MY99 UK Turbo with PP ECU - Can i decat downpipe?
#1
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Middlesex
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
MY99 UK Turbo with PP ECU - Can i decat downpipe?
Hi folks,
I have done my reading on here, and I have gathered some information but just want to make sure...
I have a MY99 UK turbo 2000 AWD, with no engine mods, but a PPP ECU. I have the centre section decat pipe and a back box. I always put in V-Power (no matter how much my wallet tells me not too).
My friend has given me a decat downpipe and tells me that it should make a big difference and to whack it on. I have read that the decat downpipe will create over boost problems and lead to fuel cut, I think.
I have also read about the restrictor pill, and that that can be drilled out in 0.5mm instalments until the best size is found, and run the car like that.
Is any of this a good idea? Should I leave it how it is, how prodrive meant for it to be? Or can I give it a go with drilling the restrictor pill?
Also, if I can do this, is there anything that should be done? Next on my list will be the panel filter, as I said above, that’s how prodrive wanted it to be...
Any help appreciated.
Thanks, Matt
I have done my reading on here, and I have gathered some information but just want to make sure...
I have a MY99 UK turbo 2000 AWD, with no engine mods, but a PPP ECU. I have the centre section decat pipe and a back box. I always put in V-Power (no matter how much my wallet tells me not too).
My friend has given me a decat downpipe and tells me that it should make a big difference and to whack it on. I have read that the decat downpipe will create over boost problems and lead to fuel cut, I think.
I have also read about the restrictor pill, and that that can be drilled out in 0.5mm instalments until the best size is found, and run the car like that.
Is any of this a good idea? Should I leave it how it is, how prodrive meant for it to be? Or can I give it a go with drilling the restrictor pill?
Also, if I can do this, is there anything that should be done? Next on my list will be the panel filter, as I said above, that’s how prodrive wanted it to be...
Any help appreciated.
Thanks, Matt
#3
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: 1600cc's of twin scroll fun :)
Posts: 25,565
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
It can cause big issues, no matter what anyone say's to the contary, if they had a generic remap and then replaced an item like a catted dp with a decatted dp it will overboost and can det.
Your best off doing 1 of 2 things, keep the car as standard (you wont gain much anyway from just a decat without a remap) or 2 replace the ecu with a standard unit and get it remapped (adding the downpipe at the same time).
Tony
Your best off doing 1 of 2 things, keep the car as standard (you wont gain much anyway from just a decat without a remap) or 2 replace the ecu with a standard unit and get it remapped (adding the downpipe at the same time).
Tony
#4
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Middlesex
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks Tony, that was the reply i'm waiting for.
As its a UK Classic, with PPP ecu, i think i will just leave it it as it is... Im only 23, and couldnt insure a JDM, but do want to start properly modding on a classic STI, so i think i may just keep the UK classic standard as the STI is better to start with anyway...
Thanks a lot mate
As its a UK Classic, with PPP ecu, i think i will just leave it it as it is... Im only 23, and couldnt insure a JDM, but do want to start properly modding on a classic STI, so i think i may just keep the UK classic standard as the STI is better to start with anyway...
Thanks a lot mate
#5
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (10)
I had a ppp ecu on my MY2000 uk,and fitted a decat downpipe,car did not seem to suffer,and still pulled 1.1 bar with no hesitation. I too read that it could lead to overboosting,but being as i only had it fitted to my car for 16 days,before i changed the ecu,turbo,etc,cant really say that it will definetley overboost as mine appeared to run fine ,without any mods to the t piece or the restrictor pill.
#7
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (26)
I done it too, when I had my PPP ecu. But at the same time I fitted a boost controller, to cap it at 1.1 bar, so never experienced any overboosting because of that.
But it wasn't long before I looked for a standard ECU to have mapped, just because I wanted to take things further.
But it wasn't long before I looked for a standard ECU to have mapped, just because I wanted to take things further.
Trending Topics
#8
As Tony says decatting the PPP can cause issues - the most likely of which will be a tendency to overboost/spike. As already said some cars will do it some won't, depends on a number of factors, not least the temperature of the ambient air - and in any case there is a simple fix for it
If you want to try the decat downpipe, it'd be worth getting a good quality boost gauge first, driving round with it on for a couple of weeks so you get to know the natural boost response of the car, and then fit the DP. If you then see any unpleasant spikes/oscillations on the gauge, you can take some remedial action - which will most likely be drilling out the restrictor orifice in the boost control pipework a little bit.
If you want to try the decat downpipe, it'd be worth getting a good quality boost gauge first, driving round with it on for a couple of weeks so you get to know the natural boost response of the car, and then fit the DP. If you then see any unpleasant spikes/oscillations on the gauge, you can take some remedial action - which will most likely be drilling out the restrictor orifice in the boost control pipework a little bit.
#9
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (3)
Join Date: Aug 2000
Location: 1600cc's of twin scroll fun :)
Posts: 25,565
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Mine was on the car a good 2.5yrs, ran 1.1ish normal, decat pushed that to 1.25-1.3bar saw det on that on cold days, knocklink loved me, always ran her on super unleaded as per Prodrives instructions.
Eventually drilled the restrictor pill out a little, still it wasnt worth the effort when a remap would have given me safer power.
Tony
Eventually drilled the restrictor pill out a little, still it wasnt worth the effort when a remap would have given me safer power.
Tony
Last edited by TonyBurns; 28 June 2010 at 03:24 PM.
#10
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Middlesex
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Hey guys, Thanks for all the replies...
The last thing I want is to hurt my engine or worse.
I have a boost gauge plumbed in, it’s a mechanical one, and I don’t think it is too accurate (my mate gave it me, it is one of the ones that you can press the button and it changes to 7 different colours (I think that means it is inaccurate)). I think the most I’ve seen on it on a nice cold evening in 5th gear was a bout 18-19psi - should I be worried? I haven’t felt any type of fuel cut in my car... Just a thought, I also have RomRaider so may go out and check that against my boost gauge to see if there is a difference.
I'm trying to steer clear of fitting it, also for MOT purposes, however, if I feel I need to test it out, is it easy to get another restrictor pill if I mess up mine, or want to change it back?
Also I know that these ECU’s are one of the best for a MY99-00 (for a standard car – plug in 40BHP at the least i think), and wouldn’t want to remap this ECU... so would sell this one and map a standard one, which also seems like a long procedure.
Please keep the replies coming....
Thanks, Matt
The last thing I want is to hurt my engine or worse.
I have a boost gauge plumbed in, it’s a mechanical one, and I don’t think it is too accurate (my mate gave it me, it is one of the ones that you can press the button and it changes to 7 different colours (I think that means it is inaccurate)). I think the most I’ve seen on it on a nice cold evening in 5th gear was a bout 18-19psi - should I be worried? I haven’t felt any type of fuel cut in my car... Just a thought, I also have RomRaider so may go out and check that against my boost gauge to see if there is a difference.
I'm trying to steer clear of fitting it, also for MOT purposes, however, if I feel I need to test it out, is it easy to get another restrictor pill if I mess up mine, or want to change it back?
Also I know that these ECU’s are one of the best for a MY99-00 (for a standard car – plug in 40BHP at the least i think), and wouldn’t want to remap this ECU... so would sell this one and map a standard one, which also seems like a long procedure.
Please keep the replies coming....
Thanks, Matt
#11
Just a thought, I also have RomRaider so may go out and check that against my boost gauge to see if there is a difference.
I'm trying to steer clear of fitting it, also for MOT purposes, however, if I feel I need to test it out, is it easy to get another restrictor pill if I mess up mine, or want to change it back?
Re. "long procedure", not quite sure what you mean - mapper will map a standard ECU just as quickly as he would a PPP one so it's not "longer" in that respect. In either case he'll most likely start from his own base map. As you say, if you are going down that route, the most financially effective way to do it is to sell the PPP ECU as it is and use a standard one for the remap.
#12
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Middlesex
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks Splitpin, i will check on RomRaider tonight and see if the gauge is over reading - suspect it is - i should have mentioned you can get them on eBay for about 20-30 pound...
But to answer your question, it would get up there and drop back down. I don't think I've ever seen it stay up there.
I have an MOT friendly test station so i not need worry about that, don't really know why i mentioned it.
With the "long Procedure" i meant that its just a bit long to get another ECU and change them over to get a map on there... I'm lazy and cant be bothered to do anything!
Oh, and thanks for the heads up with the pill, if i need to i can take a trip to Subaru.
Thanks a lot for your help, I will report back with the gauge problem, which i think it is...
Thanks a lot!!
But to answer your question, it would get up there and drop back down. I don't think I've ever seen it stay up there.
I have an MOT friendly test station so i not need worry about that, don't really know why i mentioned it.
With the "long Procedure" i meant that its just a bit long to get another ECU and change them over to get a map on there... I'm lazy and cant be bothered to do anything!
Oh, and thanks for the heads up with the pill, if i need to i can take a trip to Subaru.
Thanks a lot for your help, I will report back with the gauge problem, which i think it is...
Thanks a lot!!
Last edited by Mattmann; 28 June 2010 at 05:31 PM.
#13
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Middlesex
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
over reading boost gauge
Hi, My boost gauge is over reading, which is a good thing. RomRaider has told me that in 4th gear i hit 15.82psi at 3032RMP, it held it for a little bit, and then started drop down. My boost gauge on the hand read about 17-18psi. So that has cleared up that matter, thanks
As for the decat DP i may try it out, I'm not too sure. I think i will leave it for the moment as I'm really not bored of my car and don't need extra power yet.
If anyone else wants to leave some comments about when they put a decat downpipe on a PPP ECU and the running issues they may or may have not got...
Thanks, Matt
As for the decat DP i may try it out, I'm not too sure. I think i will leave it for the moment as I'm really not bored of my car and don't need extra power yet.
If anyone else wants to leave some comments about when they put a decat downpipe on a PPP ECU and the running issues they may or may have not got...
Thanks, Matt
Last edited by Mattmann; 28 June 2010 at 07:55 PM.
#14
Good stuff, that makes sense - and your logs suggest that the boost is where it should be at the moment. The bottom line with this gauge is that even though it's inaccurate, as long as that level of inaccuracy remains consistent, it's still usable in a compare and contrast scenario - especially for spotting spiking.
As far as other people posting comments, btw, you'll probably not find anything "better" than you've already got. Bottom line is that each car behaves slightly different - especially a decade after being assembled. To a large extent it doesn't matter what happens to other cars, when the only thing that really matters is what yours does.
As far as other people posting comments, btw, you'll probably not find anything "better" than you've already got. Bottom line is that each car behaves slightly different - especially a decade after being assembled. To a large extent it doesn't matter what happens to other cars, when the only thing that really matters is what yours does.
#17
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: Middlesex
Posts: 57
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for everyone's help
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post