ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   General Technical (https://www.scoobynet.com/general-technical-10/)
-   -   K-Sport or D2?? (https://www.scoobynet.com/general-technical-10/912350-k-sport-or-d2.html)

mnem1c 07 November 2011 09:56 PM

K-Sport or D2??
 
Looking to upgrade my front brakes. Which is a better kit, K-Sport or D2?

Cheers all

-shane- 07 November 2011 10:04 PM

I belive there the same kit

t16mbo 07 November 2011 10:08 PM

Was told k sports are not as strong as d2. I got d2s and they wicked

Scooby Parts 07 November 2011 10:09 PM

3 Attachment(s)
Easy, Brembos:lol1:

All you need for fast road use.

Cheaper to buy, and MUCH cheaper for replacement pads and discs.

I had Brembos on my UK300 and STI, D2's on my 350bhp classic and K Sports on my P1.

Attachment 55998

Attachment 55999

Attachment 56000

mnem1c 07 November 2011 10:14 PM

I heard that k-sports have dust covers for the pots??

I agree that Brembos are great brakes but i want 8pots with 356mm disks

Scooby Parts 07 November 2011 10:23 PM

They are the same brakes from the same factory

mnem1c 07 November 2011 10:30 PM


Originally Posted by Scooby Parts (Post 10321062)
They are the same brakes from the same factory

Did you notice any difference in how they perform?

LegacySTi 08 November 2011 01:08 AM

they are the exact same

mazmike 08 November 2011 10:17 AM

i use brembos with performance friction 2 piece rotors and carbotec xp12 pads .as good as AP

Godspeed Brakes 08 November 2011 11:26 AM

Yeah I know there the same but are they any better lol :D


K sport and D2 are the same kits , made in the same factory but badged up differently , they do not have any dust seals , they only have hydraulic seals , which are fitted to the piston not inside the bore of the caliper like most calipers are .

TonyBurns 08 November 2011 12:14 PM

Speak to Ian about his AP kits ;) much better all round :D

Tony:)

jura11 08 November 2011 12:55 PM


Originally Posted by Ian Godney (Post 10321615)
Yeah I know there the same but are they any better lol :D


K sport and D2 are the same kits , made in the same factory but badged up differently , they do not have any dust seals , they only have hydraulic seals , which are fitted to the piston not inside the bore of the caliper like most calipers are .

Same as BC Coilovers,Megan,Apex etc. made in same factory,but difference between these few is different.

Ian how many times you are replaced pistons/dust shield in Brembo/AP or rebuild'd calipers?

And how many times you are replaced pistons in K-sport or rebuild'd calipers?

I'm pretty sure you are done more Brembo/AP than K-sport,maybe i'm wrong.

Here is quote form K-sport website about the dust shields:


I saw that K-Sport brake calipers have no dust shield seals. How does it look then with the durability?
K-Sport brake calipers have forged aluminum brake pistons with a Hardcoat coating. Other manufacturers use steel piston, this rust then with the aluminum caliper together trought humidity. Steel and aluminum do not get along, since a local cell develops (electrochemistry) and the base metal is oxidized. The material mating, the Eloxal of the calipers and the Hardcoat coating of the forging pistons prevent a fixed rusting. Further the pistons of other manufacturers are equipped with only one sealing ring, these seal the brake fluid outward. The K-Sport forging brake pistons are equipped with two seals. The internal sealing ring serves the brake fluid (the system keeps close) for sealing, the outside sealing ring prevents the penetration and a determining of dirt.
This building method is most innovative and compact. Conventional dust shield seals are useless with K-Sport brake calipers.
If you are looking on feedback on these brakes,you will see its nothing wrong with these brakes,people like them and people use them on track days/TA or drag.

Who cares how much cost,if they're perform better that's the most important thing in my view,as i said everything is down to pads,if you are using supplied K-Sport pads,yes these are horrible,but with PF pads or even EBC BlueStuff NDX...

If AP cost similar money than K-Sport i would go with these without the doubts,but if they're cost 2-3 times more than K-sport,sorry no.

Jura

TonyBurns 08 November 2011 01:00 PM

Jura you have not seen the cost of Ian's AP setup, its not much more than the Ksport/D2's ;)

Tony:)

mnem1c 08 November 2011 01:10 PM

Cheers for the info guys. Just phone Apex (K-Sport) and they are out of stock with the set up that i want. Any other dealers? had a uk google search and nothing. Apex said they'll have some in by the 20th Dec.

Rather have them sooner than later. My brakes are terrible and this bad weather is not helping.

mnem1c 08 November 2011 01:15 PM

Aztec Performance have some in stock on their website but the number is just ringing out

Anyone used this company??

jura11 08 November 2011 01:18 PM


Originally Posted by TonyBurns (Post 10321764)
Jura you have not seen the cost of Ian's AP setup, its not much more than the Ksport/D2's ;)

Tony:)

Thanks no,i will rather keep mine K-sport and later on i've just upgrade mine discs to PF;)


Jura

jura11 08 November 2011 01:20 PM


Originally Posted by mnem1c (Post 10321785)
Aztec Performance have some in stock on their website but the number is just ringing out

Anyone used this company??

Bob is here too,but sometimes is hard to hold.

Just try and send him too PM and ring him later.


Jura

Godspeed Brakes 08 November 2011 01:24 PM

1 Attachment(s)
The AP and Brembo calipers also use aluminium pistons ,

I have changed pistons on the older style AP calipers , as they don't have a rubber boot covering the pistons , they have a dust seal sitting in a groove at the top of the bore of the calipers , this seal will stop muck/dust getting into the caliper , but will not protect the pistons.

The later style AP calipers with the rubber boots covering the pistons are the same design as the STi calipers , I have never had to change the pistons to date on either of these calipers , only seals.

The downside of the K sport / D2 caliper designs is that the way they seal , An AP or Brembo caliper has the hydraulic seal in a groove machined into the bore of the caliper , so the piston will move on this seal , if the bore or piston is ever scored or damaged , then it could still be used again , you would fit new pistons with a perfect surface that seals on the actual seal itself , if the K sport caliper bores get scored or damaged , the caliper is scrap , as the seal on these are fitted to the bottom of the piston , its the piston and seal that move in the bore , so the surface of the bore always has to be perfect

Attachment 56001

Here you can see the calipers with the pistons out , the 2 seals are at the bottom of the bore , so there is nothing stopping dust getting into the bore down to the first seal , this could be a problem with people getting damaged bores , which cannot be repaired , I haven't heard of anyone having any problems yet , but it can happen

The AP or Brembo seals are a much better design in my opinion

mnem1c 08 November 2011 01:42 PM

Thanks for the info Ian. The only thing thats put me off AP brakes is the price. My budget is £1000 and for the money Apex can do 8pots with 356mm for £849. I know AP are a better brake and i have done my research, but for the money K-Sports are winning.

jura11 08 November 2011 01:50 PM

Ian but this is older model of K-Sport,i think he little bit modified caliper and other things,but maybe again i'm wrong

I've done research before i bought mine K-sport front and rear one,i know they don't have dust seals and from mine experience and lots of search on other forums,.


Jura

TonyBurns 08 November 2011 01:55 PM


Originally Posted by mnem1c (Post 10321848)
Thanks for the info Ian. The only thing thats put me off AP brakes is the price. My budget is £1000 and for the money Apex can do 8pots with 356mm for £849. I know AP are a better brake and i have done my research, but for the money K-Sports are winning.

Everyone thinks that more pots or bigger discs always = better, thats not necessarily true, I think its about the ammount of pressure on the surface area or something like that, and if you have a nice chat with Ian (oh and you need 18's for the 356mm), you may get something within your budget that are better ;):D

Tony:)

jura11 08 November 2011 02:10 PM


Originally Posted by TonyBurns (Post 10321867)
Everyone thinks that more pots or bigger discs always = better, thats not necessarily true, I think its about the ammount of pressure on the surface area or something like that, and if you have a nice chat with Ian (oh and you need 18's for the 356mm), you may get something within your budget that are better ;):D

Tony:)

Tony due this i said everything is done to pads and disc used,i've done mine research on this too.

OE 4pots are poor on New age and on classic too if you are looking for above 350bhp or less,i've tried too OE 4pots with big brake conversion,but still not the best solution there.

Jura

mnem1c 08 November 2011 02:11 PM


Originally Posted by TonyBurns (Post 10321867)
Everyone thinks that more pots or bigger discs always = better, thats not necessarily true, I think its about the ammount of pressure on the surface area or something like that, and if you have a nice chat with Ian (oh and you need 18's for the 356mm), you may get something within your budget that are better ;):D

Tony:)

I agree Tony. Im sure that the AP 4 or 6 pots with 330mm might have the same or better stopping performance but i have never drove a car with APs on. I drove my friends Sti Blob with the same K-sport kit i want and was amazed with the brakes.

I own a Classic so a less weight. Ive got 18s so the 356mm disks wont be a problem

bren@apex 08 November 2011 02:42 PM


Originally Posted by mnem1c (Post 10321776)
Cheers for the info guys. Just phone Apex (K-Sport) and they are out of stock with the set up that i want. Any other dealers? had a uk google search and nothing. Apex said they'll have some in by the 20th Dec.

Rather have them sooner than later. My brakes are terrible and this bad weather is not helping.

We can airfreight them to get them here quicker :)

With regards to reliability of the kits, theyre superb and have been proven to be so over the past 6 years and many thousands of kits that we have sold :)

TonyBurns 08 November 2011 02:47 PM


Originally Posted by jura11 (Post 10321885)
Tony due this i said everything is done to pads and disc used,i've done mine research on this too.

OE 4pots are poor on New age and on classic too if you are looking for above 350bhp or less,i've tried too OE 4pots with big brake conversion,but still not the best solution there.

Jura

I changed my subaru 4 pots on my standard classic back in 2001 to Brembo/ap (308mm), much improved ;)

Tony:)

t16mbo 08 November 2011 06:12 PM

Japspeed do d2 brakes

mnem1c 10 November 2011 11:13 AM


Originally Posted by bren@apex (Post 10321925)
We can airfreight them to get them here quicker :)

With regards to reliability of the kits, theyre superb and have been proven to be so over the past 6 years and many thousands of kits that we have sold :)

Cheers Bren for your help, looking forward to getting those brakes on my car

What fluid would you recommend, Dot 5.1?

bren@apex 10 November 2011 11:23 AM

Yep. We have just recieved a batch of Halfords Dot 5.1 high performance fluid. Dont laugh, we have found it to be an excellent fast road and limited track product. Its very good value for money too.

We also have Motul Dot 5.1 and can also supply Moutl RBF 600 and RBF 660 should you want to go hardcore.

mnem1c 10 November 2011 11:41 AM

Cheers Bren, might try the Halfords 5.1 :)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 02:00 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands