I had this on another site. It was pretty good. Maybe it could be looked into.

Yeah, I love this idea.

But, we have to be very careful with it.

As can be seen (especially in a forum very close to this one! :D) there are some very bitter people in the world, who just love to slag things off / cause trouble.

Because of this, and simple legalities of libel, etc.. we would have to moderate it quite heavily, which would mean that it would be less valuable.

I'm open to suggestions as to how this could work though - as long as it doesn't leave scoobynet exposed to legal action, etc.

Thats fine, just wasn't sure if its been mentioned before now.
Unfortunately, I don't have any suggestions on how it could work.