Hi !

I know you will all be biased but I have a choice to pick up either a 318ci V reg BMW or a Scooby Estate.

Now the dilemma is : I've always wanted a scooby but prefer the saloon version. Is the estate version any different apart from obvious looks, ie. performance etc. ?

I need somebody unbiased (is it possible on here ? :)) to help me :


318ci or Scooby WRX (new shape) ?

HELP !!!

I'm going for a test drive in both at about 1pm so please let me kno before then !!!!

I've had a Scooby Sports before so know wat I'm letting myself in for !

Jai

I can't believe you're actually asking this question!

If you'd rather have a 4 door why not wait until one becomes avaliable :confused: Surely you're not in such a rush to buy a car?? ;)

"Is the estate version any different apart from obvious looks, ie. performance etc. ?"

Wagons are just better :D

Hi, it really boiles down to what kind of driving you prefer most. I had the 318 E46 for almost 4 years and think it was good. Nice car, good interior and handling (had sports package = lowered, bucket seats etc). No problems during ownership. It lacks power so for cruising it's ok. Fully loaded with passengers and luggage, you should be carefull when overtaking :). The Scooby is (as you probably know) a different beast when it comes to power and of course is different to drive due to the turbo and + 90 HP over the BMW. I would not change back unless it was a M3 ;)

STIVII

Tough decision!!! Scooby or BMW 318?? errrrr

SCOOBY, just get one and u won't look back