Offensive? - No, not until his recent comments.

Annoying? - Yes, constantly.

Does he add value to this site? - No, his comments provoke reaction, frustration and ultimately negativity.

Does he have an active interest in Subaru's - ?? Obvious answer? Think about it......

Should he be banned from this site? - It's is ultimately up to the Moderators to make that decision based upon Members feelings and opinions. Up until his recent and now notorious thread, he has been tolerated by the majority, disliked by a minority and possibly liked by a small minority. But the question that needs to be asked is how far can an individual be allowed to go before a Ban is is put in place? To his credit, Mycroft knows how far to push people. However, certain other Forums have still felt that he was too much of an annoyance and have banned him, that choice was down to the Community on the respective Forums. On this Forum he is allowed to go about his business of "winding up" people, usually people who don't really know him or who haven't been offended by him in the past, but for those who know of him, he is often just ignored. However, he has now posted a thread that has incited disgust, dis-belief and anger in many members of this Forum, and whilst some people can still tolerate this sort of thread and not be offended, this time too many members were upset by his comments. The true measure of Mycroft would have been for him to hold up his hands and apologise to the Forum members for over-stepping the mark, had he been forthcoming with this then most members would probably have accepted this and allowed him to carry on posting on this Forum. This has not happened and I doubt ever will....he has now been given licence to carry on regardless, which to many members will be very disappointing. Mycroft has always ran a fine line between entertainment and annoyance, he has now been allowed to overstep the mark.........

 

Hi Julesm

This has already been discussed.

Mycroft has been given another chance, which means just that. It does not need further discussion.

Thank you for your time on your post, but let's not kick it all off again.

All the best

Simon