ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   Drivetrain (https://www.scoobynet.com/drivetrain-11/)
-   -   Stock 5 speed transmission (https://www.scoobynet.com/drivetrain-11/1056290-stock-5-speed-transmission.html)

Rick2017 24 September 2018 07:43 AM

Stock 5 speed transmission
 
What are the limits on the 5spd uk2000 box in terms of bhp out of interest and what transmission oil would people recommend for the longevity of the box.

Also I watched a subaru on tv last night break high 7s on a quarter mile called the white bullet.a new world record apprently. And another subaru breaking mid 8s on a std 6 speed transmission no mods to the box :D

pjarvis6666 24 September 2018 05:29 PM

i had an old 5 speed running 280. was recommended not much more to be on the safe side. I think its more the torque that kills them

the shreksta 24 September 2018 06:12 PM

i think its torque and hard launches that will destroy a 5 speed. i had a version 6 sti 5 speed in my blobeye wrx making 354bhp and 365ftlbs of torque, i had it for maybe 2 years then upgraded to a 6 speed and sold the box to a mate who used it for a few years with no issues

Rick2017 24 September 2018 06:15 PM


Originally Posted by the shreksta (Post 12028143)
i think its torque and hard launches that will destroy a 5 speed. i had a version 6 sti 5 speed in my blobeye wrx making 354bhp and 365ftlbs of torque, i had it for maybe 2 years then upgraded to a 6 speed and sold the box to a mate who used it for a few years with no issues

are the ratios different in the 5spd sti compared to the uk2000

scooby kid 24 September 2018 06:34 PM


Originally Posted by the shreksta (Post 12028143)
i think its torque and hard launches that will destroy a 5 speed. i had a version 6 sti 5 speed in my blobeye wrx making 354bhp and 365ftlbs of torque, i had it for maybe 2 years then upgraded to a 6 speed and sold the box to a mate who used it for a few years with no issues

how did this make the car feel compared to the uk box ? It's the only thing that I don't like coming from imports to my 1st uk car is the super long gearing ,

the shreksta 24 September 2018 06:49 PM


Originally Posted by scooby kid (Post 12028149)

how did this make the car feel compared to the uk box ? It's the only thing that I don't like coming from imports to my 1st uk car is the super long gearing ,

made a really really fast car is what it did, the ratios were quite short and as the box had been refreshed by api it was rifle bolt precise

the shreksta 24 September 2018 06:50 PM


Originally Posted by Rick2017 (Post 12028144)
are the ratios different in the 5spd sti compared to the uk2000

i couldnt tell you mate to be fair, it was alot closer ratio than the box that was originally in the car

scooby kid 24 September 2018 07:13 PM

Awesome it's something I'm really thinking of having done with a clutch/flywheel.

Rick2017 24 September 2018 07:15 PM

I'm not that bothered about long gearing I wouldn't mind knowing what these can take . Has anyone ever taken one to it's limits

johnlogie 24 September 2018 09:41 PM

Destroyed 4 over probably 15,000 miles @400 bhp and similar torque

Rick2017 25 September 2018 07:40 AM


Originally Posted by johnlogie (Post 12028175)
Destroyed 4 over probably 15,000 miles @400 bhp and similar torque

I didn't no these could take 400 :Suspiciou

TECHNOPUG 25 September 2018 10:06 AM


Originally Posted by Rick2017 (Post 12028190)
I didn't no these could take 400 :Suspiciou

Eh?

Rick2017 25 September 2018 11:15 AM


Originally Posted by TECHNOPUG (Post 12028200)
Eh?

didn't no stock 5spds were capable

TECHNOPUG 25 September 2018 11:20 AM


Originally Posted by Rick2017 (Post 12028190)
I didn't no these could take 400 :Suspiciou


Originally Posted by Rick2017 (Post 12028209)
didn't no stock 5spds were capable

"Destroyed 4 over probably 15,000 miles @400 bhp and similar torque"

Does this suggest that they are capable at 400bhp? I guess if you never plan on driving more more than 3000 miles, then yes, they are capable :lol1:

johnlogie 25 September 2018 11:27 AM


Originally Posted by TECHNOPUG (Post 12028210)
"Destroyed 4 over probably 15,000 miles @400 bhp and similar torque"

Does this suggest that they are capable at 400bhp? I guess if you never plan on driving more more than 3000 miles, then yes, they are capable :lol1:

if you drive like miss daisy and don’t use full power it would probably last a while. I do occasional track days so the box was getting a bit of abuse. The last straw was at the JGM day at Elvington where the box shat itself by lunchtime. I would not suggest to anyone that 400/400 and a 5 speed box is a good combo. I now have a 6 speed set up

Rick2017 25 September 2018 11:27 AM


Originally Posted by TECHNOPUG (Post 12028210)
"Destroyed 4 over probably 15,000 miles @400 bhp and similar torque"

Does this suggest that they are capable at 400bhp? I guess if you never plan on driving more more than 3000 miles, then yes, they are capable :lol1:

:lol1:

Rick2017 25 September 2018 11:29 AM


Originally Posted by johnlogie (Post 12028213)


if you drive like miss daisy and don’t use full power it would probably last a while. I do occasional track days so the box was getting a bit of abuse. The last straw was at the JGM day at Elvington where the box shat itself by lunchtime. I would not suggest to anyone that 400/400 and a 5 speed box is a good combo. I now have a 6 speed set up

couldn't the torque be pulled back abit through mapping to save the box.the price of a 6 spd box is ridiculous

TECHNOPUG 25 September 2018 11:33 AM


Originally Posted by johnlogie (Post 12028213)


if you drive like miss daisy and don’t use full power it would probably last a while. I do occasional track days so the box was getting a bit of abuse. The last straw was at the JGM day at Elvington where the box shat itself by lunchtime. I would not suggest to anyone that 400/400 and a 5 speed box is a good combo. I now have a 6 speed set up

As you say, you can drive around the gearbox limitations but then it makes it rather pointless having a 400/400 engine if you are never able to use all the power.

Rick2017 25 September 2018 11:42 AM


Originally Posted by TECHNOPUG (Post 12028216)
As you say, you can drive around the gearbox limitations but then it makes it rather pointless having a 400/400 engine if you are never able to use all the power.

mine will never see over 300bhp that's plenty for day to day driving. What transmission oil was you using was it anything special?

TECHNOPUG 25 September 2018 11:46 AM


Originally Posted by Rick2017 (Post 12028215)
couldn't the torque be pulled back abit through mapping to save the box.the price of a 6 spd box is ridiculous


Sure. But then it's not going to be 400/400. 5 speed boxes are cheap, so if you are able to do the work yourself, you could probably drop in 4 5speeds for the price of a 6-speed conversion. If you are only doing track days then you may consider changing the box once a year as good value. However, the box could let go at any time. The first time you give it full throttle for example. Or it may last a few thousand miles of abuse.

If you have to pay someone else though, the labour costs will soon rack up. If you want 400/400, especially in a road car/daily driver and don't have the means to swap the box yourself, then 6speed is really the only sensible financial option.



Presumably you currently have a UK2000 or similar. Add up the cost of a reliable 400/400 engine plus 6-speed conversion and you may as well just save all that money towards getting an STi with 6-speed. Whilst it can seem attractive to get a cheaper WRX/5speed car and mod it over time, if you want more power than OEM bolts on’s (turbos, injectors etc) can provide; 330/350, then it makes far greater financial sense to buy an STi as a starting point. Law of diminishing returns – power is cheap and easy at first but gets progressively more expensive £/bhp. Especially once you’ve exceeded OEM parts capability and need to buy aftermarket turbos, forge the engine, strengthen drivetrain etc.



What mods/power are you running at the moment?

TECHNOPUG 25 September 2018 11:48 AM


Originally Posted by Rick2017 (Post 12028218)
mine will never see over 300bhp that's plenty for day to day driving. What transmission oil was you using was it anything special?

Why the talk of the price of 6-speed boxes then?

Rick2017 25 September 2018 11:49 AM


Originally Posted by TECHNOPUG (Post 12028220)
Why the talk of the price of 6-speed boxes then?

because I wanted to no the limitations of a 5spd box

Rick2017 25 September 2018 11:52 AM


Originally Posted by TECHNOPUG (Post 12028219)
Sure. But then it's not going to be 400/400. 5 speed boxes are cheap, so if you are able to do the work yourself, you could probably drop in 4 5speeds for the price of a 6-speed conversion. If you are only doing track days then you may consider changing the box once a year as good value. However, the box could let go at any time. The first time you give it full throttle for example. Or it may last a few thousand miles of abuse.

If you have to pay someone else though, the labour costs will soon rack up. If you want 400/400, especially in a road car/daily driver and don't have the means to swap the box yourself, then 6speed is really the only sensible financial option.



Presumably you currently have a UK2000 or similar. Add up the cost of a reliable 400/400 engine plus 6-speed conversion and you may as well just save all that money towards getting an STi with 6-speed. Whilst it can seem attractive to get a cheaper WRX/5speed car and mod it over time, if you want more power than OEM bolts on’s (turbos, injectors etc) can provide; 330/350, then it makes far greater financial sense to buy an STi as a starting point. Law of diminishing returns – power is cheap and easy at first but gets progressively more expensive £/bhp. Especially once you’ve exceeded OEM parts capability and need to buy aftermarket turbos, forge the engine, strengthen drivetrain etc.



What mods/power are you running at the moment?

I'm running about 220ish maybe a bit less. I rescued the car long story and doing it up in stages.just a k&n filter and front mount intercooler set up. I've put in a 255 walbro pump and new plugs and leads. I work for a main dealer as a tech

TECHNOPUG 25 September 2018 11:54 AM

300/300 shouldn't be an issue but you can destroy a box on stock power if you abuse it. A little mechanica sympathy goes a long way.

Rick2017 25 September 2018 11:57 AM


Originally Posted by TECHNOPUG (Post 12028223)
300/300 shouldn't be an issue but you can destroy a box on stock power if you abuse it. A little mechanica sympathy goes a long way.

that's why I was asking about the boxes. You no like someone who's been there and done type of thing. Gives me an idea of what I can do then. I surpose a good transmission oil would help abit as well

johnlogie 25 September 2018 12:33 PM

I would stick to around 300. I really don’t see the point in spending the money to get the car reliable at much higher power level when you can’t use that power properly on the road anyway.

Rick2017 25 September 2018 12:54 PM


Originally Posted by johnlogie (Post 12028229)
I would stick to around 300. I really don’t see the point in spending the money to get the car reliable at much higher power level when you can’t use that power properly on the road anyway.

that's very true .I'm changing rear mains on Saturday and the oil separator along with a stock sti clutch.

Ash Webster 19 November 2018 02:14 PM


Originally Posted by johnlogie (Post 12028229)
I would stick to around 300. I really don’t see the point in spending the money to get the car reliable at much higher power level when you can’t use that power properly on the road anyway.

For time attack racing (so no hard launches) do you think a GC8 5 speed STI box would still suffice or again is the best option the 6 speed box.... Trying to sort out my budget for the next year. I'll be running close to 400.

Cheers,

johnlogie 19 November 2018 06:55 PM


Originally Posted by Ash Webster (Post 12035288)
For time attack racing (so no hard launches) do you think a GC8 5 speed STI box would still suffice or again is the best option the 6 speed box.... Trying to sort out my budget for the next year. I'll be running close to 400.

Cheers,

i wouldn’t like to say Ash. My first gearbox went at a little over 300bhp on the road (while I was in Ireland :( ). Another on the road, one at knockhill doing a track day. Up to this point I had never launched the car. The last one went at Elvington where I tried the drag strip for the first time. I had no confidence in the gearbox lasting the day and knew it would go at some point.

Ash Webster 20 November 2018 11:31 AM


Originally Posted by johnlogie (Post 12035344)


i wouldn’t like to say Ash. My first gearbox went at a little over 300bhp on the road (while I was in Ireland :( ). Another on the road, one at knockhill doing a track day. Up to this point I had never launched the car. The last one went at Elvington where I tried the drag strip for the first time. I had no confidence in the gearbox lasting the day and knew it would go at some point.

ouch I'm already running ~330. WIll have to put the new turbo back until after the 6 speed.

thanks for the info


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:22 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands