ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   Non Scooby Related (https://www.scoobynet.com/non-scooby-related-4/)
-   -   Whats the future of hi-fi, is it all MP3's. (https://www.scoobynet.com/non-scooby-related-4/868384-whats-the-future-of-hi-fi-is-it-all-mp3s.html)

Jamie 17 January 2011 12:09 AM

I know flashplayer adobe will not work on my ipod we are doomed :(

ricardo 17 January 2011 10:50 AM

All my music is ripped from purchased CD to FLAC, then a separate variable bit-rate copy made in MP3 format (for mobile and car use).

I use Exact Audio Copy to do the ripping, so it checks that the copy matches other people's copies using the AccurateRip database.


For music playback the lossless FLAC files are streamed into a SqueezeBox and then the analogue signal into a Yamaha AV amp - but the Yamaha pre-outs go to a pair of separate mono power amps for the main stereo speakers. Each of those amps drives a Yamaha NS1000M speaker - old now but sort of legendary... There is also a Yamaha sub, plus the centre and rear Mordaunt-Short speakers. Speaker placement (especially the sub) has been done very carefully to suit the wedge-shaped room - it is normal height at one end where the PJ screen is and double height at the other, so in one sense the room is part of the system.

The physical arrangement compromises pure music listening since it is still fundamentally an AV system, but I can live with it.

I'd love to be able to download FLAC, but there is a lot to be said for having the CDs as a physical backup.

TelBoy 17 January 2011 03:33 PM

Just as it was about to fall off the front page, sorry.

I'm as big a hi-fi nut as anyone on here, but it's obvious to me that the days of "real" hi-fi are numbered, at least for the masses.

Which is a shame. No iPod dock in the world can replicate the effect of a properly set up hi-fi, and no MP3 can knock a good record into the weeds.

But as has been said before, it's all about instant gratification these days. When putting on a cd is too much hassle for many, you know you're fighting a losing battle.

But i reckon cd will be around for a while longer, maybe as a niche market along with vinyl. But it's a shame that convenience has taken priority over quality. Sign of the times.

Funkii Munkii 17 January 2011 05:08 PM

Great thread bar the Apple intrusion ;)

So many points to agree with on here, I have 3 to 4 set ups in my house covering all bases.

My seperates are my pride and joy and by far the best system to listen to.

I have my separates in the dining room and still to this day I look to improve the sound, Technics Pre and Power Amp, Dragon cassette deck (still commands a fortune on e-bay) a top end Sony QS SACD player and a Pure DAB tuner all coming out of four lovely Missions, one pair Freedom 770 MkV must be coming up to 25 years old and the clarity is something else, coupled with a pair of punchier M74'is is near perfect for me.

But that still doesn't stop you looking for something better, I'll often be on e-bay looking for a bargain, I'd quite happily buy a 20 year old 2nd hand Amp but would never consider a 2nd hand i-pod. Seperates can be a thing of visual and aural beauty whereas an i-pod/mp3 player never will be.

I have a seperate AV amp and speakers in the lounge, I once ran everything through the Yammy AV amp when I moved home and had the one living room, the AV amp is fine for watching movies but it was horrific for music even when switched to 2 channel it was so weak and lacked so much depth and clarity that music needs, I ended up sticking an amp in the kitchen with 2 Mission 72i's and the SACD player, p1ssed on the Yammy.

Decent speakers and a sub on the pc, and a Sony mini system with DAB, i-pod dock in the kitchen, which isn't bad, I wired up the 74i's for a bit of fun and it rocked.

All of that said, I love my i-pod as well, perfect for the car and flights.

I think all formats can live happily under one roof as long as they are used in the correct context, although you cant Bi-wire or Bi-Amp an MP3 player ;).

I had a play with a Beresford DAC which my Bros in law swears by, to be honest it made no difference through the Technics pre/power combo coupled with the SACD player but through his Harmon Kardon set up there is a noticeable difference.

Graphic Equalisers anyone ??, looked down upon by many enjoyed by many others, all down to your ear I guess, I'm running an Old Technics 8055 to fine tune, but was recently give a Technics Digital Sound procesor GE90 which I am still to hook up in place of the EQ, just to see what it sounds like, EQ's still get quite a bit of attention on E-bay some of the higher end models going for some good money.

If I ever win the Lotto A large chunk will be spent at a decent Hi-Fi emporium after popping to a few main dealers to pick up some wheels to carry all my new Hi-fi home :D.

SRSport 17 January 2011 05:21 PM

Ok so hypothetically you have £10,000 to spend on a sound system do you,
1) £5000 surround sound and £5000 on HIFI
or
2)£10,000 on surround sound and use the superior system for music.

With no.2 you get a surround system that offers surround sound that is worth twice as much as the £5000 set up and would offer significant improvements on you music as well (compared to the £5000 surrounds setup), maybe equal to a £4000 hifi system.

It wouldnt be quite as good as the £5000 system for hifi but overall you are getting much better value for money...aren't you? As you loose out on £1000 value for music but gain £5000 of surround value.

f1_fan 17 January 2011 05:29 PM


Originally Posted by SRSport (Post 9827052)
Ok so hypothetically you have £10,000 to spend on a sound system do you,
1) £5000 surround sound and £5000 on HIFI
or
2)£10,000 on surround sound and use the superior system for music.

With no.2 you get a surround system that offers surround sound that is worth twice as much as the £5000 set up and would offer significant improvements on you music as well (compared to the £5000 surrounds setup), maybe equal to a £4000 hifi system.

It wouldnt be quite as good as the £5000 system for hifi but overall you are getting much better value for money...aren't you? As you loose out on £1000 value for music but gain £5000 of surround value.

To my mind if you are spending that sort of money you can have the best of both worlds by building a decent audio system and piggy backing surroud onto itv ia an external processor sets of extra amps and speakers for the surrround set up.

Spend aorund 10K wisely and you will have a system that will shame most people's systems from either side of the divide.

ALi-B 17 January 2011 05:48 PM


Graphic Equalisers anyone ??, looked down upon by many enjoyed by many others, all down to your ear I guess, I'm running an Old Technics 8055 to fine tune, but was recently give a Technics Digital Sound procesor GE90 which I am still to hook up in place of the EQ, just to see what it sounds like, EQ's still get quite a bit of attention on E-bay some of the higher end models going for some good money.

Love 'em; The more adjustability the better. Especially when you can adjust each band's bandwidth curve (1N, 2N, 1Q 2Q etc). A GE90 would look quite natty under my SU-X901. :)

Very handy in a room with odd accoustics.

SRSport 17 January 2011 06:00 PM


Originally Posted by f1_fan (Post 9827074)
To my mind if you are spending that sort of money you can have the best of both worlds by building a decent audio system and piggy backing surroud onto itv ia an external processor sets of extra amps and speakers for the surrround set up.

So similar to no2 but more the other way around? HiFi based with external decoding etc.

Only reason I ask is that I live in hope that one day the question will apply for real and I think your suggestion is a pretty good one.

Rob_Impreza99 17 January 2011 06:01 PM


Originally Posted by ALi-B (Post 9827119)
Love 'em; The more adjustability the better. Especially when you can adjust each band's bandwidth curve (1N, 2N, 1Q 2Q etc). A GE90 would look quite natty under my SU-X901. :)

Very handy in a room with odd accoustics.

I have the technics GE90, its in the pic i posted earlier on the thread. The sound difference using the GE90 graphic equalizer is immense, you can fine tune it to suit different styles of music.

I love the Technics seperates system that i have but i decided to down scale, its fine if you have a large room that can take 4 or 5 large class AA seperates and a big hi fi stand but its overkill for the room i`m doing up as an AV room. The sound that a technics seperates system produces is stunning especially with some quality speakers. Mine still performs the same as the day when i first bought it, the build quality is superb.

Funkii Munkii 17 January 2011 06:50 PM


Originally Posted by ALi-B (Post 9827119)
Love 'em; The more adjustability the better. Especially when you can adjust each band's bandwidth curve (1N, 2N, 1Q 2Q etc). A GE90 would look quite natty under my SU-X901. :)

Very handy in a room with odd accoustics.

I might be selling it soon, it just doesn't look as good along side the SU A800M2, whereas the 8055 does :D
Like I said I need to try it out before parting with it, and even then it will be hard, I'm a bloody hoarder :lol1:

Funkii Munkii 17 January 2011 06:52 PM


Originally Posted by Rob_Impreza99 (Post 9827147)
I love the Technics seperates system that i have but i decided to down scale, its fine if you have a large room that can take 4 or 5 large class AA seperates and a big hi fi stand but its overkill for the room i`m doing up as an AV room. The sound that a technics seperates system produces is stunning especially with some quality speakers. Mine still performs the same as the day when i first bought it, the build quality is superb.

:nono:

Don't do it, you'll regret it

Rob_Impreza99 17 January 2011 07:09 PM


Originally Posted by Funkii Munkii (Post 9827263)
I might be selling it soon, it just doesn't look as good along side the SU A800M2:

The amp i have is the SUA 900MK2, it was the top of the range amp at the time, ive read some fairly recent reviews that say its probably the best stereo amp that technics produced.


Originally Posted by Funkii Munkii (Post 9827270)
:nono:

Don't do it, you'll regret it

Ive already bought a replacement, its a Teac Reference 600 system. It was more about space, i wanted to neaten things up and make the room more compact and clean looking.

mart360 17 January 2011 08:35 PM

There are many esoteric bits of kit out there, some i would love to audition - own, others are pure snake oil.

Ive always fancied a pair of Wilson Watt & Puppys, but tbh, i doubt i ever will.

Unfortunately with hi-fi, there is a lot of influence with personal taste, what sounds good to one sounds flat to another. One mans valve amp is another mans integrated receiver

Some is influenced by our own perceived values. (it must be good because it cost more) :D:. Ive seen uber expensive Van den Hull interconnects, trounced by budget offerings from Tandy lol ..Blind listening tests that blow holes in manufacturers claims. :D:D thats always a good one to see.

And then there is the the downright bizzare. Speaker cables utilising troughs of mercury for the ultimate in loss free signal.

Giwn that no one has perfect hearing, its always going to sound different to somebody else. i have a 5db dip at around 18k, so midrange to treble can sound a bit flat

At the end of the day, if it sounds good to you and gives you pleasure, then that's all that matters...

Mart

ScoobyDoo555 17 January 2011 11:04 PM

5db dip at around 18k??

That's not a dip - that's a fookin chasm!! :D :p

but that said, hearing loss at 18Khz is pretty good - unless you're a child!! :D

Dan :thumb:

Bubba po 17 January 2011 11:19 PM


Originally Posted by ScoobyDoo555 (Post 9827994)
5db dip at around 18k??

That's not a dip - that's a fookin chasm!! :D :p

but that said, hearing loss at 18Khz is pretty good - unless you're a child!! :D

Dan :thumb:

I can't hear above 14.5 kHz. That's what a life of Rock'n'roll does for you. :(

Bubba po 17 January 2011 11:23 PM

How can a dip at 18kHz make midrange sound flat? :lol1: Most adults' hearing tails off at about 16kHz anyway! And even when it does, the brain does a fantastic job of synthesising the high frequencies by analysing the frequencies it actually receives from the ear and reproducing the harmonics by processing.

Evolution Stu 18 January 2011 12:12 AM


Originally Posted by Scoob99 (Post 9824699)
Give me my Cyrus 8 system and my Mission speakers anytime, OK I have an I-Pod dock in my conservatory but anytime I want too blast out on goes the Hi-FI, Am are the only one??:D
Cheers
Colin

Not at all, me too. The Zeppellin for my MP3's is good, real good, but its not HiFi, just acceptable noise. :king:



Originally Posted by SRSport (Post 9827052)
Ok so hypothetically you have £10,000 to spend on a sound system do you,
1) £5000 surround sound and £5000 on HIFI
or
2)£10,000 on surround sound and use the superior system for music.

Funnily enough, I recently had a similar dilemma, there was a topic about it on here somewhere. :D


I have recently upgraded my storage drives at home as I am starting to collect lossless format m,usic to stream downstairs to my main system and of course have started recording 1080P video too so space is fast being consumed. LOL

Ref backing up your home machines, I have 4 at home and back them all up to my media server every morning when everyones asleep.
For those of you thinking its a ballache and huge money, its not if your using a decent system to do it on. Consider this media server that i use.
http://www.hp.com/united-states/camp...asmart-server/

Mines running 2TB of storage with full duplication (So 4x 1TB disc's) and it is fast enough to stream 2x 1080P movies to two separate systems at the same time.
It is VERY impressive indeed for the cash. :king:

RobJenks 18 January 2011 05:15 AM


Originally Posted by Scoob99 (Post 9824699)
Give me my Cyrus 8 system and my Mission speakers anytime, OK I have an I-Pod dock in my conservatory but anytime I want too blast out on goes the Hi-FI, Am are the only one??:D
Cheers
Colin

No Mate your not.
Big speakers, Big amps , quality source are the fundamentals of an involving sound end of.
I have - All sealed and locked away in storage - with with my Rex
Infinity Kappa 9's
Metaxas Solitaires (2) Power amps and Pre amp with separate power supply
Linn Sondek + +
I miss it .

cster 18 January 2011 07:11 AM


Originally Posted by f1_fan (Post 9823498)
Sadly these is a generation of peple growing up thinking MP3s are hi-fi... they are not. Put an iPod output into a decent separates system and you will hear a nasty compressed sound nothing like the expansiveness of a CD or vinyl LP.

Trouble is while everyone wants better quality TV and associated theatre sound it seems they are happy to listen to music on an iPod or the likes... it makes no logical sense to me.

With it all going to downloads I fear that compressed MP3s maybe as good as it gets in the future :(

Maybe a little bit harsh.;)
Perhaps today's generation are a little more multi media.
When I was younger, nothing gave me more pleasure than sitting in front of my own-built system listening to my music, but then again, what else was there to do?
No portable systems to compare with iPods, nor the video technology in varying forms that have become relatively very cheap through economies of scale etc.

JackClark 18 January 2011 09:11 AM

I think the future is bright, huge data centres, cheap massive personal storage and fast internet, download quality will increase. Amazon and Apple could cope now.

Geezer 18 January 2011 09:49 AM

Audiophiles will always bemoan anything that isn't absolutely top notch,like any other technology, but things like Spotify and the iPod and associated docks have made music much easier for everone, that is at a quality that is acceptable.

I would never put on a CD, too much hassle, (for me) but I have my Touch in a good dock and I listen to much more music than I used to. Ok, the sound out of the Bose is appreciably better than the cheap crap we had previously, but for 99% of people, how much better does it need to be?

If you are a sound geek, MP3s are bad news, for the music industry and bands wishing to get their music out there, it's great news.

Geezer

Funkii Munkii 18 January 2011 10:40 AM


Originally Posted by Rob_Impreza99 (Post 9827303)
The amp i have is the SUA 900MK2, it was the top of the range amp at the time, ive read some fairly recent reviews that say its probably the best stereo amp that technics produced.

They still comand upwards of £300 with the pre amp, for me there was never much in it with the 800 and the 900, I preferrred the agressive lines of the 800 over the VU meters of the 900

I was watching a SU-A909 on fleabay but the owner pulled it a couple of days from the end, a very tidy updated version of the 900.

Then there were the C1000 and 3000, never seen or heard either in the flesh (big Vu Meters again) but they had good reviews at the back end of the 90s and the latter went for £3K :freak3:

ScoobyDoo555 18 January 2011 12:44 PM

Interesting article about album listening in the news today.....

http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/magazine-12209143

Jamz3k 19 January 2011 08:53 PM

Due to this thread I got out my hifi gear for the attic! Sounded great.:D

Chris Rea - Auberge and Beautiful South - A Song For Whoever, AWESOME!:cool:

Evolution Stu 20 January 2011 09:10 AM


Originally Posted by Jamz3k (Post 9831494)
Due to this thread I got out my hifi gear for the attic! Sounded great.:D

Chris Rea - Auberge and Beautiful South - A Song For Whoever, AWESOME!:cool:


Two amazing tracks which I will dig out tonight and play. My biggest surprise, sound wise, was playing Dido's album on my new system! WOW! :eek:

f1_fan 29 January 2011 05:06 PM


Originally Posted by JackClark (Post 9828333)
I think the future is bright, huge data centres, cheap massive personal storage and fast internet, download quality will increase. Amazon and Apple could cope now.

Replayed via what though.... a PC??? May as well stick with MP3.

oobyJu 29 January 2011 09:12 PM

sold lots my vinyl bought cd's now never buy cd's is vastly inferior to flac taken from good vinyl so now only buy vinyl again (listening to 180gram sabotage atm) and the sound........pisses on mp3 regardless of bitrate or system as the information just isn't there to be reproduced but then i am over 40 lol

Jamz3k 09 June 2011 01:54 PM

CD may be dead but it sure is alive in my backroom thisafternoon! MP3 is utter wank fact!

vindaloo 09 June 2011 03:17 PM


Originally Posted by paulr (Post 9823484)
For people of a certain age, hi-fi was all about separates. Pioneer, Marantz, Tannoy, or if you were nerdy enough Nad. Now all the hi-fi shops seems to be closing. Sevenoaks are a good example, the one in Hull has shut, and whenever i go into the one in Lincoln, its empty. If you go into the Apple store in Meadowhall though, queue's,queue's and queue's. Is the future all mp3's. I have to admit the last three music items i bought were two ipods and a dock.
However, if its quality you want, you cannot beat separates, and by that i mean an amp, cd player and two speakers. Not a 5.1 set up.

Is the future all MP3's, docking stations and headphones. (it would be sad if it was)

People tend to spend the dosh these days on sound/cinema systems. As with all things, there's a compromise. Dynamics/bass extension vs soundstage and ultimate detail maybe?!

A mate stores all of his CDs as uncompressed WAV files. He would use FLAC or similar but the convenience of MP3 seems to have killed off FLAC on personal or ICE systems. Disk storage is so cheap these days though...

J.


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 11:39 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands