I was debating this exact issue last fall before replacing my old K-style gutters. I was really sold on the concept of the one-piece covered system, but the "waterfall effect" was my biggest fear. I spent a lot of time reading through various
LeafGuard reviews to see if people in similar climates were complaining about overshoot. While the debris protection is undeniable, several owners noted that high-velocity water can bypass the opening if the installation angle isn't perfect. I ended up installing a wider 6-inch gutter with a high-flow mesh screen instead, just to handle the volume.