybe sorted suspension etc, etc... If it aint your daily, classic would be as fun as a clio but with way more capabilities ... 400 bhp classic feels like rocketship , cant beat that feeling...

scoobywrx320

I will wait patiently now for the right car to come along

BadBadLeeroyBrown

Always this option ..... a Subareno Cliopreza Rs172 Type R

https://www.facebook.com/#!/Gould.Clio?fref=ts

big_joe

iTrader: (1)

The Clio is a fun hatch with good handling and a nippy engine........but is just a FWD French hatchback at the end of the day. Not something I'd consider special enough to warrant being a weekend toy in my opinion....fun daily at best. Comparing it with an STI is just silly