Misfire under load
Hi everybody,thank for taking the time to read this.
I have a bog standard 2000 on a x imprezza turbo classic with a misfire under load,it has been code read and came up with the lamda sensor,this has been repalced with a know working 2nd hand one,all the leads,plugs,air filter,fuel filter etc have been changed. I have also changed the wastegate actuator,checked all vac pipes etc,any ideas please? |
take it to a specialist and get them to have a look.
|
Originally Posted by Tidgy
(Post 9159738)
take it to a specialist and get them to have a look.
|
NPS maybe?
newage cars have this problem under big torque or when a nps is on its way out. hth Rob
Originally Posted by spannerboy
(Post 9159726)
Hi everybody,thank for taking the time to read this.
I have a bog standard 2000 on a x imprezza turbo classic with a misfire under load,it has been code read and came up with the lamda sensor,this has been repalced with a know working 2nd hand one,all the leads,plugs,air filter,fuel filter etc have been changed. I have also changed the wastegate actuator,checked all vac pipes etc,any ideas please? |
not realy sure what to sugest tbh, you;ve already chased it round the engine bay with no luck, is it def a misfire? or is it hitting boost cut?
|
Originally Posted by UK300 PRODRIVE
(Post 9159758)
NPS maybe?
newage cars have this problem under big torque or when a nps is on its way out. hth Rob
Originally Posted by Tidgy
(Post 9159764)
not realy sure what to sugest tbh, you;ve already chased it round the engine bay with no luck, is it def a misfire? or is it hitting boost cut?
|
ah right.... thought the Neutral Position Switch might be faulty. The ecu on the newage flashes up with a misfire code when the car is reving high with a faulty NPS as the ecu think the car is in neutral so it gives off the OBD2 misfire code.......HOWEVER:wonder: Im under the i impression this doesnt alter the performance, but i can not vouch for the classic... just a thought.
ie: my car running a brand newly built engine on a standard TD04 was fine, no ECU issues. Now engine running in with a complete overall inc 3" decat, STI pinks and VF30 etc has now started offering up the misfire code frequently due to the torque pushing the NPS out of sync on the gearbox. The gearbox litteraly twists slightly under load. Im getting a new NPS fitted next week (£50) HTH Rob
Originally Posted by spannerboy
(Post 9159780)
Whats the nps please?
I have had a boost gauge on it today,under load in 2nd and 3 rd the psi drops when it does it,it is more like a boost cut now you mention it. |
Originally Posted by UK300 PRODRIVE
(Post 9159828)
ah right.... thought the Neutral Position Switch might be faulty. The ecu on the newage flashes up with a misfire code when the car is reving high with a faulty NPS as the ecu think the car is in neutral so it gives off the OBD2 misfire code.......HOWEVER:wonder: Im under the i impression this doesnt alter the performance, but i can not vouch for the classic... just a thought.
ie: my car running a brand newly built engine on a standard TD04 was fine, no ECU issues. Now engine running in with a complete overall inc 3" decat, STI pinks and VF30 etc has now started offering up the misfire code frequently due to the torque pushing the NPS out of sync on the gearbox. The gearbox litteraly twists slightly under load. Im getting a new NPS fitted next week (£50) HTH Rob |
Originally Posted by spannerboy
(Post 9159845)
Ah ok,there is no check light or codes stored in the ecu,it literaly just farts for a second,it has also had a 2nd hand good working maf sensor,all the 2nd hand bits have been tried on my mates one and are fine.
|
Snowy Guildford
|
Originally Posted by spannerboy
(Post 9159746)
I was hoping for some inspiration from here tbh.
You can forget about the neutral position switch btw. If this was a factor you'd get an error code when you checked the memory. What's your boost gauge reading when you get the "misfire"? How, if at all, is the car modified? |
Originally Posted by Splitpin
(Post 9159862)
What was wrong with the inspiration that Tidgy gave you? On the basis of what you've told us, the most worthwhile way forward would be to get your car looked at by a specialist.
You can forget about the neutral position switch btw. If this was a factor you'd get an error code when you checked the memory. |
As above, what is the boost gauge holding/peaking at?
|
Originally Posted by spannerboy
(Post 9159858)
Snowy Guildford
As the location is on here now it wont tale long for someone to tell you where to go. Im up North so im no help with my contacts :wonder: |
Originally Posted by Splitpin
(Post 9159886)
As above, what is the boost gauge holding/peaking at?
Originally Posted by UK300 PRODRIVE
(Post 9159888)
Agreed with Splitpin :thumb:, its not the NPS (i was under the impression on the original post that the engine check light was on)
As the location is on here now it wont tale long for someone to tell you where to go. Im up North so im no help with my contacts :wonder: |
Forgot to say,it is a uk spec car.
|
Originally Posted by UK300 PRODRIVE
(Post 9159888)
Agreed with Splitpin :thumb:, its not the NPS (i was under the impression on the original post that the engine check light was on)
As the location is on here now it wont tale long for someone to tell you where to go. Im up North so im no help with my contacts :wonder: |
have you tried the fpr,i had the same problem on mine changed it to a after market one and problem solved:)
|
Originally Posted by duds64
(Post 9160166)
have you tried the fpr,i had the same problem on mine changed it to a after market one and problem solved:)
|
Fuel pressure regulator
|
Originally Posted by duds64
(Post 9160166)
have you tried the fpr,i had the same problem on mine changed it to a after market one and problem solved:)
Originally Posted by UK300 PRODRIVE
(Post 9160217)
Fuel pressure regulator
Any idea what the the fuel pressure should be? |
Just been out in it again,it hunts on idle,it is almost as if it has an air leak,I have changed the pipes that operate the actuator for ones off another one,I made sure the restricted one was in the right place.
|
Originally Posted by spannerboy
(Post 9160344)
Just been out in it again,it hunts on idle,it is almost as if it has an air leak,I have changed the pipes that operate the actuator for ones off another one,I made sure the restricted one was in the right place.
Hunting idle points to, among other things an airflow sensor issue. If your reading of c.15psi is accurate, that suggests you are not experiencing overboost and fuel cut. While there are still any number of possible explanations, one of them may be a failing airflow sensor and corresponding very lean on-boost mixtures (and probably very serious detonation). You would therefore be well advised to take Tidgy's advice and get it looked at by someone able to diagnose the car properly. You need to know what's wrong with it ASAP, as it sounds like there's enough of a fault to be doing your engine long-term damage. Incidentally - someone who doesn't know better might be along in a bit to tell you about a test which involves unplugging the airflow sensor with the engine running and seeing if the engine stalls, with a stall meaning that the "sensor is good", and a lack of stall meaning the sensor is "bad". This "test" is a myth based on complete bullsh*t and, as described above, can give dangerously misleading results, don't bother doing it. What might be worth trying is unplugging the airflow sensor with the engine off and then starting it up. If the idle magically stabilises, that adds further weight to the theory of a damaged sensor, but is not, in itself, conclusive. Oh - if you've changed the boost control pipework, one presumes that the "new" pipes have the correct size restrictor in them? |
The pipework came off another car,so all pipes are genuine,so therfore pressuming the restrictor is the right size.
Now this is the thing,when you do a cat test,the co and hc's are fine. The plugs are a nice browny colour,so that would suggest all is ok on the mixture,could it be wrong plugs? what should it have in there? The maf sensor was changed,I bought a 2nd hand one of grade a,we also tried this on my friends classic. I am in Guildford or down on the south coast,anyone recommend someone I can go to please? |
Originally Posted by spannerboy
(Post 9160409)
Now this is the thing,when you do a cat test,the co and hc's are fine.
The plugs are a nice browny colour,so that would suggest all is ok on the mixture, Aside from anything else the 99-00 MAF has a failure mode in which its output momentarily disappears due to fractures in its internal wiring causing bad connections - with the duration of the drop-out getting longer and longer as the sensor degrades. In practice this under-read on the airflow input causes the ECU to under-calculate the fuel mix for the duration of the drop-out. Depending on how bad and how long the drop-out lasts, the symptoms can either be undetectable (and undamaging) to undetectable (but cumulatively damaging) to detectable and seriously damaging. You need to know which, if any, of the above apply. could it be wrong plugs? what should it have in there? |
The tips all looked ok.
I'll just have to bite the bullet and take it in,anyone recommend anyone near to guildford,southampton or portsmouth please? |
Originally Posted by spannerboy
(Post 9160459)
The tips all looked ok.
I'll just have to bite the bullet and take it in,anyone recommend anyone near to guildford,southampton or portsmouth please? "Reputable garage required near southampton or portsmouth" That ought to work mate. Cheers Rob Edit- And put it in the Southern section https://www.scoobynet.com/southern-england-22/ ;-) |
Anyone recommend anyone good please
|
sorry if im hijacking the thread here,
i have a newage wrx and keeps throwing faults when i boot it in 4th gear mainly. the cel comes on and when i get the codes read its showing missfires on all cylinders so im asuming after changing all the plugs etc etc its the nps switch am i right??? thanks phil |
Originally Posted by fudumped
(Post 9160893)
sorry if im hijacking the thread here,
i have a newage wrx and keeps throwing faults when i boot it in 4th gear mainly. the cel comes on and when i get the codes read its showing missfires on all cylinders so im asuming after changing all the plugs etc etc its the nps switch am i right??? thanks phil There are two switches on top of the gearbox, 1)reverse swtich and 2)NPS, so if doing it yourself get the right one. Personaly im taking mine to Scoobyteknx in fleetwood. |
All times are GMT +1. The time now is 06:48 AM. |
© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands