mikemac

iTrader: (3)

Hi guys. I have been searching for a good Subaru forum and this one seems to fit the bill, so hello! Im looking to buy a newer shape Impreza, (02, 03, 04 or 05) I have a couple of questions, I would be grateful if somone could answer. I will be using this car every day to commute so comfort is quite important. BUT, Im a petrol head so the faster the better

Is the WRX with PPP 265bhp? Has anyone got any 0-60 and MPG stats for this model? Can it easilly reach STI performance with mods?

Would I be very annoyed at myself if I didnt just go for the STI if I get a WRX? Is there much difference in ride comfort and MPG?

If I go for an STI, is it worth gettng one with the PPP? What mpg average is achievable if I stay off boost and drive as economically as I can with an STI? or, whats the cost to fill a tank and how many miles will that do?

What are the main differences betwen the bug eye model and the one after?

Sorry for all the questions but I want to make sure I make the right choice when shopping.

Thanks

ALZWRXSTI

Hi mate I would go for the sti everytime, ive got a standard 04 STI and its ace. Am going to get a few mods done over the next few months to take it up to around 300bhp (265 standard) If your wanting a subaru why drive it like a miss daisy to save fuel, its around £50 ish to fill up from empty and do around 300 miles I would say. Others on here may get better than that as people do say that if you get it remapped then the mpg does go up (bonus) And thats having a bit of fun doing it aswell. Standard sti will do 0-60 in about 5.2 secs but with a couple of mods 4.8 is achievable.

mikemac

iTrader: (3)

Thanks for that mate. I think I will be going for the STI. That petrol cost you quote was around the same as my Nissan 200sx so thats not actually too bad considering.

What does the PPP have to bring the standard STI up from 265bhp to 305bhp then?

TonyBurns

iTrader: (3)

Fuel, 60ltr tank, 1.20 per ltr of super unleaded but if your going to modify the car then get the STi, bigger and better brakes, stronger internals, better gearbox etc (you get the gist )

Tony

fmp

iTrader: (7)

STI everytime.

better in everyway.

dont expect to see much more than 200 miles from a tank of petrol (in my limited experience)

ALZWRXSTI

PPP is just a standard package mate so will be the same which ever car you put it on. I cant remember what you get but some one on here will know what you get. You can also forget the PPP and just get after market stuff or just buy it stages off ebay and fit it yourself. But you will more than likely need someone to do the remap for you though

Mifo

iTrader: (10)

Ive got a WRX but definatly go for the sti.

theres loads forsale, so its a good time to buy!!

only reason why I didnt get an sti was at the time the difference in price between the 2 was about 4 to 5 grand!! - this seems to have gone down to about 2k difference at the minute.

plus being 21 at the time the insurance on the sti was £600 more than a wrx!!

good luck with your future purchase

_Meridian_

iTrader: (1)

If you don't get the STI you will spend every day wishing that you had. I didn't, and I was forced to trade up after only nine months.


M

DaveBeck

iTrader: (12)

agree completely with above.

Got a wrx myself as the price at the time for an sti was bit much for me.

ive now spent a fortune tuning it to get my power at present. when if i had brought an sti it would of been a better starting point with forged internals as standard.
everything on the sti is better.

You will enjoy the wrx but you will always think that you should of got the sti

hixxys STI

STI OR I U WILL CRY

Norman Dog

iTrader: (1)

I bought the WRX, get the STi - the power on a standard WRX is way too low and you'll spend a fortune modding it

phil_wrx

iTrader: (2)

ive got a wrx - great car very capable and does what u want, just bought an 05 sti ppp - truely amazing car does waht u ask of it and more

get an sti with dccd on and a 6 speed box

s70rjw

iTrader: (2)

The WRX and STI are quite different to drive. I use my car everyday and found the ride on the STI too harsh. The kids couldn't settle in it, complaining of being bounced around.
I went for the WRX with PPP, and am now on my second. I don't track the car, so don't feel I miss out on the better brakes and stiffer suspension.
As far as performance goes, the WRX PPP is booked at 4.8 to 60. The midrange is far fatter than a standard WRX though.
Drive both and make up your own mind. Whichever, prepare to enjoy

mikemac

iTrader: (3)

Thanks for all the comments guys, very helpful indeed. Watch this space for a new black STI!! (or maybe blue).

Skooby53

iTrader: (1)

I kind of agree an STi would be a better choice if you want out and out performance. I have a classic mapped to 280 bhp and 312 lb/ft and plan on upgrading the turbo and reaching 330bhp. Total cost ie remap turbo fuel pump etc etc is going to be edging toward 2k. I'm happy with that for now, also a bonus to have a classic as the tax will be a lot lower (MY99). The big money will start to be spent if I want to go any higher, engine+gear box etc. So for me, if I wanted more than 330 ish then I would stop now and buy an STi instead. With regard to mpg I think 200 miles per tank on v-power at 124.9 ltr is average for spirited driving.

Bez300

iTrader: (2)

I'v got a WRX it's fab I love the car, Its got some mods done to it and is now a lot mor BHP than STi.

I wish I got the STi though. they are better, if you get a WRX you will love it but every time you see an STi you will think I wish I got one off them instead, I do

Both ace cars though, good look bud.

Bez

Bikebloke

iTrader: (2)

There are also TSL Sti out there for about the same £££ as standard sti. They have 3ins sportscat ex system,Re map uprated fuel pump 333bhp & 333lbs torque.

cptcaveman

Just to play Devils Advocate.

I've recently gone from an 05 wrx to an 55 STi. I loved the WRX, I had it PPP'd early on so i couldn't tell you what performance was like without it. I found the 5 speed gearbox really easy to use and for me the gearing felt right and comfortable. I've done about 10k in the STI and i still prefer the 5 speed gearbox over the six, its probably just me, but I always seem to have the change gear light on in the STI (its on and flashing, change gear, 500rpm later its on again), the gear ratios just don't feel different enough.

I corner at exactly the same speeds I used to before (aggressively) , even though the suspension is firmer in the STI.
The WRX did have slightly more body roll but I don't feel the STI lets me go any quicker round corners.

Now my STI is stock standard and has a different engine so its not a fair comparrison, but i do feel the WRX PPP'd was better from a standing start, the STI might have a slightly better mid range feel, but they both top out roughly the same, maybe 5mph higher on the STI.

I know its petty but I think my biggest grumble is the dash board creeking the slightly firmer suspension in the STI seems to introduce, in the WRX it was slight, but inthe STI its embarrasing, and whats with the velvet-ish interior in the STI, my WRX had the black crosshatched interior, and I could be wrong but all i've seen in STI's is the kind I have now.

For Fuel econemy, well just get used to the fact you are gonna get friendly with your local Shell staff, I've never managed more than 220 miles out of a tank and I average 185 (so I fill up twice a week), but then I don't do any motorway driving.

I found the DCCD knocks at low speeds (parking and such) so I find I have it turned off a lot (even the dealer recomended turning it off), so for me it doesn't factor as a major insentive for buying it, ohh and the STI's are prone to rear suspension problems so that might be worth factoring in, although 05 on WRX get the same problem.

Don't forget the Tracker subscription when buying, In the STI you have to have one for most insurances. Its a one off payment of nearly £500 or every year at over £100 (can't remember exactly)

Fellow STI drivers, I'm not bashing it, and I'd never change it. Like some have said I bought a WRX and always wished I'd had the STI, and I'm sure my opinion will change when I get it modded (got to finish paying for the thing first) but it is a heap extra cash (at least it was for me) for not a massive improvement. I guess I'm saying I love the STI but my heart still belongs to the WRX

MrJim

sti,bugeye

2000 sport

iTrader: (1)

My black STi bugeye maywell be for sale, as I need something bigger..

mikemac

iTrader: (3)

Really appreciate the views on this chaps.

Someone said the fuel tank is 125 Litres, that seems mental big, is that correct??

One of the things I love most with the Impreza's is the lovely warble sound the engines in the classics make, I havnt heard any of the newage, am I right in thinking this beautiful sounds carried on to the newage models?

Appreciate the ind-depth views caveman. Does anyone else find the interior to 'creak' a lot. Is the ride going to be too harsh for usig the car to daily commute.

Thanks again guys

ALZWRXSTI

Im sure the tanks are only 50 or 60 litres sure its 50 but dont quote me on that

2000 sport

iTrader: (1)

50L tank, off boost motorway run = 300miles. More spirited driving will reduce that to around 230miles (that is with PPP fitted). STi's do need Tesco 99 or V-Power..

My classic used to rattle and creak, but not my newage..

I don't find the ride harsh, but it depends what you are used to driving..

psigeek

iTrader: (17)

The bugeyes (newage) still have a stock burble from the unequal headers. It's true there is a bit of rattle, but then it's plastic... nothing the stereo can't cover up.

GREGGYG

iTrader: (2)

The only way you will make the right choice for yourself is to go and drive the car's you're interested in! I've had several WRX's and STi's, and I would certainly say STi all the way.

igralec

Interesting, another 200sx owner tempted to buy an STI
Oh, what is PPP?

jeff mx

iTrader: (1)

thinking of selling my 2003 sti type uk in blue.
32k with fsh and 1 previous owner. 18 prodrive wheels and blitz nur spec-r.
near mint condition.
£10999.00 any takers?

IainMilford

iTrader: (15)

Prodrive Performance Pack

srm_sti

^^^ couldn't agree more. It's a GREAT car from stock, and if needed it has the potential to be a BEAST. Matter of personal opinion but I think the bugeye is the best looking and it is cheaper than the blob and hawkeye. The burble isn't as good as the classic's, but that's nothing a exhaust can't fix. An answer to your earler question: The prodrive Power Pack consists of an uprated fuel pump (which all turbo Impreza's need as the stock one isn't upto the job), an exhaust system and an ECU. I'm not gonna lie insurance, petrol and just general maintenance is expensive but worth every penny. IMHO I would definately get a newage STI. You only live once, so whatever you do enjoy it.

IainMilford

iTrader: (15)

I have a 55reg WRX, initially started with the PPP. The PPP is good but the turbo lag really annoyed me, ie nothing until 3200rpm, so I am in the process of modding it up to around 320bhp, which is costing around 2K and will be completed this weekend. The PPP on the WRX is a new backbox, intercooler hoses and a remap, so as soon as you change something else you are effectively wiping out the PPP, so if you're planning to MOD the car you dont necessariliy need to start with the PPP.

I bought my WRX because at the time there were no STI's to match what I was looking for, my WRX is in very good condition and low miles, all the STI's looked ragged and all came with high miles.

At the end of the day it depends what you want to get out of it, if you are planning on tracking the car loads than an STI without question, if you want to go for 400bhp plus then go for an STI. If you want a fast road car, daily runner with the odd track use then consider a WRX. With some simple handling mods it is still a car to be reckoned with, and you wont have to pay the extra insurance/tax costs that come with an STI.

As for fuel, in my experience with or without the PPP, £55ish to fill up, 250 miles average. Lots of motorway use then 280, lots of fun and right foot action then expect somewhere around 220 - 230 miles.

Just my 2 pence worth