ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum

ScoobyNet.com - Subaru Enthusiast Forum (https://www.scoobynet.com/)
-   ScoobyNet General (https://www.scoobynet.com/scoobynet-general-1/)
-   -   Water Spray Switch - What's the story? (https://www.scoobynet.com/scoobynet-general-1/453301-water-spray-switch-whats-the-story.html)

Hol 31 August 2005 08:01 PM

Im going to use the standard logic of the waterspray on my 03STI to run my water injection.

Because the auto function can map to boost & intake heat it will be a lot better than just an ERL boost switch. And aI get the benefit of a nice separate water bottle with a low level warning light.

johnfelstead 31 August 2005 08:05 PM

Pete, you sad ****, when you know something about a subject then your input is welcome, in this instance you know **** all, so shut your gob. :D

Only done castle comb a couple of times and didnt time myself, so couldnt comment on that i am afraid. It's not a circuit i like to be honest.

johnfelstead 31 August 2005 08:34 PM


Originally Posted by Hol
Im going to use the standard logic of the waterspray on my 03STI to run my water injection.

Because the auto function can map to boost & intake heat it will be a lot better than just an ERL boost switch. And aI get the benefit of a nice separate water bottle with a low level warning light.

for WI intake temp isnt a useful sensor input. That value is read at the airbox intake where the MAF sensor is located (its part of the MAF on new age cars), and is not a charge temp reading. For best results WI should trigger on at 42 degrees C charge temp and switch off at 38 degrees C charge temp, with a boost reading of 6psi and above, below those values WI will lose power. You can of course just use boost for WI triggering, but most of the time this will lose you power as its not that common to be over 42 degrees charge temp on a road car, once on the move.

Nick Read 31 August 2005 09:11 PM

I think I've mentioned this to someone before, but if you're interested in water spray, water injection, charge temps, cold air feeds, intercooler location etc then you could do a lot worse than look into some of the DIY thinking, testing and making that goes on at http://autospeed.drive.com.au/

It's an Aussie website and these guys really know their stuff - informative at all levels and they don't take ANYTHING for granted in the world of tuning turbocharged motors. Every idea is tried and given the thumbs up (or down). Definitely worth a look.

pslewis 31 August 2005 11:03 PM


Originally Posted by sammyh
Pete, would there be any chance of you posting something constructive for a change? :p

Oh, dear ............ a SENIOR Moderator has got a little hot under the collar (could it be the description fitted just a little too well??? :D )

And who thought up the term Senior Moderator???? I admire your efforts and time freely given ................. but, do me a favour - jobsworth titles?????

Come on, we all know the water Spray thingy is a toy which does bugger all useful!! Anyone know how much power is drained by carrying around 20 Litres of water??? :rolleyes:

Pete :D

johnfelstead 01 September 2005 01:01 AM


Originally Posted by pslewis
Anyone know how much power is drained by carrying around 20 Litres of water??? :rolleyes:

Why dont you ask Nial McShae or Martin Rowe? They decided to haul that around with them on their Production World Rally Championship winning seasons in their Prodrive built production based Impreza rally cars.

pslewis 01 September 2005 08:32 AM


Originally Posted by johnfelstead
Why dont you ask Nial McShae or Martin Rowe? They decided to haul that around with them on their Production World Rally Championship winning seasons in their Prodrive built production based Impreza rally cars.

I very much doubt they would bother with such junk whilst taking little Jonny to school ............ :rolleyes: do you??

I doubt they would wear helmets and a full body harness either ........... and the bump over the kerb at the Park wouldn't justify a Rollcage I am guessing??????

So, why really bother with something as pointless as a water spray unless you are trying to shave 0.0000002 second off a Rally Stage??

Like I said ..................... utterly useless piece of kit!

Pete

Nick Read 01 September 2005 10:51 AM


Originally Posted by pslewis

Come on, we all know the water Spray thingy is a toy which does bugger all useful!! Anyone know how much power is drained by carrying around 20 Litres of water??? :rolleyes:

Pete :D

Pete, I guess you got the '20 l. of water' thing from my hypothetical example? Well for a start, carrying 20 litres doesn't drain your power in any way at all. You could pull a caravan behind you and you'd still have the same amount of power. But that would be pedantic as I'm sure you don't mean THAT.

I ASSUME you're raising the question of how an extra 20 litres (or 20kg in weight) would affect your power-weight ratio? Well if you're worried about an extra 20kg on top of a road-spec Scoob, which must be - at a guess - 1300kg if not more, then you're talking about a difference as insignificant as 0.000000002 seconds over a rally stage... that you yourself quoted as the reason why water spray was a waste of time LOL

The fact is that a road spec car does not need a 20 litre water tank because it's on-boost duty cycle is nothing like a competition car's. However fast a driver might like to go on the roads, it's impossible to drive around on full boost or full brakes all the time, therefore that amount of water is not necessary. A 2 or 3 litre reservoir will easily do the job and will provide that extra margin of engine safety in real world driving situations that you meet on the road - e.g. sitting at the lights for half a minute in the height of summer then you want full boost available when they go green, a fourth gear overtake to pass a long line of crawling traffic.

The difference it makes might be small in everyday driving but occasionally it can be handy, and the weight penalty it carries on a road car is so small that you might as well have it, rather than not. There is no downside to IC water spray, although there are certainly much better ways of controlling the 'auto' function and the key to correctly using it in 'manual' is to spray BEFORE you are going to cane it, not during or after.

It's basically a free of charge power restorer; I can't understand what possible argument there can be against that. It would be like if Optimax was the same price as normal unleaded and you chose not to use Optimax because you didn't think it was necessary. You won't make more power than the engine is tuned for by using Optimax but you'll sure as hell lose power if you don't. The actual amount that you lose isn't the issue - it's whether you're happy to lose it or whether you'd rather use something that's free of charge to get it back.

automodellistagt 01 September 2005 11:28 AM


Originally Posted by Chelspeed
It's very straight forward. On rally cars it was useful to control charge temperatures so they wanted to fit one. Homologation rules didn't let them fit any performance enhancing mods unless it was on the road car. So the road cars got intercooling sprays.

Homologation only covers whether it's fitted or not and the method of controlling it is free. So rally cars get expensive ECU control of spray but road cars get a cheap manual switch.

Is it useful on rally cars? Yes, otherwise they wouldn't lug the weight of the water round. Is it useful on road cars? No, it's there for homologation purposes.

but there is no homogolation rules now, because of them moving to WRC rules rather then the groups. ?

Its half and half: a gimmick and a useful mod.

When sitting in traffic on a sunday blast following that campervan doing 10mph, spraying the water will lower the temps, meaning that you can get back on boost quicker and enjoy the rest of your drive

pslewis 01 September 2005 01:38 PM

To get on boost quicker????????????? What are we talking?? 1 second???

FFS it DOESNT matter on normal roads unless you are driving like an absolute PRATT!!

Like I said earlier ................... pointless!!

Pete

johnfelstead 01 September 2005 09:20 PM


Originally Posted by automodellistagt
but there is no homogolation rules now, because of them moving to WRC rules rather then the groups. ?

There are homologation rules, for the Production WRC Group N cars, thats what the Spec C is built for.

The spec C carries a 20L tank, the other STi's have aprox 5 litres of capacity to reflect their lower requirement of water usage.

pslewis 01 September 2005 09:32 PM

Does the EVO have a water spray system??

Pete

Gary C 01 September 2005 10:54 PM


Originally Posted by pslewis
Does the EVO have a water spray system??

Pete

Yes

Never really used the EVO V manual system, more than enough power without messing with a little switch.

Never noticed the difference in using it on my EVO or my STi. The GT4 did not have it and I did not miss it.

johnfelstead 01 September 2005 11:25 PM


Originally Posted by pslewis
Does the EVO have a water spray system??

Pete

They have a FMIC.

JTaylor 01 September 2005 11:38 PM


Originally Posted by johnfelstead
They have a FMIC.

Really sorry to highjack (briefly).

JOHN,

would you mind having a look at this

http://bbs.scoobynet.co.uk/showthrea...83#post4952383

please.

Thanks in advance

stevie boy 02 September 2005 11:32 AM

makkinens defo has water spray, don't no if all VI do? and was it not the VII that used some form of condensor (or something) so you didn't have to fill it up with water.

stevie

MadMark 02 September 2005 02:02 PM


Originally Posted by sammyh
Pete, would there be any chance of you posting something constructive for a change? :p

"Oh look Sammy - its a flying Pig" :D

automodellistagt 02 September 2005 04:57 PM


Originally Posted by Chelspeed
Some places actually call the intercooler a "charge cooler".

To add to that an intercooler is air to air

a chargecooler is when they use air-to-water-to-air

a little radiator is added, this cools the water, that then goes to a reverse radiator that cools the charge air

Gary C 02 September 2005 10:34 PM


Originally Posted by johnfelstead
They have a FMIC.

And water spray too

Generally manual up to EVO VI and auto after that,

Some of the Toyota GT4 CS's (often called the GT4 CS'WRC') had extras which included a water spray system, but it was never connected by the factory. Not needed on the road car, only really there for homlogation.

Their is no doubt that it worked on rally cars, but I think their is also little doubt that it was included on many of the non-homlogation road car versions to give an aura of 'rally car' specialness as 99.9999% of the drivers would have no idea when to use it.

pslewis 02 September 2005 10:55 PM

The IC Water Spray Discussion Group:-

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/08...SNAnalClub.jpg :rolleyes:

Pete :D :D

Gary C 02 September 2005 11:02 PM

Oh, go wash your incontinence pants ;)

EBRWRX 03 September 2005 12:14 AM

I'm in the strange position of actually agreeing with young Mr Lewis on this point. Reading through the bs, catfights and views the simple explanation seems to be that for 95% of Scooby drivers this is about as useful as a dysfunctional knob at a suicide bombers reward in heaven.

I include myself in that 95% bracket, along with that other worthless pile of poo split diff thingamejig. Both of mine haven't been touched from new. However for 5% of drivers these things are important, are used and most importantly are UNDERSTOOD what they are being used for, so PS is (as usual) less than constructive in his response.

wakeboardar 03 September 2005 12:23 AM


Originally Posted by pslewis
Oh, dear ............ a SENIOR Moderator has got a little hot under the collar (could it be the description fitted just a little too well??? :D )

And who thought up the term Senior Moderator???? I admire your efforts and time freely given ................. but, do me a favour - jobsworth titles?????

Come on, we all know the water Spray thingy is a toy which does bugger all useful!! Anyone know how much power is drained by carrying around 20 Litres of water??? :rolleyes:

Pete :D

ok this lewis guy is a nob but have to say he is very funny

Gary C 03 September 2005 11:05 PM

PS Lewis

Its like big brother

You know most of it is crap, and bound to annoy, but you just cant resist checking up on the latest episode :)

TonyBurns 03 September 2005 11:23 PM

Pete, its not there to increase power, just decrease charge temps, but in your opinion its like the turbo on your car, useless ;)

Tony:D

a1oku 04 September 2005 09:27 PM


Originally Posted by pslewis
The IC Water Spray Discussion Group:-

http://img.photobucket.com/albums/08...SNAnalClub.jpg :rolleyes:

Pete :D :D

gem!!!keep up the good work!!!nerds dont like bein pictured!!!they neva recognise themselves!!!gota go and squirt my nozzle.

DPat 05 September 2005 09:00 AM


Originally Posted by pslewis
To get on boost quicker????????????? What are we talking?? 1 second???

FFS it DOESNT matter on normal roads unless you are driving like an absolute PRATT!!

Like I said earlier ................... pointless!!

Pete

If you sit in traffic and the intercooler gets too warm then max boost is reduced (noticably and significantly), only when the intercooler temp reduces after forward motion (increased airflow through the IC) does max boost return

Much more than 1 second

So tell us then, being a Pratt, how do you drive

pslewis 05 September 2005 09:10 AM


Originally Posted by DPat
If you sit in traffic and the intercooler gets too warm then max boost is reduced (noticably and significantly), only when the intercooler temp reduces after forward motion (increased airflow through the IC) does max boost return

Much more than 1 second

So tell us then, being a Pratt, how do you drive

Let me guess??

You're the one on the far left in the nerd/geek photo above? right?? :rolleyes:

Pete

ScoobLou 05 September 2005 03:24 PM


Originally Posted by pslewis
Let me guess??

You're the one on the far left in the nerd/geek photo above? right?? :rolleyes:

Pete

This guy rocks are u single :lol:

turbo it 05 September 2005 06:27 PM


Originally Posted by pslewis
It actually adds that 0.25BHP increase to enable you to carry the water tank for the sprayer without any penalty over a car without one!!

Like I said .............. utterly pointless, but, if you feel good with it - why not??

Pete


thats bull believe me when your using the car on track on hot days it makes a massive diffrence to how the car performs, ive had mine mapped in to spray on charge temps etc and would typically use over a litre of water in a 15min session, but as ever in mho. cheers Rob


All times are GMT +1. The time now is 05:06 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands