ECU Upgrade Differences
#1
Simple one this, but I'm posting it here since Scooby drivers have been doing this kind of thing longer than us CTR drivers and so are more experienced.
(Excluding anything to do with cost)
Which would you choose, an HKS FCON S or a Unichip?
Why?
The reason for asking is that I've just had an FCON S fitted to my CTR and it's fantastic. Problem is of course that since I'm one of the first to do this there's no comparison and so 80% of people immediately fire back with 'You should have waited for the xXx ECU it's much better!'
Thanks
Laurence
(Excluding anything to do with cost)
Which would you choose, an HKS FCON S or a Unichip?
Why?
The reason for asking is that I've just had an FCON S fitted to my CTR and it's fantastic. Problem is of course that since I'm one of the first to do this there's no comparison and so 80% of people immediately fire back with 'You should have waited for the xXx ECU it's much better!'
Thanks
Laurence
#2
Scooby Regular
The point is you could have "waited"!
You could have "waited" till the STI 9 or the next shape CTR came out, but you didn't because you wanted it now
If your happy that's all that matters!!
[Edited by Dyney - 6/13/2003 5:05:39 PM]
You could have "waited" till the STI 9 or the next shape CTR came out, but you didn't because you wanted it now
If your happy that's all that matters!!
[Edited by Dyney - 6/13/2003 5:05:39 PM]
#4
Thanks Dyney, that's my attitude as well. Go for what makes you smile
The thing is that I did loads of research before getting the HKS as I had a REALLY bad experience with 'another' type of chip (not the Super variety) on my Scooby which nearly put me off.
What I thought is that since the Scooby community are likely to have been using these products for a lot longer than the CTR community I just wondered about plusses and minuses. Not because I'm unhappy but just so that I can argue more successfully.
I may have moved manufacturer for my car but I still come back here for advice on mods as no-one does it better than a Scooby owner IMO
BTW: Neither is a complete ECU replacement. I decided against that as the piggyback type will do what I want and I won't be modifying far enough to fully take advantage of a full ECU replacement. They are not as common for a CTR yet remember and so still expensive with downsides such as bad starting, lumpy cold tickover, disabled immobiliser, no aircon.
Laurence
The thing is that I did loads of research before getting the HKS as I had a REALLY bad experience with 'another' type of chip (not the Super variety) on my Scooby which nearly put me off.
What I thought is that since the Scooby community are likely to have been using these products for a lot longer than the CTR community I just wondered about plusses and minuses. Not because I'm unhappy but just so that I can argue more successfully.
I may have moved manufacturer for my car but I still come back here for advice on mods as no-one does it better than a Scooby owner IMO
BTW: Neither is a complete ECU replacement. I decided against that as the piggyback type will do what I want and I won't be modifying far enough to fully take advantage of a full ECU replacement. They are not as common for a CTR yet remember and so still expensive with downsides such as bad starting, lumpy cold tickover, disabled immobiliser, no aircon.
Laurence
#5
Thanks Dyney, that's my attitude as well. Go for what makes you smile
The thing is that I did loads of research before getting the HKS as I had a REALLY bad experience with 'another' type of chip (not the Super variety) on my Scooby which nearly put me off.
What I thought is that since the Scooby community are likely to have been using these products for a lot longer than the CTR community I just wondered about plusses and minuses. Not because I'm unhappy but just so that I can argue more successfully.
I may have moved manufacturer for my car but I still come back here for advice on mods as no-one does it better than a Scooby owner IMO
BTW: Neither is a complete ECU replacement. I decided against that as the piggyback type will do what I want and I won't be modifying far enough to fully take advantage of a full ECU replacement. They are not as common for a CTR yet remember and so still expensive with downsides such as bad starting, lumpy cold tickover, disabled immobiliser, no aircon.
Laurence
The thing is that I did loads of research before getting the HKS as I had a REALLY bad experience with 'another' type of chip (not the Super variety) on my Scooby which nearly put me off.
What I thought is that since the Scooby community are likely to have been using these products for a lot longer than the CTR community I just wondered about plusses and minuses. Not because I'm unhappy but just so that I can argue more successfully.
I may have moved manufacturer for my car but I still come back here for advice on mods as no-one does it better than a Scooby owner IMO
BTW: Neither is a complete ECU replacement. I decided against that as the piggyback type will do what I want and I won't be modifying far enough to fully take advantage of a full ECU replacement. They are not as common for a CTR yet remember and so still expensive with downsides such as bad starting, lumpy cold tickover, disabled immobiliser, no aircon.
Laurence
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Mattybr5@MB Developments
Full Cars Breaking For Spares
28
28 December 2015 11:07 PM
KK3960
General Technical
3
07 October 2015 12:33 PM
jonnyboy82
Lighting and Other Electrical
0
29 September 2015 01:59 PM