What gives better performance, panel filter or induction kit?
#1
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: In your MOMMA!!!!
Posts: 1,211
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
What gives better performance, panel filter or induction kit?
I've an 51 plate JDM STI which is due to be mapped.
I've bought a HKS panel filter for the car but it doesn't give that nice suction noise you get from an induction kit.
But my question is, what gives better performance overall when mapped, panel filter or induction kit such as K&N 57i ??
Opinions please
I've bought a HKS panel filter for the car but it doesn't give that nice suction noise you get from an induction kit.
But my question is, what gives better performance overall when mapped, panel filter or induction kit such as K&N 57i ??
Opinions please
#2
Scooby Regular
Induction Kits damage your MAF and may destroy your engine.
Panel Filters add 0.00000000000178657 of a BHP
You are not getting a re-map on a standard car are you??
Panel Filters add 0.00000000000178657 of a BHP
You are not getting a re-map on a standard car are you??
#3
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: In your MOMMA!!!!
Posts: 1,211
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Why does a panel filter only give 0.000000000000178657 bhp and induction kits damage your engine oh font of all knowledge
Read my recent threads yu tool!
#4
Scooby Regular
Please, then, tell me why you 'think' you would get any improvement with a Panel Filter??? And why would it be noticeable???
And Induction Kits vibrate + coat your MAF with Oil ..... both give bad readings to the ECU resulting in a weak mixture and a melted piston or two.
But, hey-ho, you think I am a fool and tool - so, you carry on
And Induction Kits vibrate + coat your MAF with Oil ..... both give bad readings to the ECU resulting in a weak mixture and a melted piston or two.
But, hey-ho, you think I am a fool and tool - so, you carry on
#5
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: GC8 Enthusiast - Scumball3000 Team 69
Posts: 2,002
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I've an 51 plate JDM STI which is due to be mapped.
I've bought a HKS panel filter for the car but it doesn't give that nice suction noise you get from an induction kit.
But my question is, what gives better performance overall when mapped, panel filter or induction kit such as K&N 57i ??
Opinions please
I've bought a HKS panel filter for the car but it doesn't give that nice suction noise you get from an induction kit.
But my question is, what gives better performance overall when mapped, panel filter or induction kit such as K&N 57i ??
Opinions please
MAFs arent particularly brittle on New Age cars, but air filters make little difference on Imprezas below 350+bhp
Simon
Trending Topics
#8
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2006
Location: In your MOMMA!!!!
Posts: 1,211
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If there is a chance of meltdown with an induction kit as apposed to a panel filter can you explain why please. I'm not a mechanic by any stretch of the imagination
#10
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Bebind the wheel of my red rice rocket
Posts: 5,585
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I ran a RCM induction with no probs at all. Having said that i installed a cold air feed and had the car mapped to suit.
Induction kits are only really worth it if you are going above 350+
Induction kits are only really worth it if you are going above 350+
#11
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (3)
Neither will give massive power increase but the stock air box is apparently good for 400bhp. If you go for a panel a search on here reveals a "green" on K&N filter are the best
Just fitted a green one to my STI PPP so feel free to read the attached
https://www.scoobynet.com/general-te...el-filter.html
Just fitted a green one to my STI PPP so feel free to read the attached
https://www.scoobynet.com/general-te...el-filter.html
#12
Please, then, tell me why you 'think' you would get any improvement with a Panel Filter??? And why would it be noticeable???
And Induction Kits vibrate + coat your MAF with Oil ..... both give bad readings to the ECU resulting in a weak mixture and a melted piston or two.
But, hey-ho, you think I am a fool and tool - so, you carry on
And Induction Kits vibrate + coat your MAF with Oil ..... both give bad readings to the ECU resulting in a weak mixture and a melted piston or two.
But, hey-ho, you think I am a fool and tool - so, you carry on
(Not all induction kits coat your MAF with oil as some aren't as bad with the amount of oil as others,given,that they will have oil on them,they wont do what you "think")
Regardles which way you go,either panel or Induction kit you will let the engine "breath" better wether you see a noticeable difference at this level of tune is another thing.
After speaking to a tuner who frequents this board about induction kits/filters his words are "inductions kits are ok" i drive a newage,but i must admit i went for the Green panel filter instead which DID give me a very slight difference in power,not that you would notice it on the road, but it did show on the RR.
"They" do say, however,that the standard air box (not the filter)set up is good for about 370+bhp and thats why i went for the panel filter and not the induction kit.
PSlewis you tool-didn't any one tell you it is bad english to start a sentence with "And"
Hope this helps.
#13
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: GC8 Enthusiast - Scumball3000 Team 69
Posts: 2,002
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Pete, you are a tool and always will be-fact.
(Not all induction kits coat your MAF with oil as some aren't as bad with the amount of oil as others,given,that they will have oil on them,they wont do what you "think")
Regardles which way you go,either panel or Induction kit you will let the engine "breath" better wether you see a noticeable difference at this level of tune is another thing.
After speaking to a tuner who frequents this board about induction kits/filters his words are "inductions kits are ok" i drive a newage,but i must admit i went for the Green panel filter instead which DID give me a very slight difference in power,not that you would notice it on the road, but it did show on the RR.
"They" do say, however,that the standard air box (not the filter)set up is good for about 370+bhp and thats why i went for the panel filter and not the induction kit.
PSlewis you tool-didn't any one tell you it is bad english to start a sentence with "And"
Hope this helps.
(Not all induction kits coat your MAF with oil as some aren't as bad with the amount of oil as others,given,that they will have oil on them,they wont do what you "think")
Regardles which way you go,either panel or Induction kit you will let the engine "breath" better wether you see a noticeable difference at this level of tune is another thing.
After speaking to a tuner who frequents this board about induction kits/filters his words are "inductions kits are ok" i drive a newage,but i must admit i went for the Green panel filter instead which DID give me a very slight difference in power,not that you would notice it on the road, but it did show on the RR.
"They" do say, however,that the standard air box (not the filter)set up is good for about 370+bhp and thats why i went for the panel filter and not the induction kit.
PSlewis you tool-didn't any one tell you it is bad english to start a sentence with "And"
Hope this helps.
#15
I have yet to hear of a new age with near standard power suffering engine failure as a result of an induction kit. Anyone prove me wrong????
That said they are a waste of money a good 'green' panel filter or such like would be better.
That said they are a waste of money a good 'green' panel filter or such like would be better.
#16
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: west yorkshire
Posts: 1,203
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
as stated no big differance in panel and induction at the 350bhp mark.
can say this as i had wing induction and friend same car as me had panel filter and the was 6bhp his had 351 mine had 357 so not worth it at lower state of tune
can say this as i had wing induction and friend same car as me had panel filter and the was 6bhp his had 351 mine had 357 so not worth it at lower state of tune
#18
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: Bishop Auckland
Posts: 313
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I asked one of the guys at the scooby garage about this last week as my car was in for MOT, he said dont bother with the induction kit as the standard filter system good enough, unless you are building a monster.
He then chucked me a panel filter (dont know what make but its got black foam pyramids on one side and a red foam panel on the other behind a black metal mesh) and told me to drop it in the car "bone dry". He said its a little better than the standard paper version, but still a better idea than a couple of hunderd quid induction on a standard car.
I know sod all, so I'll put my faith in his 20+ yrs experience of working on scoobs, including the garages own rally cars. Running about with the windows down this weekend, the only thing Ive noticed is a slightly more prominent "whoosh" noise as I go through the gears, which sounds kind of pleasing.
Like I said, I'm not an expert, so I took the advice of one.
He then chucked me a panel filter (dont know what make but its got black foam pyramids on one side and a red foam panel on the other behind a black metal mesh) and told me to drop it in the car "bone dry". He said its a little better than the standard paper version, but still a better idea than a couple of hunderd quid induction on a standard car.
I know sod all, so I'll put my faith in his 20+ yrs experience of working on scoobs, including the garages own rally cars. Running about with the windows down this weekend, the only thing Ive noticed is a slightly more prominent "whoosh" noise as I go through the gears, which sounds kind of pleasing.
Like I said, I'm not an expert, so I took the advice of one.
#19
Scooby Regular
Pete, you are a tool and always will be-fact.
i must admit i went for the Green panel filter instead which DID give me a very slight difference in power,not that you would notice it on the road, but it did show on the RR.
PSlewis you tool-didn't any one tell you it is bad english to start a sentence with "And"
i must admit i went for the Green panel filter instead which DID give me a very slight difference in power,not that you would notice it on the road, but it did show on the RR.
PSlewis you tool-didn't any one tell you it is bad english to start a sentence with "And"
What was the Power increase??
I am seriously interested what the Rolling Road said the increase was.
Was it 0.5 BHP? 5 BHP?
Was the RR test done before and after fitting of the Panel Filter - same day, same RR, same weather/humidity and nothing else on the car was modified at the time? the Oil was at the same Temp.?
Truth is, and everyone knows it, any power increase is in the mind - a placebo effect .........
So, leave the damned thing alone unless you want trouble by tinkering with the edges!
#20
Scooby Regular
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Hampshire
Posts: 328
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Riiiiiiight, so, this Green Panel Filter gave very slight increase in Power did it??
What was the Power increase??
I am seriously interested what the Rolling Road said the increase was.
Was it 0.5 BHP? 5 BHP?
Was the RR test done before and after fitting of the Panel Filter - same day, same RR, same weather/humidity and nothing else on the car was modified at the time? the Oil was at the same Temp.?
Truth is, and everyone knows it, any power increase is in the mind - a placebo effect .........
So, leave the damned thing alone unless you want trouble by tinkering with the edges!
What was the Power increase??
I am seriously interested what the Rolling Road said the increase was.
Was it 0.5 BHP? 5 BHP?
Was the RR test done before and after fitting of the Panel Filter - same day, same RR, same weather/humidity and nothing else on the car was modified at the time? the Oil was at the same Temp.?
Truth is, and everyone knows it, any power increase is in the mind - a placebo effect .........
So, leave the damned thing alone unless you want trouble by tinkering with the edges!
#21
Scooby Regular
#22
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Central Scotland
Posts: 3,687
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm with the saving money brigade. Over a lifetime a washable filter is bound to save cash and i'm sure more air = better efficiency if not more power.
However, although induction kits are good for noise i'm never convinced on how well they work. People end up putting heat shields and all sorts round them to keep the engine heat away, why not just leave a panal filter in its factory made box?
5t.
However, although induction kits are good for noise i'm never convinced on how well they work. People end up putting heat shields and all sorts round them to keep the engine heat away, why not just leave a panal filter in its factory made box?
5t.
#23
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2006
Location: Yorkshire
Posts: 2,966
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
The K&N site has a 'find vehicle horsepower gain' search option:
K&N Engineering, Inc. - Product Horsepower Gain
It claims the induction kits (not just panel filters) can give 11/12hp increase on a 2004 wrx. It doesn't say if the filter alone makes any difference.
K&N Engineering, Inc. - Product Horsepower Gain
It claims the induction kits (not just panel filters) can give 11/12hp increase on a 2004 wrx. It doesn't say if the filter alone makes any difference.
#25
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Nov 2003
Location: riding the crest of a wave ...
Posts: 46,493
Likes: 0
Received 13 Likes
on
12 Posts
lol - i know this,even a 10% gain in power is unoticable on top your 250
went for the green cotton thing,waste of dosh,didint care at the time ( with the stuff to clean it with every how many months-i cant remember ) 'sooted' up fairly quick tho and could have spelt trouble if my engineer hadnt looked at it whilst plugging in mobile diagnostics machine and replacing coilpacks.
Dont bother changing anything on a classic - unless your after big hp ( and for this your best off with closed deck block sti ,like i had)
went for the green cotton thing,waste of dosh,didint care at the time ( with the stuff to clean it with every how many months-i cant remember ) 'sooted' up fairly quick tho and could have spelt trouble if my engineer hadnt looked at it whilst plugging in mobile diagnostics machine and replacing coilpacks.
Dont bother changing anything on a classic - unless your after big hp ( and for this your best off with closed deck block sti ,like i had)
Last edited by dpb; 13 August 2007 at 01:38 PM.
#26
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Feb 2006
Location: Warwickshire, UK
Posts: 2,099
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Most aftermarket filters are meant to run oiled, in which case even a drop in panel, if overoiled, can wreck your MAF as fast as an induction kit, however without oiling, some of those filters don't!
Simon
Simon
#27
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2005
Location: Shell petrol station
Posts: 4,495
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#28
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2005
Location: 392/361 MY04 STi
Posts: 7,638
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Had a panel filter at 330bhp.
Then upgraded to the larger (70mm) APS CAIK with Cold air feed. All was well when mapping. More than enough air getting in and went onto making 392/361 on an 18g.
Then upgraded to the larger (70mm) APS CAIK with Cold air feed. All was well when mapping. More than enough air getting in and went onto making 392/361 on an 18g.
#30
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: May 2006
Location: Scotland
Posts: 1,394
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Harvey on here did some tests on a dyno using 4 different panel filters
In the order of best to worst for producing power...
HKS Green Pannel Sponge.
O/E Subaru item.
K+N pannel
STi panel
All filters were within 2bhp of each other.
Harvey pointed out that although the HKS gave the most power it was the worst for partial filtration capable of passing quite large grains of sand, now that will kill your MAF and your engine.!
I cant comment on an induction kit as the last time i seen one of those it was fitted to my cossie... that was a while back..lol
Rob
In the order of best to worst for producing power...
HKS Green Pannel Sponge.
O/E Subaru item.
K+N pannel
STi panel
All filters were within 2bhp of each other.
Harvey pointed out that although the HKS gave the most power it was the worst for partial filtration capable of passing quite large grains of sand, now that will kill your MAF and your engine.!
I cant comment on an induction kit as the last time i seen one of those it was fitted to my cossie... that was a while back..lol
Rob
Last edited by rob2006; 13 August 2007 at 07:59 PM.