ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   General Technical (https://www.scoobynet.com/general-technical-10/)
-   -   EcuTek mapping Vs Open mapping ? (https://www.scoobynet.com/general-technical-10/806211-ecutek-mapping-vs-open-mapping.html)

Andy.F 08 January 2010 12:32 PM

It was -22C up the road last night, got 400bhp out of a td04 :D

dynamix 08 January 2010 12:35 PM


Originally Posted by Andy.F (Post 9143540)
It was -22C up the road last night, got 400bhp out of a td04 :D

Is that all - you are slipping :D

Did you over-estimate the extra weight of your cardigans in the car ? :thumb:

scoobiewrx555 08 January 2010 02:03 PM

400bhp!! What on??...30yr old malt?? ;)

Andy.F 08 January 2010 02:04 PM

No, Ecutek of course ! ;)

scoobiewrx555 08 January 2010 02:22 PM

Fantastic!! I knew EcuTek were working on some clever stuff but a one touch auto tune button. Nice!! :D

99greenwagon 08 January 2010 06:11 PM


Originally Posted by scoobiewrx555 (Post 9143741)
Fantastic!! I knew EcuTek were working on some clever stuff but a one touch auto tune button. Nice!! :D

even if it is, the results and reliability speak for themselfs,me personally is very impressed with ecutek! wish i could coment on os but know f**k all about it!:p
another happy ecutek customer!:rolleyes::D

dynamix 08 January 2010 06:14 PM


Originally Posted by 99greenwagon (Post 9144221)
even if it is, the results and reliability speak for themselfs,me personally is very impressed with ecutek! wish i could coment on os but know f**k all about it!:p
another happy ecutek customer!:rolleyes::D

Sorry, but what results and what reliability ?

Did Ecutek map your car ?

99greenwagon 08 January 2010 06:14 PM

and as for alan and martyn at enginetuner,:notworthy:notworthy:notworthy.wont be long and ill be back down for another transformation!:luxhello::thumb:

99greenwagon 08 January 2010 06:18 PM


Originally Posted by dynamix (Post 9144233)
Sorry, but what results and what reliability ?

Did Ecutek map your car ?

my car was mapped by martyn using ecutek,and will be again in the future!:thumb:

dynamix 08 January 2010 06:20 PM


Originally Posted by 99greenwagon (Post 9144254)
my car was mapped by martyn using ecutek,and will be again in the future!:thumb:

Ah right, perhaps it would be fairer to Martyn to say 'another happy EngineTuner customer'.

What results did you get ?

99greenwagon 08 January 2010 06:23 PM


Originally Posted by dynamix (Post 9144259)
Ah right, perhaps it would be fairer to Martyn to say 'another happy EngineTuner customer'.

What results did you get ?

its not finished yet but 300/300 so far,going for about 340 on stock motor.:norty:i am a very happy enginetuner customer and they did a very good job on the other work i had done aswell,clutch,flywheel etc etc.

mickywrx 08 January 2010 10:33 PM

ECUtek vs OS? Hmmm.....

Think I'll leave my car as it is.

Whoever it was, in the Subaru ECU department, did a good enough job of mine. :D

scoobiewrx555 08 January 2010 10:38 PM

You'e probably right because If your info is correct and you have a 94 classic then neither OS nor EcuTek could help you. Your best solution would be ESL. :)

dynamix 08 January 2010 10:45 PM


Originally Posted by mickywrx (Post 9145031)
ECUtek vs OS? Hmmm.....

Think I'll leave my car as it is.

Whoever it was, in the Subaru ECU department, did a good enough job of mine. :D

Indeed. :thumb:

Hows the snaar up there Micky ?

joz8968 08 January 2010 11:29 PM


Originally Posted by apalmer (Post 9143378)
Fn F(eeler)5

Ha! Inspired! :D:D

johnlogie 08 January 2010 11:41 PM

Surely the mapper is the most important thing? If they REALLY know what they are doing and you trust them with your pride and joy and they have a good rep then it wont matter what they use?

MY99 simtek mapped by JGM for the record

99greenwagon 09 January 2010 12:14 AM


Originally Posted by johnlogie (Post 9145184)
Surely the mapper is the most important thing? If they REALLY know what they are doing and you trust them with your pride and joy and they have a good rep then it wont matter what they use?

MY99 simtek mapped by JGM for the record

good comment,i agree.:thumb:

johnlogie 09 January 2010 01:16 AM


Originally Posted by 99greenwagon (Post 9145235)
good comment,i agree.:thumb:

I took a long time to decide who would map my car.
Andy was the first choice but he was very busy and i could get in a bit quicker with JGM. ive never looked back, third remap on the way , with meth, lol, happy dayz:thumb:

Andy.F 09 January 2010 01:06 PM

Note to self............ must work faster and reduce waiting times ;)

petedotuk 09 January 2010 01:31 PM

I didnt know about OS when I first got my car EcuTek'd otherwise I think I might of give it a whirl. Purely so I could do my own datalogging without buying Delta Dash.

Anyway first outfit that mapped my car with Ecutek give me a rubbish map and the car drove like ****e, the backup was pants and tried laughing off the problems I was getting saying " dont worry about it" so there is also some rouge EcuTek dealers. Got Andy F to map it and it was great, changed the turbo and got another Andy map. Car run great but later developed problems.

Couldnt get a response from Andy to try and address the problems but it was close to him getting his 8.87sec run so I knew he was up to his eyes so cant blame him for being busy and unable to answer/help. Also being in Northern Ireland made it a bit difficult.

Got a Simtek fitted by OMA in Northern Ireland and got the user tune kit so at least now I can have a go myself. Just need to find out how to work it now I'm living in Oz and there is no SimTek dealers!

From what I can see the EcuTek dealers here in Oz are all moving to OS with 1 company having developed their own version called HPFlash.

P.s Not making any sort of complaint about your service, I mean if you were able to answer/respond instantly that would mean you had no work and if a tradesman has no work its because no wants to use them!

johnlogie 09 January 2010 01:33 PM


Originally Posted by Andy.F (Post 9145774)
Note to self............ must work faster and reduce waiting times ;)

Andy I was in no way having a go at you. The fact that you are so busy speaks volumes for how good your work is.

Andy.F 09 January 2010 01:50 PM

No probs guys :) Yes it can be tricky trying to find the balance between work and play when scoobies are concerned but I usually get back to my emails within a few days...... when we are not away racing.

dunx 09 January 2010 02:32 PM

Or answering my stupid questions at Elvington ;)

:notworthy

dunx

Tidgy 09 January 2010 02:53 PM

something that does interest me is the whole legal side of things? most of the open mappes don;t seem to have a connection to any workshops and basicly operate from home. how does liability isnurance etc work for this? i asked htis before and no one responded also what happens if things go worng and the engine goes up in smoke?

dunx 09 January 2010 02:59 PM

caveat emptor !

Buyer beware. All of this sort of work is at your own risk, and I'm sure any decent mapper would refuse to work on any car deemed unsuitable. Many may help sort minor issues, but if it came in smoking and knocking...

dunx

Tidgy 09 January 2010 03:04 PM


Originally Posted by dunx (Post 9146080)
caveat emptor !

Buyer beware. All of this sort of work is at your own risk, and I'm sure any decent mapper would refuse to work on any car deemed unsuitable. Many may help sort minor issues, but if it came in smoking and knocking...

dunx

i can see that not being a good business idea, if you blow someones car up then dump them in the poo then your gonna get a very bad rep, but what about while your mapping? you are working then you should have all sorts of insurance, public liability etc etc

lets say you have a crash, the owner of the car says the person was being paid to map the car, 3rd party or even drivers fully comp insurance wont cover this.

Splitpin 09 January 2010 03:17 PM


Originally Posted by Tidgy (Post 9146054)
something that does interest me is the whole legal side of things? most of the open mappes don;t seem to have a connection to any workshops and basicly operate from home.

You're making a false distinction between the "Open" and EcuTeK network on this issue I'd suspect, as in practice I'd suspect they'd work largely the same way.


also what happens if things go worng and the engine goes up in smoke?
If an engine suffers damage or failure it would, one would imagine, be up to you to sort out.

Aside from anything else, it would be almost impossible for you, as an end user, to prove whether engine management changes instigated by a third party were responsible for a failure, or whether it occurred as a result of an issue that was already festering before you had the car tuned.

Indeed I'd imagine most mappers would include an indemnification clause in any agreement/contract you sign.

As Duncan says though, they always have the option to decline to map an engine they have a bad feeling about - as aside from anything else, a good tuner's reputation can do without a ticked-off customer.

Tidgy 09 January 2010 03:30 PM


Originally Posted by Splitpin (Post 9146127)
You're making a false distinction between the "Open" and EcuTeK network on this issue I'd suspect, as in practice I'd suspect they'd work largely the same way.

only in as much as most ecutek are actual workshops. although it porb is a distinction about road and RR mapping.


Originally Posted by Splitpin (Post 9146127)
If an engine suffers damage or failure it would, one would imagine, be up to you to sort out.

Aside from anything else, it would be almost impossible for you, as an end user, to prove whether engine management changes instigated by a third party were responsible for a failure, or whether it occurred as a result of an issue that was already festering before you had the car tuned.

Indeed I'd imagine most mappers would include an indemnification clause in any agreement/contract you sign.

As Duncan says though, they always have the option to decline to map an engine they have a bad feeling about - as aside from anything else, a good tuner's reputation can do without a ticked-off customer.

i think alot of the open mappers setup on a shoe string budget shal we say and simply can't afford the cost of a rebuild for a customer if the worst happens. so the customer may save 150, but then they end up with no car at the end of it.

Splitpin 09 January 2010 03:45 PM


Originally Posted by Tidgy (Post 9146154)
only in as much as most ecutek are actual workshops. although it porb is a distinction about road and RR mapping.

As both I and others have said before, the necessity to make a significant up-front financial investment in the EcuTeK system means that, as a rule, it will tend to be the preserve of experienced commercial tuning houses. However, as you acknowledge, not all of them are "actual workshops".


i think alot of the open mappers setup on a shoe string budget shal we say and simply can't afford the cost of a rebuild for a customer if the worst happens. so the customer may save 150, but then they end up with no car at the end of it.
To be honest you are missing the point, it's nothing to do with affordability, it's to do with all mappers working on the basis that the owner of the car accepts any risk in altering the engine management system.

If you have your car EcuTeK mapped and it blows up a few days/weeks after, I strongly suspect that going back to the mapper will result in a reply along the lines of "sorry mate, it was okay the day it was mapped, and that's all I vouch for" (although I would be happy to stand corrected).

You're not doubt correct to imply that some will be better insured than others, but are equally a little misguided in trying to use this as a Tek vs Open issue.

Where it gets sh*tty is the type of "mapper" who, in their small print, explains that their "service" is limited to obtaining a "compatible map update" and "programming it on your ECU". That isn't mapping, in the true sense, at all, it's purloining/stealing a map done by someone else on someone else's car, bunging it on yours and hoping it works, thereby greatly increasing the chance of dissatisfaction at your end.

You can work on that basis that this sort of person would have zero insurance/business backing/etc but the end result would be the same as someone who did - in the event of an engine failure, tough titty.

mickywrx 09 January 2010 08:02 PM


Originally Posted by dynamix (Post 9145070)
Indeed. :thumb:

Hows the snaar up there Micky ?

Five inches of the bloody stuff covering the car earlier, Duncan. It hasn't moved since Monday. :( Hand brake turns in the van are fun though :D


Originally Posted by scoobiewrx555 (Post 9145046)
You'e probably right because If your info is correct and you have a 94 classic then neither OS nor EcuTek could help you. Your best solution would be ESL. :)

My best solution would have been the Power FC that I bought and then sold having only taken it out of the box to photograph to advertise it for sale. ;)

Mines not getting remapped. :D


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:05 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands