ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   Suspension (https://www.scoobynet.com/suspension-12/)
-   -   Powerflex Rear Drop Links - A Warning (https://www.scoobynet.com/suspension-12/783683-powerflex-rear-drop-links-a-warning.html)

Cannon Fodder 13 August 2009 10:17 PM

Powerflex Rear Drop Links - A Warning
 
Whilst having my car detailed today I had to remove the wheels and when I took off the O/S/R wheel what did I find? :wonder: The top bush of the link arm was totally missing and the anti-roll bar was in effect floating at the top. :eek:

These links have only been on the car for around 8 months and the car only passed its first MOT test 6 weeks ago when I presume that they would have been checked and found to be ok. :confused:

I am getting them replaced tomorrow with Whiteline links :) but I thought I would post up on here just so that other forum members with the same Powerflex links might like to check them just to ensure the same thing does not happen to you. :mad:

http://i580.photobucket.com/albums/s...t/IMG_0077.jpg

http://i580.photobucket.com/albums/s...t/IMG_0079.jpg

The rookie 14 August 2009 12:00 PM

Bolts snapped or nut undone is the Q I guess, alloy link looks OK, so probably not fair to blame powerflex?

Simon

Cannon Fodder 14 August 2009 01:50 PM


Originally Posted by The rookie (Post 8880910)
Bolts snapped or nut undone is the Q I guess, alloy link looks OK, so probably not fair to blame powerflex?

Simon

Ok I can understand what you are saying but it is just as probable that the bush failed causing the bolt to flop about and the nut to unwind.

I am not looking to blame Powerflex but merely to warn others of what happened to me before it happens to them. I did incidentally check the nuts after 150 miles just to check they were still tight.

R1CH D 14 August 2009 02:32 PM

Bloody hell ty,:eek: explains why you were so slow over the blacks. lol.:luxhello:

mshill 14 August 2009 02:47 PM

That's bloody strange:confused:
how would the bolt unwind, did you have the bolts with the nylon lock thingy?

reason i ask is i have the very same set up, need to check they are okay!

also the bush would not be able to pop out 1st as there should be a large washer to prevent this?

take a picture of the good side

Cannon Fodder 14 August 2009 02:59 PM


Originally Posted by welshy12 (Post 8881161)
Bloody hell ty,:eek: explains why you were so slow over the blacks. lol.:luxhello:

I thought the handling was a bit off :lol1:


Originally Posted by mshill (Post 8881190)
That's bloody strange:confused:
how would the bolt unwind, did you have the bolts with the nylon lock thingy?

reason i ask is i have the very same set up, need to check they are okay!

also the bush would not be able to pop out 1st as there should be a large washer to prevent this?

take a picture of the good side

Both links have been changed and I am picking the car up later, I will take some pics of both links and post them up. :)

The nuts were nylocs so they should have not unwound so it is quite probable that the bush failed. :eek:

DJ_Jon 14 August 2009 03:21 PM

maybe the bolt sheared in half

Cannon Fodder 14 August 2009 03:43 PM


Originally Posted by DJ_Jon (Post 8881243)
maybe the bolt sheared in half

Very possible as the bolts are only have a tensile strength of 8.8 whereas I would think that 10.9 or 12.1 are more suitable given the stress on the bolt as it is in effect a pivot point. :wonder:

JDM_Stig 14 August 2009 04:29 PM

Id say the bolt snapped or came out/nut not replaced when the drop links were fitted maybe? old nuts arent great,
The reason I say bolt out is if the bush had come loose you would have had a clunk bolt on ARB as you didnt id say bolt came out and bush then fell out over time.

Cannon Fodder 14 August 2009 05:22 PM


Originally Posted by JDM_Stig (Post 8881367)
Id say the bolt snapped or came out/nut not replaced when the drop links were fitted maybe? old nuts arent great,
The reason I say bolt out is if the bush had come loose you would have had a clunk bolt on ARB as you didnt id say bolt came out and bush then fell out over time.

New nuts were fitted when the drop links were changed, and they were checked after 150 miles.

redwards 15 August 2009 10:57 AM


Originally Posted by mshill (Post 8881190)
That's bloody strange:confused:
how would the bolt unwind, did you have the bolts with the nylon lock thingy?

reason i ask is i have the very same set up, need to check they are okay!

also the bush would not be able to pop out 1st as there should be a large washer to prevent this?

take a picture of the good side

Here's a pic of them fitted, you can see the large washer that would stop the bush pulling though.
https://www.scoobynet.com/picture.ph...pictureid=6577

I fitted these and made sure everything was greased and torqued properly, using nyloc nuts. I suspect the bolt sheared or the thread was stripped from the bolt/nut causing it to come undone. The bushes are a 2 piece construction with a metal sleeve going through the middle, as soon as the bolt come out, it wouldn’t take long for the bush to come apart. If the bush failed then it's likely the bolt would still be attached to the ARB.

Big thanks to Ty for not 'pointing the finger' :notworthy, some people would immediately go back and blame the person who fitted them.

I glad you found this out as soon as you did, I know some of us SWS guys enjoy fully committed driving:norty: and to have something give mid corner is likely to not have a happy ending.

Lets hope the whiteline items can stand up to the punishment Wales' road give them.

Rich.

Cannon Fodder 15 August 2009 11:22 AM


Originally Posted by rsedwards (Post 8882650)
Here's a pic of them fitted, you can see the large washer that would stop the bush pulling though.
https://www.scoobynet.com/picture.ph...pictureid=6577

I fitted these and made sure everything was greased and torqued properly, using nyloc nuts. I suspect the bolt sheared or the thread was stripped from the bolt/nut causing it to come undone. The bushes are a 2 piece construction with a metal sleeve going through the middle, as soon as the bolt come out, it wouldn’t take long for the bush to come apart. If the bush failed then it's likely the bolt would still be attached to the ARB.

Big thanks to Ty for not 'pointing the finger' :notworthy, some people would immediately go back and blame the person who fitted them.

I glad you found this out as soon as you did, I know some of us SWS guys enjoy fully committed driving:norty: and to have something give mid corner is likely to not have a happy ending.

Lets hope the whiteline items can stand up to the punishment Wales' road give them.

Rich.

No problem Rich, I would not blame anyone or even the manufacturer for the failure as the cause of the failure can only ever be conjecture as a number of reasons could have caused the problem. :)

The mostly like cause is the bolt shearing but as I have already stated I cannot understand when the bolt is in a stressed position at a pivot point for the anti-roll bar why only 8.8 bolts are used when at least 10.9 bolts would be a better fitment. :wonder:

I posted up merely to warn others and to encourage them to check their drop links as I would not like this failure to happen to anyone else especially if they are 'giving it the beans'. :eek:

Mother Theresa 20 August 2009 08:16 PM

Mine did that too, I just thought it was a one off due to too much hooning around. I bought a different set (can't remember who's) and it has been fine for the past 3 years or so.

TheVoices 20 August 2009 10:12 PM

I had the same problem, bolts and bushes missing from both sides at MOT time.

I looked at this and it's simple, if you re-use the standard droplink bolts they pull through the poly bush (obviously not through the stainless sleeve !), in effect allowing it to 'slide' off over the nut.

I sorted new bushes and refitted with high tensile bolts from Ebay with large stainless steel washers on either side, no problems since.

Guinness 20 August 2009 10:15 PM

Ive had a set of these on my car for 3yrs with no problem...also had them on my Type-R for a few years aswell......

wrighty338 20 August 2009 10:50 PM

will be keeping an eye on all my suspension bits anyway.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:51 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands