ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   Projects (https://www.scoobynet.com/projects-40/)
-   -   Williams Motorsport meets EngineMapper the great modification test mule (https://www.scoobynet.com/projects-40/882306-williams-motorsport-meets-enginemapper-the-great-modification-test-mule.html)

SouthWalesSam 28 August 2011 05:17 PM

This is a fantastic, informative thread. Big, big thanks to both EngineMapper and WMS for all your efforts!


Originally Posted by EngineMapper (Post 10207536)
Leeturbo, pinks would be ideal for this setup. I wanted to test the validity of modified injectors on the newage cars. I've already mapped a number of cars that have the earlier type side feed yellows which have been modified with very unimpressive results. So in short, 550 pinks are ideal and the original ECU would run and drive as standard on these injectors. It just doesn't cope as well with much bigger injectors.

Leeturbo, EngineMapper, I've just spent two weeks trying to work out which size injectors would suit for a progressive step-wise upgrade to 310-320bhp with maximum drivability on my Newage WRX. You've easily answered my question. I'm off to find a set of used Sti 550cc pinks. Thanks. :thumb:

Sam

juggers 28 August 2011 07:50 PM


Originally Posted by SouthWalesSam (Post 10208559)
This is a fantastic, informative thread. Big, big thanks to both EngineMapper and WMS for all your efforts!



Leeturbo, EngineMapper, I've just spent two weeks trying to work out which size injectors would suit for a progressive step-wise upgrade to 310-320bhp with maximum drivability on my Newage WRX. You've easily answered my question. I'm off to find a set of used Sti 550cc pinks. Thanks. :thumb:

Sam

I'll have a set of used injectors next week pm me ;)

jameswrx 29 August 2011 10:34 AM


Originally Posted by EngineMapper (Post 10191203)
So I thought I'd go out for a hoon tonight after our discussions about dynos and get some real world figures and on the road AIT readings.

Ambient temperature was 11c and I was able to start each run with an AIT of 20c so this was the dyno run result:


http://www.enginemapper.co.uk/testmule/testmule.jpg

On a dyno run in 2nd I would see the AIT rise to around 28c max. So I had a go at doing some runs all the way up the gears. Starting at 20c again I would ultimately see 48-55c at the end of a run through the gears.

I then had a go at some 1/4 mile runs, as my road dyno allows me to collect this data:

1/4mile = 12.871s @ 110.94mph (Std WRX = 14.3 PPP = 13.7)

Speeds were:

0-60 = 4.305s (Std WRX = 5.5 PPP = 4.8) +22% improvement
0-100 = 10.603s (Std WRX = 15.9 PPP = 14.1) +33%

Passing speeds were:

30-50 = 1.873s (Std WRX = 2.4 PPP = 2) +22%
40-60 = 1.584s (Std WRX = 2.6 PPP = 2.3) +39%
50-70 = 2.404s (Std WRX = 3.5 PPP = 2.9) +32%
60-80 = 2.721s (Std WRX = 3.8 PPP = 3.2) +29%

Generally I'm very pleased with the results so far, i've never done a properly timed 1/4 mile and it is only running with budget tyres currently.

Graham

Surely you should have 400bhp at the flywheel with that wheel power, or does that extrapolation only come about on ported vf35's? :wonder:

;)

vulnax999 29 August 2011 11:24 AM

I think the road dyno converts the wheel HP to flywheel HP, as the carweight etc. tre size etc. are entered into the programme beforethe power run ... at least on ECUTek s/ware after mapping they are.

EngineMapper @ Group B Motorsport 03 September 2011 06:57 PM

The road dyno throws out a wheel bhp and torque figure. I then use the Dyno Dynamics standard transmission loss figures to convert from wheel to flywheel.

So 275.2bhp at the wheels converts to 352.8bhp at the flywheel, using a transmission loss of 22% which is fairly standard on a UK 5 speed Impreza.

Graham

Andy916 08 September 2011 10:40 AM

Great thread!

I'm particularly interested in the ported standard / tubular headers difference. I'm at (or should be at) the borderline where the extra flow of tubular becomes advantageous. MD321H turbo, but currently running on Harvey ported + wrapped headers and Harvey uppipe. This is on a classic, with K&N 57i, Samco inlet, hybrid fmic, 550 injectors, Walbro 255, forged 2.0, 3" decat.

Right now it manages only 355bhp/305lbft on the Zen dyno, mapped by Paul, and tubular headers may be the next step.

Andy

SouthWalesSam 08 September 2011 01:44 PM


I'm at (or should be at) the borderline where the extra flow of tubular becomes advantageous. MD321H turbo, but currently running on Harvey ported + wrapped headers and Harvey uppipe. This is on a classic, with K&N 57i, Samco inlet, hybrid fmic, 550 injectors, Walbro 255, forged 2.0, 3" decat.
Andy, I'm no expert but ... could it be that you're at the limit of your 550 injectors?
You might want to check injector sizing first if you want to go further up the power scale.

E.g.: http://www.witchhunter.com/injectorcalc1.php4

Sam

Andy916 08 September 2011 02:24 PM


Originally Posted by SouthWalesSam (Post 10225654)
Andy, I'm no expert but ... could it be that you're at the limit of your 550 injectors?
You might want to check injector sizing first if you want to go further up the power scale.

E.g.: http://www.witchhunter.com/injectorcalc1.php4

Sam

The injectors come close to max on the current map, but aren't the limit right now. For sure though, bigger ones or an FPR running higher pressure will be needed if a future map needs more fuel.

Andy

Davey96wrx 22 September 2011 01:01 AM

What a great read so far!

Well done to you both for taking on such a project!

Interesting that you can predict/ measure 1/4 times on the dyno, as some modifications can sometimes change the way the power is developed and where in the rev range. ie a tune yielding a max figure of 310 hp can sometimes be faster than a 330 tune depending on where the torque and power is made. Some people don't get this sometimes, would be interesting if you could exhibit this...

BLU 28 September 2011 03:43 PM


Originally Posted by Davey96wrx (Post 10248284)
Interesting that you can predict/ measure 1/4 times on the dyno, as some modifications can sometimes change the way the power is developed and where in the rev range. ie a tune yielding a max figure of 310 hp can sometimes be faster than a 330 tune depending on where the torque and power is made. Most people don't get this most of the time, would be interesting if you could exhibit this...

EFA ;).
I too would love a way for this to be exhibited........I've a few people I'd like to show it to :lol1:

wrxsti280 28 September 2011 11:12 PM

Graham, can you do a back to back on an induction kit open and an induction kit heat shielded, as most people seem to think they just suck in hot air, and would like to know as ive looked at shielding mine off on this basis, but ive also read that it doesnt make much difference??

Interesting thread by the way, i will be keeping up to date with it as you add info.

bonesetter 29 September 2011 08:24 AM


Originally Posted by wrxsti280 (Post 10258795)
Graham, can you do a back to back on an induction kit open and an induction kit heat shielded, as most people seem to think they just suck in hot air, and would like to know as ive looked at shielding mine off on this basis, but ive also read that it doesnt make much difference??

Interesting thread by the way, i will be keeping up to date with it as you add info.

If trying this, IMHO, would need on road data-logging, as on the rollers would recirculate the warm air in the building

Would be a good one though

BrownPantsRacing 29 September 2011 10:13 AM


Originally Posted by SouthWalesSam (Post 10225654)

So i'm running 334bhp at flywheel on my 550cc Hawkeye WRX injectors. According to this i'm running a 91% duty cycle. Would that be correct? Seems a little high!

Andy

dooda 29 September 2011 01:17 PM

Brilliant thread, can't wait for the next update.

PaulJC 29 September 2011 01:21 PM

Interesting reading so far :)

Gutted1974 25 October 2011 11:32 AM

What a thread.....

Subscribed

greg320 25 October 2011 01:10 PM

Subscribed

Gutted1974 25 October 2011 02:21 PM

well -

SO impressed with Scooby net. Saved me getting scammed. Got a great deal on a brake disc and pad set that seem to have been running in nicely (until the standard engine blew) from www.godspeedbrakes.co.uk

thank you Ian.

Now that I need the engine doing, I have decided to use the great combo of Andy and Graham and will sending my car up to them on a low loader to have the following works done....

Semi forged pistons and rods, ground crank etc etc in a rebuilt engine from Andys stocks...

Matched with the following upgrades...

NGK7 plugs,
Shimmed oil pump spring
Cambelt
VF35 turbo upgrade
EM 750cc injectors
Cosworth or Pro R air filter
Steel gaskets all round ofcourse
Header ex manifold (WMS will describe the one im sure)...

So I am hoping to see my car back in a while throwing out about 300bhp (wish I could afford the ecu upgrade) and will be sure to sing these guys praises from the rooftops.

GREAT thread, GREAT contact and communications. Really very optimistic and comfortable to go with you both.

Cheers

James

Hudson_rj 01 November 2011 05:04 PM

This thread is fantastic. Excellent read. Well done guys.

Just to throw one into the mix. I'd be really interested how detrimental to power output exhaust bungs are, if at all, when fitted? I love my bung. :p

Cheers

Gutted1974 03 November 2011 03:13 PM

I am one over the moon chappy!!

My broken car is now fixed, collection tomorrow.

Andy has clearly done a great job on the rebuild and mods and Graham has managed to tweek it such that it is returning 309 bhp!!!

I guess I should wait to drive it before saying a massive thank you, but its there waiting for ya both chaps!!!

Gutted1974 05 November 2011 10:35 AM

THANK YOU Andy and Graham

Having collected my car last night I am 100% over the moon!!!

The way it pulls I might have to be careful that I dont end up ON the moon!!

Amazing job chaps.

8 day turn around. Very friendly and honest work. HIGHLY recommend!!

Thanks - I will have to get a new forum membership and change name to Happy1974!!
:luxhello::luxhello:

WAZ WRX 03 January 2012 08:41 AM

Fantastic thread! You have got me me hooked, ive have just read eveything from start to finish and for a novice when it comes to tuning it is great advice a knowledge learnt. Id just like to thank andy and graham for the amount of time and effort you have put into the "mule" lol, as it is appreciated by all of us scooby neters.

By the way graham where are you based? As i would love to pay you a visit for some mapping

Frazer 03 January 2012 09:28 AM

Can flat shift be setup on a standard ECU with a thorrle cabel?

EngineMapper @ Group B Motorsport 03 January 2012 06:22 PM

No I'm afraid it cannot on the standard ECU.

Graham

EngineMapper @ Group B Motorsport 03 January 2012 06:23 PM


Originally Posted by WAZ WRX (Post 10407670)
Fantastic thread! You have got me me hooked, ive have just read eveything from start to finish and for a novice when it comes to tuning it is great advice a knowledge learnt. Id just like to thank andy and graham for the amount of time and effort you have put into the "mule" lol, as it is appreciated by all of us scooby neters.

By the way graham where are you based? As i would love to pay you a visit for some mapping

Waz my apologies, I never replied to this, I'm based in Deeside near Chester if I can still be of assistance.

Graham

MrNoisy 04 January 2012 09:10 AM

When is the next instalment coming Graham? We're all intrigued!
Epic stuff - keep it up :thumb:

WMS 04 January 2012 10:57 AM

Happy new year everyone, firstly I would like to say sorry for the lack of progress recently, we have both been very busy earning a living unfortunately. I was also made a very good offer for the Mules engine/box and diff, so thats all been shipped over to Germany. I hope we can start again when time allows, neither of of us are twindling our thumbs though, I'm building a 2.25 development engine so I will post the results of that when we get her fired up. Graham was last seen in a concrete bunker near the English border clutching a large amount of turbo parts..........I wonder what He's up to??????

TeddyTaylor 27 April 2012 11:18 AM


Originally Posted by Bugeye_Scoob (Post 10409969)
When is the next instalment coming Graham? We're all intrigued!
Epic stuff - keep it up :thumb:

Here here, keep checking back but it's been very quiet for months now. Must be some news :sleep::lol1:

bonesetter 27 April 2012 01:22 PM

Engine was sold abroad, and car sold too - time's right for everything I guess

EngineMapper @ Group B Motorsport 28 April 2012 01:48 AM

Yes I'm afraid Andy got a very generous offer to sell the parts out of the mule and so not to miss the opportunity, took it. We're looking into a few other modding avenues at the moment and an STi which will hopefully undergo some turbo testing as the mule was at it's peak output as a WRX.

Incidentally the last test I did but never wrote about was in regards to water spray and intake cooling. We tried an aquamist system, but I found it actually hindered power when running, (jets thought to be over sized for the application), although it did bring down intake temperatures by 3-4c. However as a little test I bought a bag of ice from the Spa and dumped a load on the intercooler, reducing the temps to below ambient. I seem to remember ambient being 18c and intake temps being 8-10c on a run with ice cooling, which netted a best run of 350bhp and 370lb/ft!!

Graham


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 09:43 AM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands