new engine installed, wierd issues
#1
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
new engine installed, wierd issues
Right, just installed my new engine from api. did all the correct procedures re the oil (dry cranking etc..etc..)
i then tried to fire it up. after about 30-40 seconds it started coughing then rythmically coughing (without starter motor) for about 15 seconds (the engine was litteraly rocking) then it all kicked into life and idles perfectly.
when trying to depress the accelerator it tries to stall and goes to rocking then idles fine again!
turned engine off, waited 5 mins and its starts all over again
im thinking its not firing on all cylinders to begin with.
could this be injectors/sparkplugs/timing/maf???
would appreciate any advise,
Cheers
Si
i then tried to fire it up. after about 30-40 seconds it started coughing then rythmically coughing (without starter motor) for about 15 seconds (the engine was litteraly rocking) then it all kicked into life and idles perfectly.
when trying to depress the accelerator it tries to stall and goes to rocking then idles fine again!
turned engine off, waited 5 mins and its starts all over again
im thinking its not firing on all cylinders to begin with.
could this be injectors/sparkplugs/timing/maf???
would appreciate any advise,
Cheers
Si
Last edited by SyHightower; 07 May 2005 at 09:03 PM.
#2
Go back to basics.
Eventually it runs ok, though I'm not sure if you have driiven it on the road?
Thus basic engine all ok.
There are a lot of 'hidden'/'hard to get to' pipes around the back of the inlet manifold especially, and I suggest you retrace you step when you re-fitted the engine.
The ecu will work hard to get the engine running to try to compensate for some things. Do you have any engine lights on?(CEL = check engine light) as decoded this will give you a good direction to go in.
Try every wire etc and you may get there quickly.
It's an API engine so solid, just a stupid pipe somewhere!
Let us all know where you end up. Lots will catch the thread and respond!
Graham.
Eventually it runs ok, though I'm not sure if you have driiven it on the road?
Thus basic engine all ok.
There are a lot of 'hidden'/'hard to get to' pipes around the back of the inlet manifold especially, and I suggest you retrace you step when you re-fitted the engine.
The ecu will work hard to get the engine running to try to compensate for some things. Do you have any engine lights on?(CEL = check engine light) as decoded this will give you a good direction to go in.
Try every wire etc and you may get there quickly.
It's an API engine so solid, just a stupid pipe somewhere!
Let us all know where you end up. Lots will catch the thread and respond!
Graham.
#3
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
no CEL codes when black connectors together. you can slowly depress the accelerator to get it to rev about 50% of the time but if you press normally it tries to stall, ive only driven in up and down my drive.
i installed a VTA breather kit, it was actualy your design (http://tinypic.com/1fbz38) because the pipe off the big inlet pipe to the crank breather was broken. so ive bunged up and replaced the the other side of the tpiece with a longer pipe and VTA. ive done the same with the rockers, and bunged up the inlet. only differecnce ive not got em linked em together andgoing into a container like you design.
could this cause it?
Simon
i installed a VTA breather kit, it was actualy your design (http://tinypic.com/1fbz38) because the pipe off the big inlet pipe to the crank breather was broken. so ive bunged up and replaced the the other side of the tpiece with a longer pipe and VTA. ive done the same with the rockers, and bunged up the inlet. only differecnce ive not got em linked em together andgoing into a container like you design.
could this cause it?
Simon
#4
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Jul 2002
Location: Under your bonnet
Posts: 9,173
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
As long as the intake pipe joins are sealed or "bunged up" as you say, then venting to atmos on all / any of the breathers wont affect the running of the engine.
You say it runs at idle!
does it run smoothly and on all four cylinders as you'd expect, is there any hissing around the inlet manifold? (looking for air leaks, pipes missed off etc)
Andy
You say it runs at idle!
does it run smoothly and on all four cylinders as you'd expect, is there any hissing around the inlet manifold? (looking for air leaks, pipes missed off etc)
Andy
#5
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
its sounds like its only running on 1 or 2 cylinders when its rocking then it eventually kick into life on all 4 and then idles perfectly. but if you depress the accelerator it sounds as if 2 or 3 cylinders stop, causes it to almost stall, then rocks the engine, and then all start up again when acceletrator is released.
im going outside in a min to check for hissing etc. in a min
Simon
im going outside in a min to check for hissing etc. in a min
Simon
#6
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
right been playing all day on this. i connected the rocker covers back to the inlet, but it made no difference.
i have a forge dump valve, dawes, and a backbox.
the car eventually started after much turning and rocking and coughing. it then would idle ok and keep cutting out after a min or two randomly.
i checked for leaks etc but couldnt find anything....
i then took it round the block and up and down the road, making sure not to go over 3k.
the car would try to stall if it went under 1.5k so i have to drop the clutch rev and engage lower gear. when driving its almost normal until you try to put a tiny amout of load onto it when accelerating (to put this into perspective i had a scooter etching to overtake when leaving a roundabout) it seemed to miss and try to stall. took it home and let it idle for another min. i noticed the temp gage fluctuating iraticallyby about -+5 degrees. my neighbour came over to have a nosey at it and it seemed to be hunting idle and missing everyso often. when reving it, its alot better than yesterday and only chokes/misses about 10% of the time
HELP!
Simon
ps. just to reiterate api built me a new engine, i put the inlet manifold on.
i have a forge dump valve, dawes, and a backbox.
the car eventually started after much turning and rocking and coughing. it then would idle ok and keep cutting out after a min or two randomly.
i checked for leaks etc but couldnt find anything....
i then took it round the block and up and down the road, making sure not to go over 3k.
the car would try to stall if it went under 1.5k so i have to drop the clutch rev and engage lower gear. when driving its almost normal until you try to put a tiny amout of load onto it when accelerating (to put this into perspective i had a scooter etching to overtake when leaving a roundabout) it seemed to miss and try to stall. took it home and let it idle for another min. i noticed the temp gage fluctuating iraticallyby about -+5 degrees. my neighbour came over to have a nosey at it and it seemed to be hunting idle and missing everyso often. when reving it, its alot better than yesterday and only chokes/misses about 10% of the time
HELP!
Simon
ps. just to reiterate api built me a new engine, i put the inlet manifold on.
Last edited by SyHightower; 08 May 2005 at 04:11 PM.
#7
Have you checked that your injectors are all working? With the engine running try disconnecting and then reconnecting each one in turn to see if it makes the engine run worse or better.
Trending Topics
#8
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
havent done the injectors yet but it seems to run on all 4 when it working. just showed my father in law.
it kinda started straight away from cold with a couple of coughs, but cut out twice randomly when idling.
when you blip the throttle it tries to stall and the temp gage moves up and down with it, which is odd.
he said the cutting out could be the coil pack, cos its stopping all 4 sparks?? does this sound plausable for the problems encoutered?
seems when hot the problems kinda' get a little better but its not drivable the way it is.
any other ideas?
Si
it kinda started straight away from cold with a couple of coughs, but cut out twice randomly when idling.
when you blip the throttle it tries to stall and the temp gage moves up and down with it, which is odd.
he said the cutting out could be the coil pack, cos its stopping all 4 sparks?? does this sound plausable for the problems encoutered?
seems when hot the problems kinda' get a little better but its not drivable the way it is.
any other ideas?
Si
Last edited by SyHightower; 08 May 2005 at 06:03 PM.
#9
That still sunds like a tube or two off/leaking/in wrong place.
As you try to accellerate, the vac in the inlet changes and things have to work together.
As you are in Cheshire, why not get it to Scoobyclinic?
These probs drive you nuts I know too well.
The injector idea is a good one, and do the same with the plug leads too.
Keep telling us the results!
Graham.
As you try to accellerate, the vac in the inlet changes and things have to work together.
As you are in Cheshire, why not get it to Scoobyclinic?
These probs drive you nuts I know too well.
The injector idea is a good one, and do the same with the plug leads too.
Keep telling us the results!
Graham.
#11
I would say you have connected the ignition the wrong way round on one side of the engine.
try swapping the coilpacks/leads on ONE side. if it suddenly works then presto, otherwise, put them back and try the other side.
Also be aware that if you do have the ignition the wrong way round, you could be sending out lots of unburnt fuel and air through the exhaust. It can mean flames, or if you still have a cat then fireworks, and an exhaust system that glow red from top to tip.
Paul
try swapping the coilpacks/leads on ONE side. if it suddenly works then presto, otherwise, put them back and try the other side.
Also be aware that if you do have the ignition the wrong way round, you could be sending out lots of unburnt fuel and air through the exhaust. It can mean flames, or if you still have a cat then fireworks, and an exhaust system that glow red from top to tip.
Paul
#13
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
ignition leads are in the correct order, its kinda hard to get it wrong, my mate did his wrong once and that really didnt work well.
ive checked all wiring, all piping, theres no hissing, no oil leaks, no water leaks and checked ground wiring. and the injectors all work.
im now thinking wiring loom, or a sensor not working properly, or timing
whats the implications of a failing MAF? would it produce these problems? and lambda?
exhaust has a cat, fumes smell sweet, could be over fueling?
is there anymore diagnosticas i can do myself other that flatbedding it to a garage to be charged a fortune?
Si
ive checked all wiring, all piping, theres no hissing, no oil leaks, no water leaks and checked ground wiring. and the injectors all work.
im now thinking wiring loom, or a sensor not working properly, or timing
whats the implications of a failing MAF? would it produce these problems? and lambda?
exhaust has a cat, fumes smell sweet, could be over fueling?
is there anymore diagnosticas i can do myself other that flatbedding it to a garage to be charged a fortune?
Si
#14
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (2)
Join Date: May 2000
Location: Class record holder at Pembrey Llandow Goodwood MIRA Hethel Blyton Curborough Lydden and Snetterton
Posts: 8,626
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Have you checked the Idle control valve, and its air intake feed? I have / had a similar problem where idle would jump to about 1700 rpm and run very rich on the AFR. It was so rich any throttle would make it splutter.
Gave it a clean today and the problem hasn't come back after 30 miles of driving.
Gave it a clean today and the problem hasn't come back after 30 miles of driving.
#15
what year of car is it? you say it's had to get it wrong, but that's not the case if they are coil packs. You should double check the leads nonetheless.
There are some things you can do.
Get it running badly, then stop it dead, take out the plugs, look for badly sooted or wet plugs.
It you find a wet plug this means either no spark, or way too much fuel. Check the spart with clean plugs, and make sure there is a plug on every lead (check all sparks). If it actually sparks then it could be being massively overfuelled.
If only one plug was wet/sooted and they all spark when clean, then I would check the injectors are not leaking in the rails. If you have removed them, at any point, then check for o-rings not seated correctly (only really a big problem on the phase 1-1.5 injectors).
If all the plugs are badly sooted or wet, and you are getting sparks, then check the coolant temp sensor is plugged in properly.
Also (as a seperate test) unplug the lambda sensor before starting the car, this will force it to go open loop, if there are some funnies with the fuelling then it may run a little better like this. If this makes it sudden work much better, then it could be the sensor itself, or, if it's better but not great, then it's likely to be a misfire (which will fool the sensor). So possibly looking at a lean condition for some reason, possibly MAF sensor.
If it looks like it could be a MAF sensor problem (all plugs same, starts okay but then dies) try unplugging it start it again. When starting it will use a fixed injector pulse length (based on water temp not MAF readings) but once started, it will move to the MAF sensor, hence things can get better or worse after start up.
Personally I think it sounds like fuelling on startup and idle, so I would check out the coolan temp sensor, its a brown sensor mounted on water cross pipe that goes over engine, it will either be at the front to the left of the alternator (as you look at the engine bay standing in front of car), or on the back (of the water cross pipe) but still to the left of centre.
Paul
There are some things you can do.
Get it running badly, then stop it dead, take out the plugs, look for badly sooted or wet plugs.
It you find a wet plug this means either no spark, or way too much fuel. Check the spart with clean plugs, and make sure there is a plug on every lead (check all sparks). If it actually sparks then it could be being massively overfuelled.
If only one plug was wet/sooted and they all spark when clean, then I would check the injectors are not leaking in the rails. If you have removed them, at any point, then check for o-rings not seated correctly (only really a big problem on the phase 1-1.5 injectors).
If all the plugs are badly sooted or wet, and you are getting sparks, then check the coolant temp sensor is plugged in properly.
Also (as a seperate test) unplug the lambda sensor before starting the car, this will force it to go open loop, if there are some funnies with the fuelling then it may run a little better like this. If this makes it sudden work much better, then it could be the sensor itself, or, if it's better but not great, then it's likely to be a misfire (which will fool the sensor). So possibly looking at a lean condition for some reason, possibly MAF sensor.
If it looks like it could be a MAF sensor problem (all plugs same, starts okay but then dies) try unplugging it start it again. When starting it will use a fixed injector pulse length (based on water temp not MAF readings) but once started, it will move to the MAF sensor, hence things can get better or worse after start up.
Personally I think it sounds like fuelling on startup and idle, so I would check out the coolan temp sensor, its a brown sensor mounted on water cross pipe that goes over engine, it will either be at the front to the left of the alternator (as you look at the engine bay standing in front of car), or on the back (of the water cross pipe) but still to the left of centre.
Paul
#16
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
thanks for the input ill check tomorrow night.
the car is a UK MY97 Turbo
just to make sure the grounding is correct, the thick ground cable is connected to the starter motor onto the gearbox then obviously the block. as the engine has been painted and laquered could cause grounding problems?
Simon
the car is a UK MY97 Turbo
just to make sure the grounding is correct, the thick ground cable is connected to the starter motor onto the gearbox then obviously the block. as the engine has been painted and laquered could cause grounding problems?
Simon
#18
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
http://syhightower.no-ip.com/small/DSCF0019.JPG
is the the sensor the one 'above' the crank sensor, the other brown plug?
Si
is the the sensor the one 'above' the crank sensor, the other brown plug?
Si
#19
Originally Posted by Pavlo
what year of car is it? you say it's had to get it wrong, but that's not the case if they are coil packs. You should double check the leads nonetheless.
There are some things you can do.
Get it running badly, then stop it dead, take out the plugs, look for badly sooted or wet plugs.
It you find a wet plug this means either no spark, or way too much fuel. Check the spart with clean plugs, and make sure there is a plug on every lead (check all sparks). If it actually sparks then it could be being massively overfuelled.
If only one plug was wet/sooted and they all spark when clean, then I would check the injectors are not leaking in the rails. If you have removed them, at any point, then check for o-rings not seated correctly (only really a big problem on the phase 1-1.5 injectors).
If all the plugs are badly sooted or wet, and you are getting sparks, then check the coolant temp sensor is plugged in properly.
Also (as a seperate test) unplug the lambda sensor before starting the car, this will force it to go open loop, if there are some funnies with the fuelling then it may run a little better like this. If this makes it sudden work much better, then it could be the sensor itself, or, if it's better but not great, then it's likely to be a misfire (which will fool the sensor). So possibly looking at a lean condition for some reason, possibly MAF sensor.
If it looks like it could be a MAF sensor problem (all plugs same, starts okay but then dies) try unplugging it start it again. When starting it will use a fixed injector pulse length (based on water temp not MAF readings) but once started, it will move to the MAF sensor, hence things can get better or worse after start up.
Personally I think it sounds like fuelling on startup and idle, so I would check out the coolan temp sensor, its a brown sensor mounted on water cross pipe that goes over engine, it will either be at the front to the left of the alternator (as you look at the engine bay standing in front of car), or on the back (of the water cross pipe) but still to the left of centre.
Paul
There are some things you can do.
Get it running badly, then stop it dead, take out the plugs, look for badly sooted or wet plugs.
It you find a wet plug this means either no spark, or way too much fuel. Check the spart with clean plugs, and make sure there is a plug on every lead (check all sparks). If it actually sparks then it could be being massively overfuelled.
If only one plug was wet/sooted and they all spark when clean, then I would check the injectors are not leaking in the rails. If you have removed them, at any point, then check for o-rings not seated correctly (only really a big problem on the phase 1-1.5 injectors).
If all the plugs are badly sooted or wet, and you are getting sparks, then check the coolant temp sensor is plugged in properly.
Also (as a seperate test) unplug the lambda sensor before starting the car, this will force it to go open loop, if there are some funnies with the fuelling then it may run a little better like this. If this makes it sudden work much better, then it could be the sensor itself, or, if it's better but not great, then it's likely to be a misfire (which will fool the sensor). So possibly looking at a lean condition for some reason, possibly MAF sensor.
If it looks like it could be a MAF sensor problem (all plugs same, starts okay but then dies) try unplugging it start it again. When starting it will use a fixed injector pulse length (based on water temp not MAF readings) but once started, it will move to the MAF sensor, hence things can get better or worse after start up.
Personally I think it sounds like fuelling on startup and idle, so I would check out the coolan temp sensor, its a brown sensor mounted on water cross pipe that goes over engine, it will either be at the front to the left of the alternator (as you look at the engine bay standing in front of car), or on the back (of the water cross pipe) but still to the left of centre.
Paul
#20
Originally Posted by SyHightower
http://syhightower.no-ip.com/small/DSCF0019.JPG
is the the sensor the one 'above' the crank sensor, the other brown plug?
Si
is the the sensor the one 'above' the crank sensor, the other brown plug?
Si
#26
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
havent really had chance to look tonight but ive just disconnected the maf and started the engine and it ran horrible and cut out. i plugged back and its seems to idle ok, so i guess its not the maf then.
too busy working at home tonight to look at my car
will deffo try tomorrow
Si
too busy working at home tonight to look at my car
will deffo try tomorrow
Si
#28
Former Sponsor
iTrader: (4)
Join Date: Jul 2003
Location: @Junc 12, M40 Warwicksh; 01926 614522 CV33 9PL -Use 9GX for Satnav. South Mids Alcatek ECu dealer
Posts: 6,377
Likes: 0
Received 3 Likes
on
3 Posts
Simon, Sounds like some crossed wires somewhere, especially with the temp gauge going up and down etc., etc.
You need to be careful, because of the unburnt fuel going into the engine washing the bores. Next thing, you'll drag a piston skirt due to lack of lubtrication and have piston slap.
If at all possible try to get another simila car and check your wiring connections correspond with theirs. Usually the wiring when laid on the engine sort of lines up naturally. Anything stretched or at a funny angle generally indicates a crossed connection.
Good luck Kind regards
David APi Engines / APi lmpreza
www.apiengines.com
You need to be careful, because of the unburnt fuel going into the engine washing the bores. Next thing, you'll drag a piston skirt due to lack of lubtrication and have piston slap.
If at all possible try to get another simila car and check your wiring connections correspond with theirs. Usually the wiring when laid on the engine sort of lines up naturally. Anything stretched or at a funny angle generally indicates a crossed connection.
Good luck Kind regards
David APi Engines / APi lmpreza
www.apiengines.com
#29
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Mar 2003
Location: Cheshire
Posts: 532
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
how embarasing :o
omg!!!
just found the problem. The bolt holding grounding wire on the manifold was loose
after i had checked every pipe, wire, spark, it was just the one i over looked. ***** sake. well its the only good thing that happened today. I was told today at 5:25pm i was being made redundant - over the phone. Saw him today as well. chicken ****. or is it because im 6'10"
Simon
just found the problem. The bolt holding grounding wire on the manifold was loose
after i had checked every pipe, wire, spark, it was just the one i over looked. ***** sake. well its the only good thing that happened today. I was told today at 5:25pm i was being made redundant - over the phone. Saw him today as well. chicken ****. or is it because im 6'10"
Simon
Last edited by SyHightower; 10 May 2005 at 10:00 PM.