ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   ScoobyNet General (https://www.scoobynet.com/scoobynet-general-1/)
-   -   335bhp to 345/350bhp? (https://www.scoobynet.com/scoobynet-general-1/998995-335bhp-to-345-350bhp.html)

madey 06 March 2014 04:00 PM

335bhp to 345/350bhp?
 
03 sti tsl 333 remap, would a remap by jgm or duncan/dynamix give me an extra 10/15 bhp or would I need 3 port solenoid and or caik? Thanks.

BrownPantsRacing 06 March 2014 04:09 PM

All another mapper can do to increase your power is fiddle the timing, fuel, boost etc differently and try. To be honest, if you put your car on a different rolling road it may read more.

For the sake of 10bhp is it really worth all the hastle? Will you notice the difference on the road?

alcazar 06 March 2014 04:23 PM

As above, what's the point?

you may end up with a more powerful, but less "driveable" car:(

urban 06 March 2014 04:29 PM


Originally Posted by madey (Post 11371533)
03 sti tsl 333 remap, would a remap by jgm or duncan/dynamix give me an extra 10/15 bhp or would I need 3 port solenoid and or caik? Thanks.

You'd need a full decat.
But then you'd be in trouble come MOT time.

madey 06 March 2014 04:34 PM

That settles that then!

BrownPantsRacing 06 March 2014 04:42 PM

I have a VF48, sports cat, full exhaust, K&N filter, 3 port etc on mine and still only made 334bhp.

Just live with it and enjoy it! No point spending much more money unless you are aiming much higher from where you are now in my opinion! :)

L.J.F 06 March 2014 04:43 PM

A set of ported Harvey headers and up pipe, decat down pipe and a meth mix map will get you a awesome driving 350+bhp car.


You could also get the turbo ported aswell.

burt2000 06 March 2014 05:12 PM

go for 400 or no point spending the money imo

craigybaby 06 March 2014 06:29 PM

Bhp is just pub talk and bragging rights anyway if you enjoy how it drives and how it feels on the road just leave it chances are you won't be able to feel a massive difference from a extra 10bhp anyway

madey 08 March 2014 02:06 PM

Thanks for the replys.

Apostle 08 March 2014 10:40 PM

Yep....
 
Perrin inlet with CAIK should take it to 350 and free it a little at the top end :thumb: Decent three port (Grimmspeed or similar) and recirc Forge BOV should sharpen the boost up / may get a few more lbs.
if IRC the TSL 333 map gives great midrange and sensible boost. A remap from a good mapper would squeeze a little more.

Go for it. :norty:

Then when your bored - get a SC billet turbo to finish it off :cool:



Originally Posted by madey (Post 11371533)
03 sti tsl 333 remap, would a remap by jgm or duncan/dynamix give me an extra 10/15 bhp or would I need 3 port solenoid and or caik? Thanks.


BrownPantsRacing 09 March 2014 10:05 AM


Originally Posted by Apostle (Post 11373984)
Perrin inlet with CAIK should take it to 350 and free it a little at the top end :thumb: Decent three port (Grimmspeed or similar) and recirc Forge BOV should sharpen the boost up / may get a few more lbs.
if IRC the TSL 333 map gives great midrange and sensible boost. A remap from a good mapper would squeeze a little more.

Go for it. :norty:

Then when your bored - get a SC billet turbo to finish it off :cool:

Not wishing to be difficult but don't 100% agree with some of the comments. There is certainly no benefit to be had swapping the standard dump valve for an alternative forge recirculating unit, will not sharpen boost or add power or torque in any way.

Also, the standard Subaru air intake system in very good and you don't need to go to CAI to achieve 350bhp. Secondly, an uprated panel filter has been proved as a very good upgrade path for 350bhp.

A 3 port solenoid is also not essential for this power level.

Sorry, not wishing to be difficult. :)

madey 09 March 2014 05:39 PM

Does a aftermarket turbo inlet pipe such as Perrin make a difference on a sti? I know it does on a mazda mps.

alcazar 09 March 2014 07:42 PM

Not afaik.

Maybe look at a trick up-pipe, like the Harvey one now sold by AS Performance?

Boost comes in lower and more of it.

Apostle 09 March 2014 10:06 PM

Yep
 

Originally Posted by madey (Post 11374545)
Does a aftermarket turbo inlet pipe such as Perrin make a difference on a sti? I know it does on a mazda mps.

Very much so.... Esp with CAIK :thumb:

Just look at them together....

Apostle 09 March 2014 10:30 PM

Well....
 

Originally Posted by BrownPantsRacing (Post 11374216)
Not wishing to be difficult but don't 100% agree with some of the comments. There is certainly no benefit to be had swapping the standard dump valve for an alternative forge recirculating unit, will not sharpen boost or add power or torque in any way.

Also, the standard Subaru air intake system in very good and you don't need to go to CAI to achieve 350bhp. Secondly, an uprated panel filter has been proved as a very good upgrade path for 350bhp.

A 3 port solenoid is also not essential for this power level.

Sorry, not wishing to be difficult. :)

It's all about how it drives... :thumb:

I believe it was the Subaru guru John Felstead (of SN Hall of Fame) who discovered that a good metal recirc BOV like the Forge gave him another 20+lbs on his current nigh on 500bhp Sti. His reckoning 'ish was that at higher boost pressure the plastic one can leak a little ... his did. It sharpened it all up - a vastly superior part.

As for the three port- the Grimmspeed uses a Manley valve ( only them and one other manufacturer I believe use this design - could be TurboXS) thus creating sharper response etc. Better holding/ control of boost :cool:

That was my experience. :top::top:

I've tried to mod my car from listening to the truly established experts such as Andy F, John Felstead, John Banks, Alan & Martyn Jeffries, Harvey Smith plus some others on here. :notworthy

Not all 'upgrade components' upgrade performance I agree. :nono:

If Brown Pants hasn't found these little changes helpful that's okay. It's a free world man....

I've found that every little helps. Talk to a race team. :D.
I wanted response, driveability, increased power band ( Harvey up-pipe definitely good with headers).

I now run a safe 452/454 @1.6bar on a Grimmspeed top mount - it's very responsive - boosts at 2900 full whack by 3500. Creates power all the way to 6000 where we slowly ease it off.

Of course you can squeeze more but tbh I don't think it'd be that noticeable and not really worth the extra stresses on the 2.5 lump.

Back to the OP... If it's only headline figures you want then fair play, but if driveability is top dog, then have a little think ;)

A

BrownPantsRacing 09 March 2014 10:47 PM

Some good info here about the CAIK. Some good varied opinions

https://www.scoobynet.com/scoobynet-...a-warning.html

Each to their own. I'd say the recommendations for a 350bhp car and a 500bhp car will vary somewhat. I'd only suggest you don't need to overspend on lots of unnecessary bits for 350bhp.

Cheers.

BrownPantsRacing 09 March 2014 10:55 PM

P.s. you are completely right about a 3 port helping to control boost better. I have one on my 334bhp car, although it wasn't an essential mod to achieve that figure.

I also understand what you say about dump valves and sure the standard unit has it's limits too, but those limits are beyond the ops target. Personally I have an HKS ssqv fitted to mine which are not everyone's cup of tea. They are the only dump valve designed to be held shut by it's own boost pressure.

Andy.

alcazar 10 March 2014 02:33 PM

One of the problems about tuning is called "The Law of Diminishing Returns".

It's the same with most things.....in my early days, I used to spend a lot of time and money trying to make my Hi-Fi sound better.
Some of the stuff we did, looked like snake oil, but it had some effect. Using a thin layer of Blu-Tack to bond the pickup cartridge to the arm was one. Cost nowt, but deepened the bass and freed the top-end. (this was in the days when vinyl ruled, guys, bear with me, OK:D) Even turning a ridged turntable platter mat over so that the LP rested on a solid side, seemed to have an effect.

Other things had more effect, but started to cost good money. Speaker cables were a case in point: change from the old bell-wire that used to come with most speakers, or be sold as speaker wire, and you'd hear a noticeable difference when you changed to QED 89 strand at £0.90 per metre. Change up to something like QED silver and you might hear the difference, but now you are paying £4 a metre. Change again to QED Silver Genesis spiral bi-wire at £80 per metre and most folk, using most stereos, won't hear the difference. Some may even think it's worse. Yet it costs 20x more!

So it is with car tuning. Spend a few £££, do a few simple things, you'll feel the difference.

But with most people driving most Scoobs, lots of stuff you do is a case of, "What has it done? Anything?"

Now I'm not saying, therefore, that you shouldn't do it, if it's what you want. Just don't expect amazing results from everything...and watch those £££, they soon become ££££££.

BrownPantsRacing 10 March 2014 03:20 PM

Well said Alcazar. There is a moral to the end of that long story! :)

That's precisely why I wouldn't bother spending any more money to achieve an increase from 335bhp to 350bhp. It will start to get very expensive and you may not be able to quantify the improvement against the spending.

Jolly Green Monster 10 March 2014 04:05 PM

seeing as TSL havent been trading for a while just selling off old stock it might be an idea to find out what power you actually have now and perhaps have a health check as you may find that the cars actually not 333bhp at all and could be in need for a safety tweak.

Engines wear, mods get altered on the car, fuel pumps flow less etc.. I would assume the 333 was added some time back now?

Simon

Jolly Green Monster 10 March 2014 04:07 PM


Originally Posted by BrownPantsRacing (Post 11371541)
All another mapper can do to increase your power is fiddle the timing, fuel, boost etc differently and try. To be honest, if you put your car on a different rolling road it may read more.

For the sake of 10bhp is it really worth all the hastle? Will you notice the difference on the road?

remapped a car the other week where the gain at peak power was only 7hp from memory but it gained throughout the rev range around 15-20hp and around 25lb.. owner said it transformed it.. and a very noticable difference but on paper looking at peak power it only gain 7hp.

Simon

BrownPantsRacing 10 March 2014 04:15 PM


Originally Posted by Jolly Green Monster (Post 11375532)
remapped a car the other week where the gain at peak power was only 7hp from memory but it gained throughout the rev range around 15-20hp and around 25lb.. owner said it transformed it.. and a very noticable difference but on paper looking at peak power it only gain 7hp.

Simon

Nice work! Suppose it all depends how one mapper sets the ECU up compared to another and as you say, at the end of the day it's all about how it actually drives on the road!

madey 10 March 2014 05:37 PM

Simon, I've had the car on r/r at Powerstation (tewksbury) last week, 335/314. Yes, your right, the remap by tsl was long before I had the car. Having had two 2.5 sti's before I miss the torque.

Jolly Green Monster 10 March 2014 08:36 PM


Originally Posted by madey (Post 11375594)
Simon, I've had the car on r/r at Powerstation (tewksbury) last week, 335/314. Yes, your right, the remap by tsl was long before I had the car. Having had two 2.5 sti's before I miss the torque.

and its a little low on torque also.

heres one I did last month, 340lb. Compare your graph

https://fbcdn-sphotos-e-a.akamaihd.n...60147238_n.jpg

Simon

madey 13 March 2014 11:58 AM

Yes I think torque is low, which is the nearest r/r you use to Somerset?

Jolly Green Monster 13 March 2014 12:08 PM

Not really one down that way. Use subaru4you in newbury but a reasonable drive. Perhaps a road map?

urban 13 March 2014 12:27 PM

Road maps - they're great fun :D

L.J.F 13 March 2014 02:26 PM

I've only ever had road maps done on my Impreza's as that's where it will be driven ;)

madey 14 March 2014 01:17 PM

I've done road maps with Bob rawle and Duncan/dynamix but I thought I would do on the dyno this time.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:47 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands