Is this detonation?!
Thread Starter
Scooby Regular
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 504
Likes: 0
From: maturin23 - 205GTi Drivers.com
hello all,
I'm just about to fit a Dawes Device this weekend when I put my new boost gauge in.
Of course now I'm getting paranoid, but I'm concerned that there is a slight 'rustling' or 'crackling' noise as well as the induction and turbo noise when accelerating.
I don't have to really boot it to get this sound, although it happens only when the turbo is spinning.
It doesn't sound like the 'pinking' I rememeber from my old Vauxhall Shove-it, it's really not very loud - but I'm worried nonetheless.
Any tips would be great - I hate to think I'm minutes away from needing an engine rebuild, and I'm losing confidence in fitting the Dawes device!
Spec - Euro MY99, with decat downpipe, SS back box and Unichip (mapped by Power Station). No other engine/induction mods.
Edited to say it's only ever run on 98 RON Euro Super Unleaded (I'm based in teh Netherlands)
[Edited by IanWatson - 4/25/2002 3:54:20 PM]
I'm just about to fit a Dawes Device this weekend when I put my new boost gauge in.
Of course now I'm getting paranoid, but I'm concerned that there is a slight 'rustling' or 'crackling' noise as well as the induction and turbo noise when accelerating.
I don't have to really boot it to get this sound, although it happens only when the turbo is spinning.
It doesn't sound like the 'pinking' I rememeber from my old Vauxhall Shove-it, it's really not very loud - but I'm worried nonetheless.
Any tips would be great - I hate to think I'm minutes away from needing an engine rebuild, and I'm losing confidence in fitting the Dawes device!
Spec - Euro MY99, with decat downpipe, SS back box and Unichip (mapped by Power Station). No other engine/induction mods.
Edited to say it's only ever run on 98 RON Euro Super Unleaded (I'm based in teh Netherlands)
[Edited by IanWatson - 4/25/2002 3:54:20 PM]
Thread Starter
Scooby Regular
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 504
Likes: 0
From: maturin23 - 205GTi Drivers.com
greetings RT! Bit late for you?! 
not necessarily WOT - maybe half-open or so - also not resticted to high-load scenarios - does it in first as much as fifth..
No idea what boost is (not fitted the gauge yet
), but I've never had an 'over-boost' problem or messed with it at all.
The ECU map is fairly conservative, according to Power Station, although it's around a year since I had the Unichip fitted.
It really isn't an obvious noise - maybe more like a very small sandwich bag being crumpled rather than the full heavyweight Tesco's effort....
Does anyone have a .wav file of a detting engine?
cheers
ian

not necessarily WOT - maybe half-open or so - also not resticted to high-load scenarios - does it in first as much as fifth..
No idea what boost is (not fitted the gauge yet
), but I've never had an 'over-boost' problem or messed with it at all.The ECU map is fairly conservative, according to Power Station, although it's around a year since I had the Unichip fitted.
It really isn't an obvious noise - maybe more like a very small sandwich bag being crumpled rather than the full heavyweight Tesco's effort....
Does anyone have a .wav file of a detting engine?
cheers
ian
Higher suspicion if you have a Unichip. To be brutally honest I would not put a Dawes anywhere near a car that had been mapped with a Unichip previously unless the mapping was being setup with a boost controller unless you have access to something like DeltaDash (and then the numbers will be altered because of your unichip!) Absolute minefield to be honest mate.
Trending Topics
Thread Starter
Scooby Regular
Joined: Jul 2001
Posts: 504
Likes: 0
From: maturin23 - 205GTi Drivers.com
John - thanks for replying.
Reading your post - I think I may actually have a Superchip. It's not the one that fools the ecu and is generally considered risky on Scoobynet. It was recommended by Powerstation in Cheltenham.
Apologies if this is actually the case
I think I need to do a little underbonnet scouting - and re-read your Dawes faqs
Matt - you're right of course - things just seem take ages in Amsterdam, slightly different approach to customer service
No excuse - shouldn't risk a few grand for the sake of lazyness!
Reading your post - I think I may actually have a Superchip. It's not the one that fools the ecu and is generally considered risky on Scoobynet. It was recommended by Powerstation in Cheltenham.
Apologies if this is actually the case
I think I need to do a little underbonnet scouting - and re-read your Dawes faqs

Matt - you're right of course - things just seem take ages in Amsterdam, slightly different approach to customer service

No excuse - shouldn't risk a few grand for the sake of lazyness!
Katana,
I was actually talking to Ian
I know of some dealers that will still diagnose a Jap import. Power Engineering and Scoobysport also have a Select Monitor and the list of DeltaDash owners is growing by the day....
Matt
I was actually talking to Ian

I know of some dealers that will still diagnose a Jap import. Power Engineering and Scoobysport also have a Select Monitor and the list of DeltaDash owners is growing by the day....Matt
Hehe, no problem. I was only hypothetically saying what if I had a problem. I don't think I do, but you'll never know when that dreaded day would come.....especially since I'll be joining the Dawes club soon.
Ian, if you're getting the noise on half throttle, I would quite safely rule det out. I don't think your engine would still be in one piece if you were det'ing with only 50% throttle.
I've never encountered det, or heard anyone encounter det, with a decent management setup and half throttle.
I've never encountered det, or heard anyone encounter det, with a decent management setup and half throttle.
Hi Ian, I know it may sound simple, but have u checked all the heat shileds under the bonnet, they are quite 'tinny" and can make a noise similar to what u decribe, as u've had a DP in the shield may be vibrating... just a thought
Cheers
Fergal
Cheers
Fergal
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
annointed
General Technical
29
Apr 21, 2002 08:58 PM
taug6
Drivetrain
6
Mar 14, 2000 02:19 PM




