I've been with NFU mutual for the past two years and found them to be pretty much unbeatable on price, though I do ring around a few of the usual suspects for quotes every year.

You may find this helpful when looking round yourself.

Renewal with NFU £743 up from £630 last year.

Liverpool Victoria £1283.

Tesco £1025 - I expected them to be much better judging by other peoples comments on here.

Eagle Star £1202.

Then I phoned Greenlight, £683. Very impressed with their knowledge of the Impreza and said they give a discount for SIDC membership.

Quotes based on the following:
MY 95 Turbo cat2 + Tracker parked on drive
7 years no claims & clean licence
only me to drive 33 years old
Induction kit, EBC brakes, STI backbox
6000 miles per year due to me having company car as well.

Anyone else worth contacting?

could give Tom (Rum*) @ schofields a bell on 0113 250 0377. might get it lower, not promising but he might.