ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   ScoobyNet General (https://www.scoobynet.com/scoobynet-general-1/)
-   -   WR1 vs 03/04 PPP/JDM Sti (https://www.scoobynet.com/scoobynet-general-1/668353-wr1-vs-03-04-ppp-jdm-sti.html)

karl.hughes 17 February 2008 09:55 PM

WR1 vs 03/04 PPP/JDM Sti
 
Can you help, looking at Sti ownership in July funds looking at around 15k. Should i blow the lot on a Wr1 or go for a 03/04 PPP/Jdm Sti and cash in the bank. Is the Wr1 a better car ? is it worth the extra cash ?. Any advice would be appreciated.

T5NYW 17 February 2008 10:12 PM


Originally Posted by karl.hughes (Post 7663622)
Can you help, looking at Sti ownership in July funds looking at around 15k. Should i blow the lot on a Wr1 or go for a 03/04 PPP/Jdm Sti and cash in the bank. Is the Wr1 a better car ? is it worth the extra cash ?. Any advice would be appreciated.

Yes and no ;)

The WR1 has all the goodies on it but if you can get a MY05PPP, PHP & PF7's at simular price 05 would be better buy IMHO

Personally a Sorted 03/04 STi JDM would be better spec and quicker than the WR1, A 03/04 Spec C would eat it alive.

IMHO, IIRC

Tony

juggers 17 February 2008 10:15 PM

As above or try and push for MY05 SPEC C with the better hubs.

Immy

corradoboy 17 February 2008 10:42 PM

Definitely worth spending the extra on an 05 if you can stretch to it. I'd be looking at a JDM STi at the least, but preferably a JDM based special such as SpecC, T25/20 (possibly SpecC based) or a Type RA.

Terminator X 17 February 2008 11:06 PM

A Spec C like mine is probably £15k ish. :( for me & :) for you if you can find someone selling ...

TX.

T5NYW 18 February 2008 10:42 AM


Originally Posted by Terminator X (Post 7663890)
A Spec C like mine is probably £15k ish. :( for me & :) for you if you can find someone selling ...

TX

A bargain for a buyer, if you can get one :D:D but for the seller :cry:

Tony

GazTheHat 18 February 2008 12:17 PM

I'd get the STi over the WR1. Keep that extra money for mods, there's always something you'll want to change. And if not, then it can go towards fuel. :)

taffyboyo 18 February 2008 02:30 PM

get a couple of insurance quotes , the wr1 could be a lot cheaper, just something to think about,
taffy

PantsUK 18 February 2008 05:59 PM

wr1 pricing seems to hold up well as do other special editions !!

karl.hughes 18 February 2008 09:28 PM

Thanks, seems a WR1 is a lot cheaper to insure as it not being an import. I am 34, 16 years ncb, garaged and can get it for around £450 Jdm looking at closer £900. Are servicing costs similar Wr1 vs Jdm, being a import does that mean servicing can only be carried out by a specialist.

T5NYW 18 February 2008 10:44 PM


Originally Posted by karl.hughes (Post 7666394)
Thanks, seems a WR1 is a lot cheaper to insure as it not being an import. I am 34, 16 years ncb, garaged and can get it for around £450 Jdm looking at closer £900.

All depends on insurance Company "Many" don't charge any difference between JDM's and UK Cars (My JDM 350bhp is priced exactly the same as a 310bhp WR1 ;)

try keith Micheals "If you have to amend your policy or need a new quote please call 0208 6427868 and ask for someone in Gary Moulson's team. (Will probably be Jason, Pat or Andy)"

A-Plan or Greenlight

be very careful of "Online" quotes for a Subaru, make a phone Call to double ccomfirm it's correct model etc. I had great quotes not many have been right


Originally Posted by karl.hughes (Post 7666394)
Are servicing costs similar Wr1 vs Jdm, .

both 10km/12months (simular price as both have DCCD cheaper if Non DCCD) and both recommend Engine intermediate services 5Km/6months.


Originally Posted by karl.hughes (Post 7666394)
being a import does that mean servicing can only be carried out by a specialist.

I take my JDM to a "Subaru Specialists" which is also normally cheaper than a UK Dealerships.

Depending where you live may have more Specialist than Dealers in a 50 mile radius.

It does depend on Waranty, UK are 3 years (extendable) JDM 1 year(extendable)

Tony

pippyrips 18 February 2008 10:49 PM

If you use your car for everyday use and shift the family about a jdm sti is the one to go for. If you fancy something a little more extreme go for the spec-c.

Terminator X 18 February 2008 11:33 PM

I'm 4yrs older than you :( & pay £480 for a JDM Spec C so not much more than the UK WR1 :) Just need to know who to get quotes from ;)

I always use a specialist for servicing, don't you?

TX.


Originally Posted by karl.hughes (Post 7666394)
Thanks, seems a WR1 is a lot cheaper to insure as it not being an import. I am 34, 16 years ncb, garaged and can get it for around £450 Jdm looking at closer £900. Are servicing costs similar Wr1 vs Jdm, being a import does that mean servicing can only be carried out by a specialist.


Phil555 19 February 2008 08:04 AM

£17K and you can have mine LOL. I use A-Plan and pay £516 fully comp on my JDM STI.

Terminator X 19 February 2008 09:19 AM

^^ You've been busy since you bought the car (mods)?! Did it come like that or have you been spending £'s?

TX.

Phil555 19 February 2008 10:04 AM


Originally Posted by Terminator X (Post 7667195)
^^ You've been busy since you bought the car (mods)?! Did it come like that or have you been spending £'s?

TX.

Spent a few quid on her. Mixture of standard an after market parts on the spec list. Running like a dream at the mo. Quick as lightening too :norty:

Pav 20 February 2008 11:43 PM

The servicing intervals for the WR! are 5k. although this is just oil and filter change. the reason the insurance is cheaper is because it has been fitted with the PPP from the factory, so it's not classed as a mod

Hope this helps mate :thumb:

Scutch 21 February 2008 10:48 AM

I opted for the WR1 over the STi/Spec C model etc due to the limited edition resale value, the colour which I love, the creature comforts included, its a UK car, the performance package as a whole and the overall look of the car. Like the P1 before it, I'm a bit of a badge whore, and as such would like to be a little different when standing out from the typical blue and gold of the Subaru's on the streets. No disrespect, obviously, but the ice blue for me is stunning.

I realise there are faster cars out there, but then thats the case with any car; there will always be something better and faster somewhere.

The WR1 for me is everything I need, especially with a 4 month old baby to think about too :)

Following the remap, I think circa 350bhp is quite enough for the time being :)

GazTheHat 21 February 2008 10:55 AM

Excellent! If you like it, that's good enough.

Enjoy it. You wont have to worry so much about depreciation in this current market, which is nice.

Scutch 21 February 2008 11:05 AM

^ Amen to that.

:)


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 07:46 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands