Floor standing speaker recommendations
#35
The original TDL transmission line speakers (RTL 2 & 3 i think) got very good reviews when they were originally launched. Not sure what they are like now, but i believe there were some changes within the company, and the new type are some way removed from the old. For me its either Tannoy Dual concentrics, 611 series in the office or KEF IQ series - currently in the living room Nothing else comes close And a Rel sub tucked away in the corner mart
#36
If I was planning a sub woofer route, then I'd defiantly look at kef, tannoy, tdi and simlar as I know they have very crisp sound (well in the past they did so I expect them to have got better).
But I'm not wanting a subwoofer so that's why my desicion is a bit harder as I'd like an in between.
Tbf the Dali zensor is looking promising the more owners reviews I read on them 'for my needs'
But I'm not wanting a subwoofer so that's why my desicion is a bit harder as I'd like an in between.
Tbf the Dali zensor is looking promising the more owners reviews I read on them 'for my needs'
#37
Moderator
iTrader: (1)
That's the problem...logically you shouldn't really need a subwoofer, but it seems with some floorstanders you do. Hence me calling some of them glorified bookshelfers.
I have pair of ancient technics speakers with 10" drivers that will rattle your brains out (especially if placed in a corner). Nothing special either - just a big driver in a infinite baffle chipboard cabinet. Only reason I never use them is the tweeters are rubbish and they need a huge amp to power them to any decent level of loudness - so no good for Hifi (ace for parties though ).
I have pair of ancient technics speakers with 10" drivers that will rattle your brains out (especially if placed in a corner). Nothing special either - just a big driver in a infinite baffle chipboard cabinet. Only reason I never use them is the tweeters are rubbish and they need a huge amp to power them to any decent level of loudness - so no good for Hifi (ace for parties though ).
Last edited by ALi-B; 18 November 2014 at 08:38 PM.
#39
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: Mar 2001
Location: Swilling coffee at my lab bench
Posts: 9,096
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
There may well be better speakers out there by now, of course, but if I've learned one thing about hi-fi, it's that if it's not broken, don't try to fix it. I've been disappointed with new equipment just as often as I've been delighted with it, so now I have a system I like, I'm very hesitant to change it.
#41
It might be worth seeing what you can find on the used market. I also have a pair of MA800 Gold stand-mounted speakers, which I bought nearly 20 years ago (yikes! that makes me feel old...), and still listen to almost every day.
There may well be better speakers out there by now, of course, but if I've learned one thing about hi-fi, it's that if it's not broken, don't try to fix it. I've been disappointed with new equipment just as often as I've been delighted with it, so now I have a system I like, I'm very hesitant to change it.
There may well be better speakers out there by now, of course, but if I've learned one thing about hi-fi, it's that if it's not broken, don't try to fix it. I've been disappointed with new equipment just as often as I've been delighted with it, so now I have a system I like, I'm very hesitant to change it.
I need to test some out before I make my desicion, I keep frequenting ebay for bargains but I'd like to know what I'm going for first.
#42
Tannoy
I did this a couple of years ago and went for the Tannoy's in the end - spent weeks trying different speakers (some at home as free tests and such) and for the price the Tannoy's were/are excellent. Ended up getting Ex-Demo DC6T Signatures for front, and DC4T signatures for side and rear. For Music the DC6T's are excellent, by far the best I've heard/played with at the price and I never liked Tannoy before! For movies/games a sub is needed and something fairly punchy as well.
Unfortunately time to listen to them all, preferably at home first, is needed but often not possible.
Best of Luck.
Unfortunately time to listen to them all, preferably at home first, is needed but often not possible.
Best of Luck.
#43
I did this a couple of years ago and went for the Tannoy's in the end - spent weeks trying different speakers (some at home as free tests and such) and for the price the Tannoy's were/are excellent. Ended up getting Ex-Demo DC6T Signatures for front, and DC4T signatures for side and rear. For Music the DC6T's are excellent, by far the best I've heard/played with at the price and I never liked Tannoy before! For movies/games a sub is needed and something fairly punchy as well.
Unfortunately time to listen to them all, preferably at home first, is needed but often not possible.
Best of Luck.
Unfortunately time to listen to them all, preferably at home first, is needed but often not possible.
Best of Luck.
I take it they are just very musical considering you say it needs a separate sub?
#44
With the DC6T the bass is good but it's just a very well balanced and rounded speaker - for music I will just run the fronts in the Onkyo 'Pure Audio' mode which (to me anyway) sounds superb and the speakers are very clear and concise. The bass is quite deep and rich but isn't over the top. A proper sub is required for movies - not only to get the low deep tones required but anything less will be 'weedy' next to the Tannoy's.
I tried all sorts over a month period and could genuinely notice the difference between speakers running the same receiver (an Onkyo 818).
Only thing would be - everyone is different - time and testing is what's needed - 28 hour days required
I tried all sorts over a month period and could genuinely notice the difference between speakers running the same receiver (an Onkyo 818).
Only thing would be - everyone is different - time and testing is what's needed - 28 hour days required
#45
With the DC6T the bass is good but it's just a very well balanced and rounded speaker - for music I will just run the fronts in the Onkyo 'Pure Audio' mode which (to me anyway) sounds superb and the speakers are very clear and concise. The bass is quite deep and rich but isn't over the top. A proper sub is required for movies - not only to get the low deep tones required but anything less will be 'weedy' next to the Tannoy's.
I tried all sorts over a month period and could genuinely notice the difference between speakers running the same receiver (an Onkyo 818).
Only thing would be - everyone is different - time and testing is what's needed - 28 hour days required
I tried all sorts over a month period and could genuinely notice the difference between speakers running the same receiver (an Onkyo 818).
Only thing would be - everyone is different - time and testing is what's needed - 28 hour days required
#46
Scooby Regular
Hi Busta , like others I also doubt if 500 squids will get you far new. Your best off doing the ebay and traders . I had Kefs Q50 which cost that price in 94 ! although the mid range is fine they lacked Bass response.
So In the used 500 range Id look at used speakers Ruark Talismann / Rogers studio 7 / Castle Avons or Harlech.
So In the used 500 range Id look at used speakers Ruark Talismann / Rogers studio 7 / Castle Avons or Harlech.
#48
I have Celestion A4 ,for hifi and monitor audiors6 for my av system. with a sub.
Try Bk, electrics for your sub, they are good value and hit the mark!!
are second hand act s within your budget? and spencer???
good luck with your choice. as its more than just one component, that makes thesound.
I love my Celestions, bryston , and audio synthesis combo.!!
Try Bk, electrics for your sub, they are good value and hit the mark!!
are second hand act s within your budget? and spencer???
good luck with your choice. as its more than just one component, that makes thesound.
I love my Celestions, bryston , and audio synthesis combo.!!
#49
Thanks guys, as I'm sure some of you are aware, I'm NOT getting a sub, I'm pretty confident I can find the right speaker without needing one. On my amp I choose to turn off sub input so it pushes it to the fronts (main speakers). I have cewin vega surround/monitors which are quite powerful (I have some new b&w cones in loft for me to try in my cewin Vega's but just not got round to it)
I'm already probably going to go over my budget but again I'm pretty confident still, but the Dali zensor are around £700+. But after testing and if they are right then I'll spend it, if I find some cheaper that are better then I'll go for them, or if I find some even better ones for my requirments that turn out to be £1k then hell, I may just get them.
I need time to waste at the hifi shops to help me decide with my junglistic bassline at the ready on my iPhone
I'm already probably going to go over my budget but again I'm pretty confident still, but the Dali zensor are around £700+. But after testing and if they are right then I'll spend it, if I find some cheaper that are better then I'll go for them, or if I find some even better ones for my requirments that turn out to be £1k then hell, I may just get them.
I need time to waste at the hifi shops to help me decide with my junglistic bassline at the ready on my iPhone
#50
Yes I tried the Dali Zensor's as well - a full setup for movie's (curtesy of RS) and was very good but they just weren't as good as the Tannoy's. Maybe slightly more bass but a bit 'boomier' and not as tight. Generally the Tannoy's just felt more 'musical'. Although I preferred the Dali Zensor Vokal centre speaker and the Dali E12F sub to all others so made a 'Mix and Match' system.
I only ever run music as 2 channel stereo (pure Audio mode on Onkyo which is good) and they sound superb to me but if you like deep deep powerful bass then they might not cut it.
I only ever run music as 2 channel stereo (pure Audio mode on Onkyo which is good) and they sound superb to me but if you like deep deep powerful bass then they might not cut it.
#51
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (7)
Big up to the Junglist Massive.
I don't claim to be an expert as I'm not desperately into Hi-Fi but I do like my music, also spent a few years installing big in-car systems.
To be honest if your into sound quality and base then you really should re- consider a sub, the only way to have the best of all worlds is to separate the base as your never going to get a really good mid and tops while the speakers are being pressurised by the base in the same cabinet.
I know you say you don't want to go the sub route but I think if your a deep base freak then you will only be compromising in all departments , as soon as you whack the base up you'll lose the quality, just like guys that used to spend thousands on a car system then start the engine, our spectrum analyser at work would squiggle away like it was hearing an old goodmans spindle radio in a metro with bogo paper cone speakers.
Just saying.
I don't claim to be an expert as I'm not desperately into Hi-Fi but I do like my music, also spent a few years installing big in-car systems.
To be honest if your into sound quality and base then you really should re- consider a sub, the only way to have the best of all worlds is to separate the base as your never going to get a really good mid and tops while the speakers are being pressurised by the base in the same cabinet.
I know you say you don't want to go the sub route but I think if your a deep base freak then you will only be compromising in all departments , as soon as you whack the base up you'll lose the quality, just like guys that used to spend thousands on a car system then start the engine, our spectrum analyser at work would squiggle away like it was hearing an old goodmans spindle radio in a metro with bogo paper cone speakers.
Just saying.
#52
Noted ditch.
But these new floorstanders have a separate cabinet built into them that separate the bass, mids and tops etc so you keep that quality sound.
My old mission speakers (bookshelf) are actually very decent sounding coupled with my amp and cerwin vega surround/monitors.
The bass is nice and deep at reasonable volume but once pushed can get a bit rubbish.
If I find the right speaker then I definattly don't need a sub (depends what most people buy a sub for?) I've read some reviews of owners that say the Dali zensor 7 don't actually need a sub, but just need to listen to the clarity of them at pushed volumes.
Thanks henrysmith, I'll look into the dc6t as they do have good reviews to for a compact design, so they are definattly worth a listen.
But these new floorstanders have a separate cabinet built into them that separate the bass, mids and tops etc so you keep that quality sound.
My old mission speakers (bookshelf) are actually very decent sounding coupled with my amp and cerwin vega surround/monitors.
The bass is nice and deep at reasonable volume but once pushed can get a bit rubbish.
If I find the right speaker then I definattly don't need a sub (depends what most people buy a sub for?) I've read some reviews of owners that say the Dali zensor 7 don't actually need a sub, but just need to listen to the clarity of them at pushed volumes.
Thanks henrysmith, I'll look into the dc6t as they do have good reviews to for a compact design, so they are definattly worth a listen.
#53
http://www.richersounds.com/package/...014-11-20_2040
Just had an email from RS and they are doing this setup as £999 if you register for the VIP membership and mention it.
Good luck and enjoy either way
Just had an email from RS and they are doing this setup as £999 if you register for the VIP membership and mention it.
Good luck and enjoy either way
#55
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Aug 2003
Location: Epsom
Posts: 5,832
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Interesting article on speaker design, only slightly off topic! http://www.theregister.co.uk/2014/07...peaker_design/
#58
Moderator
iTrader: (1)
Oh well, looks like I'm back looking again: There's two pairs of KEF RDM 3's on ebay. Nice speaker in its heyday...
Bidding just gone crazy with snipers though...was £100 a pair all week. I was winning for the best part of today...not anymore though and there's no way am I going over £200 for 15+ year old speakers.
I've got KEF bookshelfers that are newer than these that need the drivers re-foaming...sealed cabinets put a lot of pressure and strain on the drivers, so the foams have just given way, I suspect the mid-bass (sealed) on the RDMs will eventually suffer the same fate - worth the risk/cost of rebuilding if they can be purchased at the right price though.
Bidding just gone crazy with snipers though...was £100 a pair all week. I was winning for the best part of today...not anymore though and there's no way am I going over £200 for 15+ year old speakers.
I've got KEF bookshelfers that are newer than these that need the drivers re-foaming...sealed cabinets put a lot of pressure and strain on the drivers, so the foams have just given way, I suspect the mid-bass (sealed) on the RDMs will eventually suffer the same fate - worth the risk/cost of rebuilding if they can be purchased at the right price though.
Last edited by ALi-B; 23 November 2014 at 07:12 PM.
#59
lol I'm watching some monitor audio and if they go for a decent price I might buy them, their £700+ new.
Tbh, I'm thinking now that the b&w 684 would be perfect for me, or even the 683 s2 which have glowing awards for punchy powerful ness = heavy weight bass with b&w sound quality.
Tbh, I'm thinking now that the b&w 684 would be perfect for me, or even the 683 s2 which have glowing awards for punchy powerful ness = heavy weight bass with b&w sound quality.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post