Which Mini Digital camcorder?
#1
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Derby
Posts: 415
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Which Mini Digital camcorder?
Just started looking at purchasing a mini digital camcorder, I've looked on a few sites like firebox ect. But I'm still not sure what to go for, any suggestions/reviews welcomed.
My budget is £100 to £150.
My budget is £100 to £150.
Last edited by Jamie_B; 14 August 2004 at 06:55 PM. Reason: Really bad spelling
#4
Whatever you do, don't be duped into buying these "digital camcorders" for around £100, which are really just 640x480 webcam type things.....
You want a camcorder which adheres to the MiniDV standard....and you'll prob have to spend £250+ new.
You want a camcorder which adheres to the MiniDV standard....and you'll prob have to spend £250+ new.
#5
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Some country and western
Posts: 13,488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I just bought one of these. Has an AV in, comes with Pinnacle editing Software. Battery life is short though.
http://www.digital-cameras.com/Digit...mera-2199.html
http://www.digital-cameras.com/Digit...mera-2199.html
#6
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Berkshire
Posts: 1,280
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by gsm1
You'll be lucky to get a digital camcorder for that kind of budget. You might find a discounted Samsung somewhere but that would be about it.
David
#7
Guest
Posts: n/a
I have just been looking at one of these in Dixons in Bluewater to see one up close, £260 but then £197 on Amazon...
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/...397920-7734035
Anybody know what they are like?
http://www.amazon.co.uk/exec/obidos/...397920-7734035
Anybody know what they are like?
Trending Topics
#8
I've yet to see a bad MiniDV camcorder, and I'm sure Sony don't make a bad one. You'll find the MiniDV pictures in good daylight are great. Lowlight always presents more of an issue for most camcorders.
#9
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Some country and western
Posts: 13,488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I looked at those, but I wanted one that I could plug an external camera in to, so I needed an AV in.
Digital 8 as well which I have no experience of.
Digital 8 as well which I have no experience of.
#10
Guest
Posts: n/a
Davyboy yours looks better at 800,000 pixels and I think for an extra £50 it would be worth it but then if your on that tight a budget then I don't think you will get lower than the Sony one with such a good brand name as Sony
Whats the quality like of the Canon one when downloaded to a pc? Also is it only firewire conection as I don't have firewire on my pc
Whats the quality like of the Canon one when downloaded to a pc? Also is it only firewire conection as I don't have firewire on my pc
#11
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2004
Location: Derby
Posts: 415
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for all the replys, I think I'll wait a while and up my budget. I was looking at one of these but as Imlach says they are only just 640x480 webcam type things....
Thanks,
Thanks,
#12
Originally Posted by **************
Whats the quality like of the Canon one when downloaded to a pc? Also is it only firewire conection as I don't have firewire on my pc
#13
Originally Posted by Jamie_B
Thanks for all the replys, I think I'll wait a while and up my budget. I was looking at one of these but as Imlach says they are only just 640x480 webcam type things....
Thanks,
Thanks,
#15
#16
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2001
Location: Some country and western
Posts: 13,488
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by **************
Whats the quality like of the Canon one when downloaded to a pc? Also is it only firewire conection as I don't have firewire on my pc
I bought a firewire cable, but the camera came with a USB cable.
#18
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Berkshire
Posts: 1,280
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by davyboy
Quality is great, certainly up to the job of recording track days etc.
I bought a firewire cable, but the camera came with a USB cable.
I bought a firewire cable, but the camera came with a USB cable.
#21
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jun 2002
Location: Berkshire
Posts: 1,280
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Originally Posted by davyboy
Then you will need some tapes.....oh and a bigger capacity battery too!
#23
Yes, do remember full MiniDV output over firewire eats into the hard-drive at the rate of 3Mbytes/s. So, that's 1 Gigabyte of drive for every 5 minutes of video.
The advantage of buying in the high st is that while the price is higher, you may also persuade them into giving you 5 DV tapes for free....so do take that into account when comparing. Same rule applies for most purchases - if the different is only £10, ease of purchase is sometimes worth it.
The advantage of buying in the high st is that while the price is higher, you may also persuade them into giving you 5 DV tapes for free....so do take that into account when comparing. Same rule applies for most purchases - if the different is only £10, ease of purchase is sometimes worth it.
#24
Yeah, so with a DVD burner, you can easily edit your footage, and then convert it into MPEG2 which will allow about 2 hours of footage on a single layer DVD.
You do need a fast-ish PC for all this - faster the better helps the MPEG2 to compress quicker - you'd prob have to leave it processing overnight for a long video anyway....
You do need a fast-ish PC for all this - faster the better helps the MPEG2 to compress quicker - you'd prob have to leave it processing overnight for a long video anyway....
#25
Guest
Posts: n/a
*ahem* p4 2.4 and half a gig of ram, not the worlds fastest by any means but think it will be adequate for video conversion, certainly does vcds quickly enough
However @
Have the space but thats a hell of a lot required, 12gig for an hours play
Not in a postion to buy yet anyway so hopefully prices wont go up only down or at worst stay where they are.
What do the ones that are £800/£900 do thats so special to be 3x the price of the above? Must have some flash gadgets with them?
However @
1 Gigabyte of drive for every 5 minutes of video
Not in a postion to buy yet anyway so hopefully prices wont go up only down or at worst stay where they are.
What do the ones that are £800/£900 do thats so special to be 3x the price of the above? Must have some flash gadgets with them?
#26
Your PC will be fine for the job.
Yes, DV output in raw form is huge, but then there's no need to store it in raw form aside from on tape. A magnetic tape probably has a lifetime of around 15 years, but long before then, you'll be able to shove hundreds of Gb on something pretty small (ie, next gen format for data storage). ie, in 5-10 years, all your footage from this year will probably fit on 1 cd-sized media....
I have stored some raw (and edited) DV video on DVD, but most are 20 minute films, so can fit on 1 DVD.
If you're happy enough to store it as MPEG2 (ie, DVD) as a permanent record, then you have no probs.
Suffice to say, the disk space required on your hard drive will only be transitory. It does sometimes help if the free space on the hard drive is contiguous though....you might get glitches if the hard drive head is bouncing all over the place trying to find the next free sectors.....so defrag if you are tight on space.
Yes, DV output in raw form is huge, but then there's no need to store it in raw form aside from on tape. A magnetic tape probably has a lifetime of around 15 years, but long before then, you'll be able to shove hundreds of Gb on something pretty small (ie, next gen format for data storage). ie, in 5-10 years, all your footage from this year will probably fit on 1 cd-sized media....
I have stored some raw (and edited) DV video on DVD, but most are 20 minute films, so can fit on 1 DVD.
If you're happy enough to store it as MPEG2 (ie, DVD) as a permanent record, then you have no probs.
Suffice to say, the disk space required on your hard drive will only be transitory. It does sometimes help if the free space on the hard drive is contiguous though....you might get glitches if the hard drive head is bouncing all over the place trying to find the next free sectors.....so defrag if you are tight on space.
#27
PS Once you've started editing video footage on a PC, and tried to make it into short films, you'll understand how time consuming film editing as a job must be - especially co-ordinating overdubbed sounds/music etc to film.
#28
Oh, and I know the data size of DV sounds staggering, but think of it like this....
An image from a 3MP digital camera is 1Mb if compressed as a JPEG.
There are 25 frames per second in video.
So, if you were taking 25 digital still photos per second, it'd be 25Mb/second.
Obviously DV is nowhere near the quality of a 3MP still image, hence the 3Mb/second.
It seems fair enough when you think of it like that......
An image from a 3MP digital camera is 1Mb if compressed as a JPEG.
There are 25 frames per second in video.
So, if you were taking 25 digital still photos per second, it'd be 25Mb/second.
Obviously DV is nowhere near the quality of a 3MP still image, hence the 3Mb/second.
It seems fair enough when you think of it like that......
#29
Originally Posted by **************
What do the ones that are £800/£900 do thats so special to be 3x the price of the above? Must have some flash gadgets with them?
Above £1k, you're starting to look at 3CCD models (1 CCD for each primary colour, red, green, blue). I have one of these, and the picture quality is one step up towards broadcast quality. Colour reproduction is improved with less wishy-washy colours than on a 1CCD model. That sometimes comes at the expense of low-light performance. You'll find that ALL video requires strong lighting to be at it's best - just like professional tv cameras really - the tv cameras need extra light even if during the day!
You'll find a lot of tv channels now have these prosumer 3CCD models used by people recording video-diaries etc. The quality really is quite acceptable for even broadcast use.
#30
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jan 1999
Location: Gone for Good
Posts: 13,628
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As of my info last month the Sony PDX10 DVCAM is what the BBC uses for video-diaries. Supurb camera, I've had mine for about 5 weeks now.
DVCAM is pro, mini dv is consumer. But once you make the leap it starts to get all abit pricey!
DVCAM is pro, mini dv is consumer. But once you make the leap it starts to get all abit pricey!
Last edited by Nevetas; 16 August 2004 at 01:24 AM.