Are scoobys over rated?
#451
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (6)
Join Date: May 2012
Location: Cardiff
Posts: 3,221
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
not watched it yet, but that spoiler is foooking hugh! haha
Mk2 RS, what power is your scoob then? As i know a mk1 FRS is quite a weapon when running around 350bhp!!!
Quite a few mk2's have made over 500ft lb torque when running a 400+ kit, so as you can imagine, they can be quite an animal...
His is a puma speed conversion, sounds bloody lovely tho ill give it that when it's going for it
#453
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Near milton keynes
Posts: 840
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
you really are a tool, its an aerodynamic aid that helped him win totb.
f1 cars must be crap then as they have big wings too, im sure an rs could beat them around a track too.
people have shown you videos of rs getting beaten by imprezas backed up by top gear tests etc.
so wheres your evidence?, the only argument you have so far is your mate kicked your **** in his fiesta because you cant drive.
f1 cars must be crap then as they have big wings too, im sure an rs could beat them around a track too.
people have shown you videos of rs getting beaten by imprezas backed up by top gear tests etc.
so wheres your evidence?, the only argument you have so far is your mate kicked your **** in his fiesta because you cant drive.
All the videos youve put up and links have all either been in the wet or off the line.... i know it sounds like im being picky, but thats the scoobs 2 specialites, poor weather conditions and gettign off the line.... dry road rolling start, 30-130 the RS would win....
Look foward to my flake
#458
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Near milton keynes
Posts: 840
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Im pritty sure in real world conditions in the wet, from a rolling start the focus would still win... the 2 secs on the top gear vid is probably half the advantage it got from launching..
#459
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (10)
Join Date: Apr 2010
Location: preston
Posts: 2,081
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I like mine too just a modest 437/400 but held my own with a gtr at totb
and had a load of fun on the handling circuit
(Saturday practice went a lot better than sunday )
only ford there worth a mention was a Ford Granada 6.3 Ltr called the beast
I think you need some driving lessons ash
get your mum to apply for your provisional m8
and had a load of fun on the handling circuit
(Saturday practice went a lot better than sunday )
only ford there worth a mention was a Ford Granada 6.3 Ltr called the beast
I think you need some driving lessons ash
get your mum to apply for your provisional m8
Last edited by Dave-W-; 31 July 2013 at 04:23 PM.
#463
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: Wales
Posts: 2,794
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Or did you mean on that same course in the dry?
Last edited by LuckyWelshchap; 31 July 2013 at 05:09 PM. Reason: Afterthought
#465
Scooby Regular
I came from the FWD Blue Oval ST arena... Granted, it was a 13 year old Mondeo ST, but after stepping into a Scoob (albeit only a WRX) I wouldn't say they're overrated. It has taken me 3 months to get used to the the behaviour in and out of corners at speed of course, and I still have a lot to learn, despite always having FWD/RWD performance motors with the exception of 1 or 2.
I think the difference on how people feel about Scoobs is this: I never bought the car with expectations of super car performance, I bought it with expectations of AWD, and a 5.8 second 0-60 (2.5 seconds faster than my blue oval) and that's exactly what I got.
So do I think that Scoobs are overrated? No. I got exactly what I expected. I could've bought and Audi, a Beemer, or another Ford ST, but I bought the Scoob, and I'd do it again. Simply because it challenged everything I knew about the way a car cornered at speed, and still does!
I think the difference on how people feel about Scoobs is this: I never bought the car with expectations of super car performance, I bought it with expectations of AWD, and a 5.8 second 0-60 (2.5 seconds faster than my blue oval) and that's exactly what I got.
So do I think that Scoobs are overrated? No. I got exactly what I expected. I could've bought and Audi, a Beemer, or another Ford ST, but I bought the Scoob, and I'd do it again. Simply because it challenged everything I knew about the way a car cornered at speed, and still does!
#466
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Mar 2013
Location: Wales
Posts: 2,794
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I came from the FWD Blue Oval ST arena... Granted, it was a 13 year old Mondeo ST, but after stepping into a Scoob (albeit only a WRX) I wouldn't say they're overrated. It has taken me 3 months to get used to the the behaviour in and out of corners at speed of course, and I still have a lot to learn, despite always having FWD/RWD performance motors with the exception of 1 or 2.
I think the difference on how people feel about Scoobs is this: I never bought the car with expectations of super car performance, I bought it with expectations of AWD, and a 5.8 second 0-60 (2.5 seconds faster than my blue oval) and that's exactly what I got.
So do I think that Scoobs are overrated? No. I got exactly what I expected. I could've bought and Audi, a Beemer, or another Ford ST, but I bought the Scoob, and I'd do it again. Simply because it challenged everything I knew about the way a car cornered at speed, and still does!
I think the difference on how people feel about Scoobs is this: I never bought the car with expectations of super car performance, I bought it with expectations of AWD, and a 5.8 second 0-60 (2.5 seconds faster than my blue oval) and that's exactly what I got.
So do I think that Scoobs are overrated? No. I got exactly what I expected. I could've bought and Audi, a Beemer, or another Ford ST, but I bought the Scoob, and I'd do it again. Simply because it challenged everything I knew about the way a car cornered at speed, and still does!
We're now starting to take the 'common sense approach'.
*You hear a lot about a car;
* You see if it does everything it says on the box;
*MORE importantly, you make sure it's like that;
There's no personal criticism ( even if you think there is and some come over as meaning it).
Bring it up in the Winter, and drive impassively as you overtake an Audi, fezzer, Volvo etc. You'll spread OUR word.
#467
I will answer in a mature way regardless of some of the silly things you have said..
Mate you deffo need to get your cars handling checked out as there's something not right..maybe the bushes need replacing? Do you have a rolling road print out? Is it using oil? Good compression??
I have a good experience of a few cars from the 300bhp r5 gt I currently own along with my impreza p1 running 550bhp and my v8 m3 I recently sold along with the mrs e46 m3 convertible and all the other type r/gti's bla bla bla that I used to own back in the day.
Iv owned my p1 for nearly 6 years now and I'm 29 years old and it started at standard power 280 bhp being the same as your type r to what it is now weighing 1270kg and 550bhp putting a whipping on Nissan gt-r's. I did it in stages of standard power to 330bhp to 370bhp to 415 to 450 to now being capable of 600bhp.
Directly Before my p1 I owned a mk1 focus rs when they first came out which was eventually stolen but regardless was running 360bhp on a gt28rs turbo with original ford Motorsport manifold, dreamscience and the full works from puma speed being pistons, rods, copper head gasket..the works!
And in a nut shell my impreza would give my focus rs a right pasting and that's no lie!
I'd have wheelspin/torque steer in from 1st to 3rd in the rs and by then my impreza would be a mile down the road "doing" 60 in 4 seconds at the time (now doing 3 and a bit lol) before the rs could finally put the power down on the rs which once it stuck would then fly but with just a basic remap exhaust and filter on my impreza my rs would then be put away for good! It only took 320 odd bhp for my p1 to beat my rs in every department even though the rs had more power. The rs handled amazing but the coil overs on my impreza dealt with that and the alcons on my impreza dealt with my rs's brembo's.
In every department it was beat and as I said that was after spending a mere 2k on modding my p1 to 330bhp at the time compared to the 10k plus I spent on modding my rs to run 360bhp. Loved my rs and I'd argue to the death like you when I was your age but there comes a time for a boy to turn to a man that was done once I got my p1 and il never look at a fwd for performance again.
I drove the new rs and it was ok..but it just felt like a modded st and front wheel drives are limited in what they can do so I wouldn't buy one.
The new rs weighs over 1400kg which is heavy compared to a classic impreza so there's your first head start.. Spend a little money on your impreza to make it run a genuine 330bhp and you'll make your mates 350bhp rs look silly. At 330 bhp I was doing 12 second 1/4 miles at Santa pod and your mate in his 400bhp rs would be lucky to do that in 13 as the last time I was at the pod there was a few modded rs's that couldn't beat 13. 1.. 1 whole second is a lot of difference!!!
In relation to a fiesta I won't even go there but as I said there is deffo a problem going on.. You should be running rings around him!
I'm always up for a laugh and sometimes il see some Leary **** in their suped up golf, rs etc and once I floor it's bye bye time followed by me then slowing down waiting for them to catch up and doing it all over again (yes I'm immature lol) however I try to save my power for more serious machines now days as I can't be arsed to waste the fuel anymore.
An impreza classic like a type r is a brilliant weapon of choice, There's not many cars in this world that have 4wd and weigh less then every modern fwd out there.. That's a brilliant recipe for a fast car! But you need to move with the times an update a few things.. Brakes, suspension and a few horses and it will then be a 2013 vehicle with 330 bhp weighing around 1270kg which is pretty quick!. To give you a comparison an m5 with 500 horses weighs over 1800kg!!! In other words I think you will then be very impressed with your subaru! Spend some more money after that and its skies the limit whipping super cars all day long if you want it too which is what mine does.
Ps if your even thinking about a cossie for performance I'd stay well clear as they will be twice as slow as your impreza.. Don't get me wrong i ABSOLUTLEY love cossies and was about to buy one but if your impreza is 13 years old then the cossie is 20 years lol with 80's tec and wooly suspension and with out spending a lot of dollar it won't be going anywhere very fast unless you buy a modded one which had already had thousands spent on to raise the baby 225 bhp they begin with.
Mate you deffo need to get your cars handling checked out as there's something not right..maybe the bushes need replacing? Do you have a rolling road print out? Is it using oil? Good compression??
I have a good experience of a few cars from the 300bhp r5 gt I currently own along with my impreza p1 running 550bhp and my v8 m3 I recently sold along with the mrs e46 m3 convertible and all the other type r/gti's bla bla bla that I used to own back in the day.
Iv owned my p1 for nearly 6 years now and I'm 29 years old and it started at standard power 280 bhp being the same as your type r to what it is now weighing 1270kg and 550bhp putting a whipping on Nissan gt-r's. I did it in stages of standard power to 330bhp to 370bhp to 415 to 450 to now being capable of 600bhp.
Directly Before my p1 I owned a mk1 focus rs when they first came out which was eventually stolen but regardless was running 360bhp on a gt28rs turbo with original ford Motorsport manifold, dreamscience and the full works from puma speed being pistons, rods, copper head gasket..the works!
And in a nut shell my impreza would give my focus rs a right pasting and that's no lie!
I'd have wheelspin/torque steer in from 1st to 3rd in the rs and by then my impreza would be a mile down the road "doing" 60 in 4 seconds at the time (now doing 3 and a bit lol) before the rs could finally put the power down on the rs which once it stuck would then fly but with just a basic remap exhaust and filter on my impreza my rs would then be put away for good! It only took 320 odd bhp for my p1 to beat my rs in every department even though the rs had more power. The rs handled amazing but the coil overs on my impreza dealt with that and the alcons on my impreza dealt with my rs's brembo's.
In every department it was beat and as I said that was after spending a mere 2k on modding my p1 to 330bhp at the time compared to the 10k plus I spent on modding my rs to run 360bhp. Loved my rs and I'd argue to the death like you when I was your age but there comes a time for a boy to turn to a man that was done once I got my p1 and il never look at a fwd for performance again.
I drove the new rs and it was ok..but it just felt like a modded st and front wheel drives are limited in what they can do so I wouldn't buy one.
The new rs weighs over 1400kg which is heavy compared to a classic impreza so there's your first head start.. Spend a little money on your impreza to make it run a genuine 330bhp and you'll make your mates 350bhp rs look silly. At 330 bhp I was doing 12 second 1/4 miles at Santa pod and your mate in his 400bhp rs would be lucky to do that in 13 as the last time I was at the pod there was a few modded rs's that couldn't beat 13. 1.. 1 whole second is a lot of difference!!!
In relation to a fiesta I won't even go there but as I said there is deffo a problem going on.. You should be running rings around him!
I'm always up for a laugh and sometimes il see some Leary **** in their suped up golf, rs etc and once I floor it's bye bye time followed by me then slowing down waiting for them to catch up and doing it all over again (yes I'm immature lol) however I try to save my power for more serious machines now days as I can't be arsed to waste the fuel anymore.
An impreza classic like a type r is a brilliant weapon of choice, There's not many cars in this world that have 4wd and weigh less then every modern fwd out there.. That's a brilliant recipe for a fast car! But you need to move with the times an update a few things.. Brakes, suspension and a few horses and it will then be a 2013 vehicle with 330 bhp weighing around 1270kg which is pretty quick!. To give you a comparison an m5 with 500 horses weighs over 1800kg!!! In other words I think you will then be very impressed with your subaru! Spend some more money after that and its skies the limit whipping super cars all day long if you want it too which is what mine does.
Ps if your even thinking about a cossie for performance I'd stay well clear as they will be twice as slow as your impreza.. Don't get me wrong i ABSOLUTLEY love cossies and was about to buy one but if your impreza is 13 years old then the cossie is 20 years lol with 80's tec and wooly suspension and with out spending a lot of dollar it won't be going anywhere very fast unless you buy a modded one which had already had thousands spent on to raise the baby 225 bhp they begin with.
Last edited by P1power; 01 August 2013 at 02:41 AM.
#469
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2007
Location: location, location, location
Posts: 1,458
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Ps if your even thinking about a cossie for performance I'd stay well clear as they will be twice as slow as your impreza.. Don't get me wrong i ABSOLUTLEY love cossies and was about to buy one but if your impreza is 13 years old then the cossie is 20 years lol with 80's tec and wooly suspension and with out spending a lot of dollar it won't be going anywhere very fast unless you buy a modded one which had already had thousands spent on to raise the baby 225 bhp they begin with.
#472
Don't agree with that statement to be honest. Having owned a 3 door for some years, and also a Subaru I would say there's not much in it. The Cosworth is more fun to drive though, due to the twitchyness. Yes, they are laggy but when you hit full boost on a T4 turbo there's nothing quite like it. It's all about what YOU want out of a car at the end of the day.
Once youv uprated the suspension, brakes, fat wheels with sticky rubber and added an extra 80bhp to the cossie then it's a fair playing field and anyones race.
I think this was actually covered on a very old episode of top gear lol.
But as i said I'm not dissing the cossie in anyway so don't get me wrong as like I said they are still amazing cars which I'd still love to own in a heartbeat.
Last edited by P1power; 01 August 2013 at 01:00 PM.
#473
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: Aberdeen
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I'm on an ST and RS owners forum and I think I might post a link. When I posted what I'd bought I'd quite a few RS owners commenting on how it was an awesome bit of kit. On the forum I'm on 90% of the guys accept that the Ford ST and RS ranges are just very well sorted examples of mass market cars and don't share the dillusion that they are the best thing since sliced bread. They appreciate and know their limits. I loved my old 220 and having driven Fiesta STs, Focus STs and RSs and Mondeo STs I can say that they do offer a lot, but they are not Impreza rivals, nor do they pretend to be. The Focus RS is a pretty quick and comfortable car that is necely spec'd, cheap enough to run and service and handles very well for a FWD hatch. It is a completely different proposition from a Type R Impreza. Or any Impreza.
I wouldn't bash someone for buying an ST or an RS - I know it's a popular band wagon to be anti Ford on this kind of forum, but in truth they do make some good cars. But I also would never try and say that a Fiesta ST is a match for an Impreza. It's just not. They are good fun as you can grab them by the scruff of the neck and thrash them while never worrying about much chance of a big oversteer moment and they are very easy to learn to drive at 90% of their limit. The Impreza is not such an easy car to learn. After 3000 miles in mine I'm still growing in confidence with what mine can do and am learning more about it by the day. I fear Ash may just be too used to the ease with which you can jump into a well sorted FWD hatchback and isn't prepared to try to learn how to drive his car correctly. But, if he does decide to listen to what people are telling him he might find he has a much better car beneath him than he chooses to believe.
I wouldn't bash someone for buying an ST or an RS - I know it's a popular band wagon to be anti Ford on this kind of forum, but in truth they do make some good cars. But I also would never try and say that a Fiesta ST is a match for an Impreza. It's just not. They are good fun as you can grab them by the scruff of the neck and thrash them while never worrying about much chance of a big oversteer moment and they are very easy to learn to drive at 90% of their limit. The Impreza is not such an easy car to learn. After 3000 miles in mine I'm still growing in confidence with what mine can do and am learning more about it by the day. I fear Ash may just be too used to the ease with which you can jump into a well sorted FWD hatchback and isn't prepared to try to learn how to drive his car correctly. But, if he does decide to listen to what people are telling him he might find he has a much better car beneath him than he chooses to believe.
#477
Scooby Regular
Thread Starter
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Nov 2011
Location: Near milton keynes
Posts: 840
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
#479
Scooby Regular
iTrader: (7)
Mate you need to give in and just admit that you need some tuition, it's nothing to be ashamed of, everyone has to start somewhere, most pro drivers even in F1 have ongoing tuition.
Seriously, when you book your next track day just have a few laps with an instructor as well, it will be better than any mods you can do to your car.
Edit to add: I along with many others on here i'm sure have had a fair bit of tuition on track in cars and on bikes, I even went to the British rally school for my birthday when I first got my Type R, because it was so different to my previous WRX, and when I got a 4x4 I had a week end at the Land Rover off road experience centre so I'd know what I was doing off road, there is no shame in admitting you don't know what your doing and getting someone to show you the error of your ways.
Last edited by ditchmyster; 01 August 2013 at 02:56 PM.
#480
Scooby Regular
Join Date: Apr 2013
Location: Aberdeen
Posts: 85
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
He has been given every possible opportunity to say, 'ok guyes, maybe I need to change my driving technique here', but no. Instead we are all idiots. And he won't even listen to good adive when he gets given it. Oh dear. He'll learn one day. Meantime, if he has a GoPro I'm sure we would all be much obliged if he would upload some footage of his driving so we can see this driving God in action.