Boost controllers - any point?
#1
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Bournemouth - 5x Ex Impreza owner. 997 GT3 CS.
Posts: 7,333
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Much as i'd like to have some flash ******* digital displays in the car, I can't find much point to these things for any peformance increase...
Surely if the ECU is controlling things, ie boost and fuelling, its not really sensible to fit a controller, and up the boost past the ECU's target boost? With a standard ECU, you are just assuming the right degree of fuelling is there if you up the boost.
And for the £400 - £500 they cost (except dawes ) you're not far off a Remap, which seems much more a pukka option.
Guess they are good for limiting boost if you get overboost, or want to keep it down on a motorway drive etc?
Any thoughts?
MB
Surely if the ECU is controlling things, ie boost and fuelling, its not really sensible to fit a controller, and up the boost past the ECU's target boost? With a standard ECU, you are just assuming the right degree of fuelling is there if you up the boost.
And for the £400 - £500 they cost (except dawes ) you're not far off a Remap, which seems much more a pukka option.
Guess they are good for limiting boost if you get overboost, or want to keep it down on a motorway drive etc?
Any thoughts?
MB
#2
yeah i totally agree that a remap is a better option especially if u have other mods that the standard ecu isn't mapped for.
not necessarily assuming if u have a knocklink etc and u could always adjust the fuelling anyway. the standard ecu is mapped to allow for *some* degree of crappy petrol, poor maintenance etc and also is set to allow for longish engine life.
With a standard ECU, you are just assuming the right degree of fuelling is there if you up the boost.
#3
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: Out of darkness cometh light
Posts: 1,457
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I can't find much point to these things for any peformance increase...
A manual boost controller, such as GBE, Dawes, etc, is a cheap (albeit crude) method of increasing the volume of air going into the engine. As long as a boost gauge is used to set it up, the level is set safely below fuel cut, the AFR is OK, and there is no detonation, you should be able to substantially increase the performance of your car for less than £250.
Surely if the ECU is controlling things, ie. boost and fuelling, its not really sensible to fit a controller, and up the boost past the ECU's target boost?
With a standard ECU, you are just assuming the right degree of fuelling is there if you up the boost.
And for the £400 - £500 they cost (except dawes ) you're not far off a Remap, which seems much more a pukka option.
Guess they are good for limiting boost if you get overboost, or want to keep it down on a motorway drive etc?
#4
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2002
Location: Bournemouth - 5x Ex Impreza owner. 997 GT3 CS.
Posts: 7,333
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Look, Google suggested something sensible for once!
Judge,
Ta for the info. Im still would be a little worried about upping the boost and relying on the AFR and KL, but I guess thats nearly as good as it gets. I have both of these fitted, and use them all the time.
Unfortunately there's no TEK for STi4's, but looks like there are new options appearing.
Trouble is, decatted, mine hits 1.27 bar peak, which leaves little room to add boost with a controller. Certainly not worth hundreds of pounds for 1 or 3 psi.
MB
Judge,
Ta for the info. Im still would be a little worried about upping the boost and relying on the AFR and KL, but I guess thats nearly as good as it gets. I have both of these fitted, and use them all the time.
Unfortunately there's no TEK for STi4's, but looks like there are new options appearing.
Trouble is, decatted, mine hits 1.27 bar peak, which leaves little room to add boost with a controller. Certainly not worth hundreds of pounds for 1 or 3 psi.
MB
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post